State Aid Formula Said to Hurt in a District Where Most Go to Yeshivas
December 15, 2015 The New York Times
"A monitor chosen by Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo
Civil Rights and the East Ramapo School Board
December 10, 2014 “People
constantly confuse ‘direct democracy’ with ‘representative democracy’.
The United States
Bruce Levine's Response to Aron Wieder's Comments on Civil Rights in East Ramapo (here)
Robert Rhodes' Comments on the Public Relations Officer in East Ramapo (here)
Weissmandl’s Letter to Cuomo—Deceptive, Occasionally Delusional,
fiscal monitor, Hank Greenberg, had delivered his report on the
Back-Door School Vouchers: What Money and Block Voting Buy
Posted: 11/24/2014 "Multiple-choice quiz for groups and people who either endorsed or voted to reelect Andrew Cuomo.
What is Andrew Cuomo's top legislative priority now that he has been
reelected Governor of New York State?
Toward the end of the campaign, in a series of targeted, lightly publicized meetings, Cuomo's top legislative priority emerged.
It is rewarding campaign donors and block voting by religious communities with a back-door school vouchers plan for private
and religious schools." (More)
State: E. Ramapo board may be on hook for legal fees
December 2, 2014 "Current
and former East Ramapo school board members could one day be made to
return some of
Ed Day blasts proposed Ramapo zone change
November 30, 2014 "Opponents
of a proposed zone change that could accommodate more than 200
apartments near the
State sets training deadlines for East Ramapo leaders
State will require diversity, open meetings law training for school board by winter
November 26, 2014 "State
education officials aren't waiting for the Legislature to draft an East
Ramapo schools oversight
East Ramapo legal costs 'absurd,' monitor says
November 25, 2014 "State fiscal monitor Hank Greenberg gave authoritative
backing last week to the critics who've long
East Ramapo sells Hillcrest for use as yeshiva again
November 25, 2014 "It's
the second time in about four years the property has been sold to Avir
Yakov by the district, where
Crafting East Ramapo 'watchdog' bill no easy feat
November 23, 2014 "Early
support is building for state oversight of the East Ramapo school
district, but pressure is on Rockland
November 21, 2044 The
Huffington Post "I
do not make accusations of racism lightly. I am not talking about
East Ramapo School Board Is Criticized by New York State Monitor
NOV. 17, 2014 The New York Times
appointed by the state to investigate the
State Calls for East Ramapo Watchdog
Schools need long-term entitiy with veto power over board decisions
state-appointed fiscal monitor of the East Ramapo school district wants
a legislative intervention that would
Orange & Rockland seeks $34-a-month rate hike
customers would see their electric and natural gas bills increase by an
average of more than $34 per month
United Water's Hudson plant, surcharge request denied
November 14, 2014 "The
state has ruled there is no current need for additional water supply for
Rockland County, halting United
Frank Sparaco charged with falsifying GOP petitions
County Legislator Frank Sparaco was arrested and charged Monday
afternoon with more than three dozen
Suffern probes retired treasurer's accounting practices
Suffern probes retired treasurer while stripping him of medical coverage.
village is investigating its accounting practices under a recently
retired village treasurer who served for the
Un-neighborly: Clarkstown blasts Ramapo high-density zone
Clarkstown opposes Ramapo's proposed zoning change that would allow multifamily homes.
November 9, 2013
officials are expressing anger about housing proposals they fear would
allow more than 2,000 people to move
Ramapo must appeal ward ruling by Dec. 3
November 6, 2014
fate of the town's controversial ward referendum could be decided sooner
than expected as the state Supreme Court
Supervisor’s Budget for 2015 Raises Questions of Favoritism
November 6th, 2014
Posted in The Rockland County Times
"The proposed 2015 budget for the Town of Ramapo, submitted by
Ramapo has 6 months to appeal ward vote decision
October 25, 2014 "Voters
may not learn the status of the controversial ward referendum until next
spring, as the town has up to six months to
Developers' influence in Ramapo
October 24, 2014
Many Journal News subscribers have read about Ramapo Democratic Party
Chairwoman Mona Montal's remarkable request for
Upper Saddle River awarded nearly $1 million in sewage lawsuit
October 21, 2014
"A federal court judge awarded Upper Saddle River nearly $1 million from
a Rockland County sewer authority for sewage spills
Stressed or 'scare tactic'? Examining Ramapo's financial audit
October 24, 2014
audit report, prepared for the town by O'Connor Davies LLP, stated that
cash assets in the police fund were about $3.2 million
State investigates United Water after VP's departure
state has launched an investigation to determine if the actions of three
United Water New York workers terminated
Government Files Suit Against Kiryas Joel Slaughterhouse
Charges Processing Facility with discharging animal waste into Ramapo River tributaries--Fine is $330,000
October 23, 2014
U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara stated: “For years, the defendants flouted
the law by repeatedly discharging waste from their
East Ramapo apology 'not enough,' Latino protesters say
October 23, 2014
fourth night of protests by the Latino community and supporters resulted
in a personal apology from the East Ramapo
Kaser: Fire-damaged house awaits inspection
Fire officials say they found possibly a dozen illegally converted units on Sunday
October 20, 2014
village's building inspector said Monday that he's has not yet been able
to inspect a Cedar Lane apartment building
Monitor Hank Greenberg Questions East Ramapo Compliance on immigrant rights
October 20, 2014
former federal prosecutor who is monitoring East Ramapo schools
questioned the district's "understanding of and
After Months Delay Klein Decides to Apologize to Hispanic Community
Ocotober 18, 2014 "After
two months of protests, East Ramapo schools Superintendent Joel Klein
has apologized for suggesting that the
Developer pulls Suffern apartment plan; tax deal stalls
October 14, 2014
developer seeking a controversial zone change in Suffern has withdrawn
its application after failing to negotiate a tax
East Ramapo: Klein's dropout remarks prompt new protests
October 12, 2014
angry and they're not going away. It's the message being sent from
hundreds of Latino students who attend East Ramapo
October 10, 2014
Like many other modern political scandals,
the ones in this report first
Journal News Editorial--Ramapo's appeal shakes voter faith
10, 2014 "Ramapo's
Town Board should stop its appeal of a state Supreme Court judge's
Ramapo says judge prematurely voided referendum vote
October 10, 2014
is arguing a state judge should have waited until votes were counted
before deciding to void the referendum
Judge Tosses All the Returns of
the Ward Referendum Vote -- Cites Clerk Sampsons'
October 7, 2014 "State
Supreme Court Justice Margaret Garvey on Tuesday invalidated Ramapo's
referendums on establishing a ward
Assemblyman Ken Zebrowski Is
Drafting Legislation to Prevent a Repeat
October 4, 2014 "In
light of chaos
and reports of corruption during Ramapo's referendums,
Assemblyman Kenneth Zebrowski
CBS News Coverage of
Click here to view report
October 1, 2014
BY Melissa Gerr of the Baltimore Jewish Times
Response to Impounded Ballots Posted by County Executive Ed Day
yesterday's ward system vote held by the Town of Ramapo ... In response
to a number of substantive messages
Supreme Court Judge Orders all Ramapo Ballots Be Impounded
September 30, 2014 Michael Parietti and
Robert Romanowski successfully argued in Rockland Supreme Court that
there were serious irregularities
Ramapo Town Clerk
Refuses to Answer Questions about
The First Job for a New Town Board Will Be to Cut Payroll
September 28, 2014
If we elect a new town board in November of 2015 its first job
will be to stop the incredible abuse of our tax payers.
Letter: Ramapo ward system ensures protection for all
September 28, 2014
A ward system for Ramapo would ensure minority representation,
and goes to the heart of the Voting Rights Act's
Councilwoman Brendel Charles reports that she has written to the
Department of Justice with concerns that a ward system
State Reps Slam St. Lawrence's Banning Poll Watchers
September 27, 2014
All three local state
representatives condemned the Supervisor's refusal to allow
independent poll watchers
Read Press Release from Robert Rhodes regarding the ban here
Poll Watchers Barred from Ward Referendum Vote Scheduled for
September 25, 2014
The Ramapo political machine spent two years fighting tooth and
nail to prevent a ward referendum in Ramapo.
Ward system allows fair representation
We've had "at large" elections in Ramapo offices for many years,
and where has that
E. Ramapo uses Albany lobbying firm for PR
September 25, 2014 "The
East Ramapo school district is on track to spend at least
$49,000 this year
Anger and Paranoia at Ramapo Town Hall
This article is in response to the bizarre disingenuous recent
press release issued by Ramapo Democratic
East Ramapo contingent takes concerns over cuts to fiscal monitor
September 23, 2014 "The longest writing assignment Olivia
Castor had during her senior year at Spring
Community View: Ward System Benefits all Ramapo CommunitiesSeptember18, 2014 A recent article in The Journal News suggested that the Ramapo Ward Referendum
scheduled for September 30 is motivated by the desire “to counter the political influence of Ramapo’s growing
Orthodox community.” This characterization is not fair. The unfortunate fact is that Supervisor Christopher
St. Lawrence has become a petty dictator who has made our religious community hostage to his irresponsible
conduct. His incompetent rule is an example of why democracy is necessary for honest and efficient government.(More)
East Ramapo shuns immigrant students
September 14, 2014 "East
Ramapo is a very diverse school district. People from all over
the world live here,
Rockland primaries: Fonvil, Stein, Zebrowski win—Wieder Loses
Valley Village Trustee Vilair Fonvil, leader of a board majority
that has stood against
LoHud Primary vote totals: Rockland, Westchester, Putnam
Cuomo Defeats Teachout, Liberal Rival, in the Democratic Primary
Sept. 9, 2014
“Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo of New York claimed the Democratic
nomination for a second term on Tuesday,
Lawsuit Details Systemic Corruption
September 4, 2014 When you read the
lawsuit summons, several themes emerge. St. Lawrence’s
Immigrants decry East Ramapo chief's dropout comments
2014 "A crowd of immigrant students and their families rallied
Tuesday night in a show of opposition to what
Another Smelly Deal in Ramapo
Letter in Our
Town September 2, 2014 The Ramapo Town Board has just voted
to give the developers of a luxury housing
Clarkstown poised to pass term limits for elected officials
August 30, 2014 "Term
limits are close to being approved in Clarkstown, potentially the first
town in Rockland County to enact
Tax Watch: Ramapo Central fights $16M tax deal
August 29, 2014 "The
school board met Tuesday in response to the Town of Ramapo's decision
last week to impose the tax deal
Ramapo's deal for Suffern development binds schools
August 26, 2014 "A
luxury apartment project has been handed a tax break by the Town of
Ramapo that also lowers its school taxes
Thanks all who came out to support our candidates
Ramapo Taxes to Increase 26% in 2014
St. Lawrence Prevents Release of Documents until After the ElectionOctober 31, 2013 The Town of Ramapo Tentative Budget for Fiscal Year Ending December 31, 2014, has the numbers that reveal what the tax increase
Suffern Trustee and Mayoral Candidate Charles Falciglia responds to attacks
Trustee and Preserve Rockland Mayoral Candidate, Charles Falciglia,
continues to be the target of his three opponents, with attacks
that have now devolved into just good old fashioned lying. “You have this small cabal of career candidates who have been around forever
and who have no positive message or vision for Suffern. The spinning has now reached the point of being delusional.” (More)
Candidate Koplen's Really Bad Week
The story of the Preserve-Ghanistan-Gate Scandal
Oct. 31, 2013 Rockland County Times "Michael Koplen, New Hempstead village trustee, former county legislator, and GOP candidate
Slams St. Lawrence, Claims Ramapo Is Not Forthcoming on Finances
October 31st, 2013 The Rockland County Times Preserve Ramapo has been asking the town of Ramapo and the Ramapo Local Development Corporation
for their year-end financial statements since the summer and we have been told repeatedly that they are not yet available. Just another St. Lawrence
lie. On October 15 they were released to the national site that reports information on bonds, municipal and others. Now Ramapo is holding off on its
public hearing on next year’s budget until after the election. If last year is any guide we will have a public hearing without knowing our finances
for 2013. (More)
Jaffee and Carlucci Back Down on their Support for Tax Exempt Status for Illegal Yeshiva
October 31, 2013
legislators from Rockland said Wednesday they will urge the governor
to reject their bill offering a retroactive tax
exemption to a congregation that illegally converted a single-family house into a school on Highview Road. Assemblywoman Ellen Jaffee, D-Suffern,
and state Sen. David Carlucci, D-New City, said they backed off support for the 2011 exemption for the Talmud Torah Ohr Yochanan because it had
zoning violations and no certificate of occupancy. Jaffee also said there were other issues. The students are being taught in the four-bedroom house,
including on the second floor in violation of zoning, and in two classroom trailers. The Assembly and Senate approved the bill for Gov. Andrew
Cuomo’s signature." Read the entire Journal News article here.
Legislator Aron Weider Bashes Cops to Win Hasidic Community Support for David Fried
October 31, 2013 "Rockland
County Legislator Aron Weider has been discovered to be
bashing police in an effort to push David Fried
to the Hasidic community, using a phone-based news and information network to conduct Yiddish-language outreach as a surrogate of
David Fried. (More)
"Town of Ramapo is on notice. Clean up your act before being party to a mass fatal fire.
Stop playing politics with people’s lives."
October 27, 2013 In a letter to the Journal News, the Chairman
of the Rockland County Illegal Housing Task Force accuses
Christopher St. Lawrence
and other politicians with risking lives in the community for votes: "Ramapo is a ticking time bomb and this fire is just the tip of the iceberg. We’re
getting nothing from the town but lip service from the supervisor and building officials in an election year. The only one who seems to care is the
town’s head fire inspector. If the town is going to continue with its policy of granting permissions after the fact and ignoring violations, it’s time
for a higher authority to step in." Read the letter here.
Illegal Mismanagement of Millions
by the Ramapo Five
October 26, 2013 With the publication
of the audited 2012 Financial
Statement, there is evidence that Ramapo Supervisor St. Lawrence
and his four board members, Friedman, Ullman, Logan and Withers,
have taken $2.9 million from five different funds and never repaid
these loans as required by law. Most surprising is that they continue
to violate municipal law while stooping beneath the cloud of a
wide-ranging FBI criminal investigation. (More)
East Ramapo parent appeals to state over lack of music, art instructionOctober 24, 2013 "The parent of a third-grade student is appealing to the state education commissioner over what he claims is a complete
Fire breaks out at Ramapo house tied to disputed yeshiva on Highview RoadOctober 24, 2013 "A 13-year-old girl suffered smoke inhalation Wednesday after a fire broke out at a building next door to a yeshiva
October 22, 2012 "B&H
Photo & Electronics Corp., the nation’s largest non-chain
photographic equipment vendor, is considering
moving its Brooklyn warehouse and Rockland County is an option. In December a limited liability corporation affiliated with B&H,
Chestnut Ridge Venture of 390 Berry St. in Brooklyn, bought the Edwin Gould Foundation for Children property in Chestnut Ridge for
$9.3 million. Jacobowitz confirmed that Chestnut Ridge Venture is affiliated with B&H, but he added that B&H’s owners have many
businesses and the property could be used for some other purpose." Journal News story here.
October 13, 2013
The accusations in an
FBI criminal complaint seem fantastic: a ring of thugs violently
extorted religious divorce
agreements from recalcitrant husbands in the observant Jewish community. The price for their services? Tens of thousands of dollars,
according to an FBI criminal complaint. Threats, beatings and even a cattle prod were employed, according to FBI documents, but
the men aimed at leaving no physical mark. Insular communities often 'protect' themselves by trying to handle conflicts internally.
That leaves their own members as prey to criminal acts. The community cannot look the other way. Neither can local law enforcement
agencies, no matter the pressures. The FBI probe demonstrates the risks. Full Journal editorial here.
Two responses to the editorial: The "Insular Community" Euphemism, and The Criminals Using Slander here
FBI Raids Monsey Yeshiva--Arrests Two Rabbis
October 10, 2013
Defendant Rabbi Mendel Epstein spoke about kidnapping, beating and
torturing husbands in
order to force a divorce. He stated, “Suppose we, ya know this is an expensive thing to do. It’s not simply;
we’re talking, uh, I don’t want to use the, the terms but, basically what we are going to be doing is kidnapping
the guy for a couple of hours and beating him up and torturing him and then getting him to give the get. We take
an electric cattle prod. You put it in certain parts of his body and in one minute the guy will know.” (From the
Federal Criminal Complaint) (More)
No Memory--No Shame
October 10, 2013
From the long list of
personality disorders that professional politicians are prone to,
of an intentionally faulty memory and shamelessness is particularly annoying. A recent example of this kind of
brainless shameless behavior involved a whole group of local political recognizables. (More)
"Preserving Rockland": A 10-Point Plan to Stop Irresponsible Overdevelopment
October 9, 2013 Here's
the press release and a link to the details of Ed Day's plan to
bring some sort of sanity to the problem of
overdevelopment in Ramapo and Rockland. Read the overview in the press release here and then link to the details linked to
on Ed's website.
State judge shuts Nanuet religious school over safety concerns
October 4, 2013
congregation has been ordered by a state judge to close down
portions of its religious school at the former
Singer’s Hotel and Caterers due to safety and zoning violations found by Clarkstown inspectors. Inspectors found numerous violations including
exposed and improper wiring, more than 100 feet of missing sheet rock and missing or damaged tiles designed to reduce the spread of fire, problems
with fire sprinklers, and debris and garbage, according to court documents. The inspectors also found additional violations of the state fire code and
Clarkstown codes concerning some fire doors and other fire suppression equipment, documents state. Congregation Lizensk, which faces numerous
violations on its schools in Ramapo, runs the Clarkstown school for up to 180 students and 50 dormitory rooms for up to three students each on the
campus at 100 S. Central Ave., Nanuet, just outside the village of Spring Valley." Full text of The Journal News coverage here.
An Accountant, an Auditor, and the Attorney with Amnesia—Melissa Reimer’s
Disciplinary Hearing Final Session
October 3, 2013 The Town of Ramapo’s
hearing concerning its disciplinary action taken against
Reimer resumed Monday morning at 10:15 and ran through the day until after 4 pm. Three witnesses were cross-examined:
a partner with the auditing firm O’Connor Davies; an accountant working in the Ramapo finance department; and Town
Attorney Michael Klein. (More)
Judge: Federal suit against East Ramapo officials can proceed
September 30, 2013 "A
federal judge allowed key claims in a lawsuit against current and
former East Ramapo school officials to move forward
Monday, even as she dismissed most other claims. Judge Cathy Seibel gave life to a much smaller, but potentially revealing class-action lawsuit
against a dozen defendants, who had sought to have the claims against them dismissed. The lawsuit can now confront several of the most divisive
issues in East Ramapo, including the placement of Hasidic and other Orthodox students in private special-education schools at public expense, the
alleged purchase of religious textbooks for private schools, and whether the school board tried to sell two schools at below-market rates. She also
allowed the lawsuit to look at whether the school board hired Long Island-based lawyer Albert D’Agostino in 2009 as part of a conspiracy to place
special-education students in private schools in a manner that forfeits state reimbursements." Complete Journal News story here.
In the Fiscal Race to the Bottom Rockland
Plunges Past Ramapo to Dead Last in the State
September 27, 2013 In a press release
issued Wednesday from the Office of the Comptroller, Thomas
DiNapoli announced the updated list for the most fiscally stressed towns, cities and counties in the
State of New York. If the results were bad for Ramapo and Rockland in the Spring, they were even
worse with the updated numbers. (More)
Federal prosecutors target Spring Valley officials' pensions in corruption casesSep. 20, 2013 10:44 AM "Federal prosecutors have moved to eliminate government pensions for two Spring Valley board members and other
Community View: Owners profit as illegal housing poses many dangers in Ramapo
2013 "Does anyone care about that there are reckless landlords
that profit from their illegal housing/ construction
that is running rampant in the town of Ramapo and its surrounding villages in a Wild West environment, where almost anything goes
in building and zoning? When violators are fined, town and village courts repeatedly reduce the amounts to the equivalent of a slap on
the wrist, which is often seen as the cost of doing business. The landlords keep making more money, groups continue to build illegal schools
in single-family homes, and tenants, students and firefighters are put in harm’s way." Read the full text of Rabbi Justin Schwartz's Community
"You do not have to do the right thing here, you have to play
make the supervisor happy." (Nat Oberman, Ramapo Collector of Taxes)
August 30, 2013 The disciplinary
hearings against Ramapo employee Melissa Reimer resumed on Tuesday,
30, 2013 "People
connected to Clarkstown businessman Richard Brega, including his
relatives and employees, have donated at
least $48,000 to a Rockland County executive candidate, The Journal News has found. State records released Friday show an additional
$12,000 from associates of Brega, who is in line for a $70 million county bus contract.The money went to the campaign war chest of
County Legislator Ilan Schoenberger, who is running in the Sept. 10 Democratic primary. The Journal News reported on the initial donations
Thursday.The three most recent contributions were made Aug. 14, the largest coming from Brega’s father-in-law, Aniello Feola of Thiells,
who gave $6,000.Feola’s wife told a reporter Friday that the family would have no comment. Feola is the 10th person with direct links to Brega
that The Journal News has identified as having given $4,000 or more to Schoenberger." Read the article here.
August 28, 2013 "An
illegally subdivided townhouse was found at a housing complex owned
by the president of the East
Ramapo Board of Education, village housing inspectors said Wednesday. Walls were built to add three apartments to one of the
eight townhouses at 29 Bethune Blvd., officials said. The three-story building is owned by Yehuda Weissmandl through his company,
Prestige Builders of 1 Koritz Way, New Square, officials said. Booker said the owner will face violations of construction without a
permit, occupancy of uninhabitable space in the basement, and occupancy without a certificate of occupancy for the added rooms.
Weissmandl, a son of the late New Square village administrator, has been school board president since the spring in a district rocked by
financial and social controversies. Weissmandl came under criticism before getting elected to the school board when he tore down a
fence separating New Square from Hillcrest Elementary School. He claimed at the time that a storm tore down the fencing and trees.
Read the full story on LoHud here.
St. Lawrence Administration Picks up another
"Worst in the State"—Highest Average Salaries in NYS
August 25, 2013 The Empire Center issued a press release
Thursday announcing that their
data for municipal salaries throughout the state has been published in the 2012-2013 edition
of What They Make. And once again, at the very top of the list, in the nation’s third-most
populous state of 19.47 million, the Town of Ramapo has the most onerous totals for cost
of local government. (More)
The Melissa Reimer Disciplinary Hearing—Part Two
slow beginning, with only a single witness called in the first
hearing, the Monday continuance of the
Town of Ramapo Disciplinary Hearing against Melissa Reimer produced some interesting developments. Among the more notable:
Aaron Troodler forgot for whom he works, now there are two Apples that are problematic, the town wants all those recordings,
on the video Linda Condon made a wrong turn, and Michael Klein is still fighting to keep out of sight. And there were some new
questions: who’s got the iPhones, were Mona Montal and Pat Withers working on election materials in a Town of Ramapo office
after hours, why did Michael Specht bring in that video without reviewing all of it, and who was the suit sitting in the back of
the room taking notes? (More)
hearings: Ramapo’s ‘Night at the Opera’
Letter published in Our Town August 21, 2013
week I attended a comedy at Ramapo Town Hall. It was a tremendous
performance. But sadly it will have a tragic
ending for Ramapo taxpayers. (More)
Rockland, state must rescue the kids of East Ramapo
August 15, 2013 "Reduced pre-K,
schools being shuttered and sold off for losses, dropping test
kindergarten, cuts to BOCES technical programs, increased class sizes, canceled extracurricular programs,
distressingly low graduation rates — these kids are suffering from a series of deprivations that simply cannot
be tolerated." Read the full text of the Community View by Ed Day here.
August 7, 2013 "Critics
argue the law itself is the problem. Thanks to town law and policy,
schools like those at 95-97 Highview Road,
49 College Road, 50 College Road and 5 Lane St. are allowed to continue operating for years — while collecting thousands of dollars
in tuition fees — without approvals. Some have expanded with town-permitted classroom trailers while awaiting approvals. The policy
deems a house is like a classroom trailer and can be used temporarily for up to two years while a school is built. Residents and firefighters
say the system gives de facto approval for new structures without environmental reviews or public input. “If people think they can get
away with operating illegally, they will,” said Bob Doerr, who lives on Highview Road. “The problem is the Town of Ramapo.” Journal
News story here.
August 7, 2013 "Calling
for a “regime change” and an end to political favoritism believed to
plague town government, a group of
more than 100 Ramapo residents rallied at Town Hall on Tuesday. Many of the ralliers support the grass-roots political group Preserve
Ramapo, which has criticized Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence’s land use and development policies and has long tried to oust him
from office. The Rev. Weldon McWilliams IV, of the grass-roots group Wake Up Rockland, led the crowd in chants of “a community united
will never be divided.” Opposition to town-sanctioned zoning changes that many believe favor the town’s increasingly large ultra-Orthodox
Jewish population isn’t an issue of religious discrimination, he said, in a reference to an argument frequently voiced by members of the
ultra-Orthodox community.“I don’t care what your religion is — if your value system is to exploit the community, I want you out of the way,”
he shouted. “This has nothing to do with religion.” Several ralliers, including McWilliams, are running for office on the Preserve Ramapo slate
with hopes of representing the town of Ramapo or the village of Spring Valley next year. The approaching election has created more tension
than usual as town officials remain the subject of an FBI investigation into financial practices after federal authorities raided Town Hall in May."
Read the complete Journal News story here.
August 4, 2013 "Steeper
fines and a crackdown on reckless landlords are needed to stop the
proliferation of illegally altered housing in
Ramapo and Spring Valley, frustrated inspectors and fire officials say. Half of all illegal-housing complaints countywide come from the
town and village, a Journal News analysis found. The housing is dangerous to tenants and emergency responders, yet municipal enforcement
is sporadic and penalties far too soft, officials and volunteer firefighters said in numerous interviews with The Journal News between May
and July. They say the problem is especially pronounced in Ramapo, which one county fire official characterized as “the Wild West, where
almost anything goes.”
department: "[Anthony] Mallia and Ramapo town lawyers responsible
for prosecuting violations argue that Kryger, Wren and the task
volunteers exaggerate the extent of violations and dangers." That's the same legal department that was recently visited by FBI agents, and
computer drives and documents were carted out, over a span of about eight hours." Please read the entirety of this important and wide-ranging
investigative report here on the LoHud website.
August 2, 2013 "Melissa
Reimer’s stealthy iPad recordings of her interviews with town
officials as she faced misconduct charges
in January — and what’s contained in those recordings — are a focal point in a second disciplinary hearing that began Thursday as
Reimer faces possible punitive action by the town, including termination. [Lichtmacher, her lawyer, insists], “We’re not here because
of things Melissa Reimer did. We’re here because of things Melissa Reimer would not do,” he said. “We’re here because she’s a truth teller.”
The town, he argued, is looking for any excuse to fire Reimer because she complained about what she believed were illegal activities
within town government. Lichtmacher said Reimer’s complaints targeted Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence, who serves as the town’s
finance director, among others. When she brought her concerns to Finkelstein and another town attorney, Janice Gittelman, she was
laughed at and told to quit her job, Lichtmacher said. He has not elaborated on the details of the complaints but indicated Reimer
questioned town finance practices in the period before federal authorities raided Town Hall in May and took financial documents
as part of a continuing FBI investigation. Other witnesses, including Reimer, are expected to testify when the hearing resumes
Aug. 12." Complete story on LoHud here.
Where in the World is Governor Cuomo?
July 31, 2013 "What is in the water cooler at the Long
Island-based law firm of Minerva & D’Agostino? Attorneys for the
which was hired in 2009 to represent the East Ramapo School District ("ERSD"), have engaged in a pattern of bullying, intimidation
and unprofessional conduct toward the parents and students of the district." (More)
July 31, 2013
controversial sale of an East Ramapo school building in 2010 to an
religious congregation was based on a falsified appraisal report that undervalued the building and
netted the appraiser $8,500, according to a state Attorney General’s investigation into the troubled
school district. The appraiser, Avi M. Vardi, 57, was arraigned Wednesday in Clarkstown Justice Court
on charges of grand larceny and filing a false instrument, both felonies. He was released on his own
recognizance. Vardi was arrested by Attorney General Eric Schneiderman’s office as that office continues
a more than 18-month investigation into the district’s real estate deals involving the former Hillcrest and Colton elementary school
buildings.Vardi was hired by the school board’s attorney to provide the appraisal after an unidentified board member emailed Vardi’s
cellphone number and other contact information to the attorney, according to the complaint. The complaint goes on to state that Vardi
later asked for and received $3,500 from the district, which paid him “acting on the false understanding” that Vardi had provided an
independent appraisal. Vardi was also allegedly paid $5,000 by Avir Yakov. County Legislator Aron Wieder, who was the school board’s
vice president at the time of the appraisal. Wieder supported the closure and sale of the school." Complete Journal News coverage here.
You can read the original appraisal drawn up by Vardi here.
July 31, 2013 How broke is Ramapo? According to
the New York State Comptroller Ramapo is the most financially
917 towns in New York State. But what does that actually mean? (More)
Daily Scratch Sheet for Several Local Races
July 23, 2013 The following
scratches were reported in The Journal News. In Spring
Valley, two candidates for Mayor were removed
from the list. "The Rockland County Board of Elections invalidated the petitions of Spring Valley Village Trustee Joseph Gross and village
parks and recreation employee Bernard Charles Jr., which eliminates them from the ballot." In Spring Valley the number of valid signatures
needed is 364. In the race for County Executive where 2000 signatures are needed, "Vladimir Leon is no longer a candidate for the primary
after problems with his petitions left many of them invalid." And David Fried, who is a candidate in the primary, "filed specific objections to
petitions filed by Suffern Mayor Dagan Lacorte. Fried is challenging the valididty of 3,337 of Lacorte's total of 4,435 signatures on various
grounds." The matter has not yet been resolved.
Spring Valley marchers seek justice in Trayvon Martin killing
July 21, 2013
of people called for justice Saturday as they protested the fatal
Trayvon Martin and the laws and cultural disconnect that they say allowed his killer to go free. “It is
unfair to charge a young black boy with his own murder,” the Rev. Weldon McWilliams IV said. “What
do we want? Justice. When do we want it? Now.” McWilliams organized a march that started in front
of Spring Valley Village Hall, proceeded down Route 45 and ended with a rally at Memorial Park.
It was one of dozens called for in cities across the nation Saturday." Read The Journal News story
with video coverage here. Additional photos of the March appear on Len Tsou's Picasa page here.
No, the Glass is not Half FullJuly 19, 2013 Last night, the Winnipeg Goldeyes played the Rockland Boulders in a game at Provident Bank
Spring Valley corruption case trial possible as soon as January
July 19, 2013 "As
he faces federal bribery-related charges and potential trial in
January, Spring Valley Deputy Mayor Joseph Desmaret
has resigned his job with the town of Ramapo where he had been suspended pending a civil service hearing. Desmaret resigned his town
job last week to concentrate on the federal charges of mail fraud and Hobbs Act extortion — a case that could go to trial next year, his
lawyer, Kenneth Gribetz, said. Desmaret was supended on a town misconduct charge from his $55,000-a-year job as a data clerk with the
Ramapo Tax Assessor’s Office. He had been suspended shortly after being arrested on the federal charges. The job was in addition to his
village deputy mayor post, which he still holds, with a $25,750 salary. He has not resigned from his elected office. At a federal court
appearance Friday attended by Jasmin, Desmaret and city officials in White Plains, the judge set a date of Dec. 13 for a discussion among
defense lawyers and prosecutors on scheduling a trial as early as January 2014." Journal News story here.
United Water desal plant faces review over supply needs
July 18, 2013 "The
state will review United Water New York’s proposed Hudson River
treatment plant to determine whether it is needed to
satisfy Rockland County’s long-term water supply requirements.The state Public Service Commission also said Thursday that the review would
require United Water to consider the most recent information about the county’s supply in a report relating to the need for a new supply source.
Word of the commission’s review brought praise from activists who question the current need for the plant. George Potanovic, a founder of
the Rockland Water Coalition, said he hoped the PSC would give the hard look needed regarding supply, conservation and the choice of projects
to add to the supply." Journal News story here.
Stonewalling in Ramapo
July 13, 2013
What do you do when the
numbers are so bad you can’t
let the public know? Well, in Ramapo there’s
three-point plan put in place by Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence. It’s a “hide ‘em, denied ‘em, fired ‘em” full
coverage plan for all occasions. (More)
State education chief blocks East Ramapo school lease to yeshiva
State: E. Ramapo didn't take steps to get best dealJuly 16, 2013 "The state Education Department on Tuesday upheld a petition by an East Ramapo public school parent to nullify the current lease
July 9, 2013 "The
United States Department of Education, New York Office for Civil
Rights is now investigating the East Ramapo Central School
District based on a discrimination complaint that alleges that special needs students were discriminated against based upon disability on three
separate occasions during the past school year." (More)
July 9, 2013 "For the second time in two weeks, Ramapo Councilwoman Brendel Logan’s 23-year-old son has been arrested.
July 9, 2013 "It could be weeks, months or longer before the East Ramapo school district is ready to part ways with its controversial
July 8, 2013 "Less
than a week after an East Ramapo school district attorney’s
outburst went viral, the school board decided Monday night to split from his controversial law
firm and transition to a new one. The board, meeting at district headquarters Monday, made
the move in response to the outburst from Christopher Kirby, an attorney with Minerva & D’Agostino
of Long Island, who was recorded on video yelling obscenities at a group of parents and threatening
to fight one."
The Rev. Weldon
McWilliams led a chant of “Are you with me?” and elicited responses
of “Yes!” from
the 100 or so gathered outside.
Read the complete Journal News coverage here.
Jul. 7, 2013 "East Ramapo school board President Yehuda Weissmandl should get to know a little more about his district and the
Preserve Ramapo/Preserve Rockland Candidates Demand Removal of
School Board's Legal Firm Minerva & D'Agostino
July 5, 2013
Immediate termination of the contract with Minerva &
D'Agostino is the only acceptable remedy to this hideous display of
contempt towards the parents, supporters and students of East Ramapo. The School Board should look to retain a legal firm with a
reasonable rate structure and a reputation for competence, integrity and respect, rather than a simple track record of enabling the
subjugation of the needs of public school students to those of the private schools. (Full text of the Press Release here)
Assemblywoman Jaffee says, “The
ERCSD Board should terminate the contract with
Minerva and D'Agostino now.”
July 5, 2013 Assemblywoman Ellen Jaffee joins David Carlucci demanding that the Board fire the D'Agostino law firm. Read the press relesase.
Why D’Agostino has to Go, Too
July 3, 2013
Not only has East Ramapo
attorney Albert D’Agostino cursed out an honor student at a
Ramapo Attorney Erupts at Board Meeting—Physically Threatens
one Parent, Mocks Another and Spews Obscenities at a Group of others
The Journal News, Senator David Carlucci, County Exec Candidate Ed
Day, and the National
Organization of Women call for the immediate firing of the D’Agostino law firm
July 3, 2013
last night’s East Ramapo School Board meeting, the Board’s attorney,
Christopher Kirby, from
the Minerva & D’Agostino firm from Long Island, exploded with an obscenity-laced rant against one parent and
physically threatened another. Police were called and charges were filed against Kirby who left the parking
lot before the police arrived. Today, the list of individuals and organizations calling for the immediate dismissal of the law firm continues to
June 28, 2013 "They walked single-file into the bustling
kosher grocery, calmly surveyed the aisles, and chose their items. A
bag of potato chips.
A bottle of water. One by one, they lined up at the cash registers, made their purchases and stepped aside quietly. Busy with their shopping, Hasidic
men and women in conservative dress paused to eye the group of 25 local activists — black, white, young, old, wearing shorts and T-shirts and jeans — and
wondered what was happening. A few minutes later, the disgruntled store owner appeared, tried to block news photographers’ cameras and steered the
demonstrators toward the door. “You have no right to do this. Get out of here,” he said. The “stop and shop” demonstration Friday afternoon at Rockland
Kosher Supermarket off Route 306 was the kickoff event by a new group called Wake Up Rockland. Organizers said their purpose is to “combat the growing
phenomenon of de facto segregation” between Hasidic and non-Hasidic communities in Rockland County, specifically in the East Ramapo Central School
District. “We’re basically saying to the Hasidic community that we are here and we’re not going anywhere, so it behooves both of us to coexist,” said the
Rev. Weldon McWilliams IV, who organized the demonstration. “But the way things are, we can’t coexist.” The complete Journal News story here.
Ward Petition Update: June 27The town of Ramapo has notified Judge Garvey that they are seeking permission from the appellate division to appeal all of her recent
Newsday: Spring Valley Deputy Mayor Desmaret talks plea with
aid Rockland probes, sources say
June 26, 2013
"Spring Valley Deputy Mayor Joseph Desmaret is negotiating a plea
deal with federal prosecutors that would require him
to be a cooperating witness for the government in two public corruption probes in Rockland County, Newsday has learned. Desmaret,
55, was indicted April 18 along with five other political figures, including Spring Valley Mayor Noramie Jasmin, in a complex bribery scheme
involving a proposed community center in Spring Valley as well as the New York City mayoral race. Desmaret and his lawyer Kenneth Gribetz
met for several hours Tuesday afternoon with federal prosecutors and FBI agents at the U.S. attorney's office in White Plains to discuss the
terms of a possible plea deal, multiple sources familiar with the case told Newsday. "Desmaret has no choice, really. He has to plead guilty.
The video and audio they have against him is damning," said one source familiar with the case." Full Newsday coverage here.
Just How Bad is the Financial Mess in Ramapo?
June 25, 2013How about the worst in the State of New York? The Office of the Comptroller follows
Ward Update—Another Win in court
Judge Garvey Tosses All Four St. Lawrence Motions Opposing the Ward System Initiative
June 24, 2013 The Preserve Ramapo
fight to grant the voters of Ramapo the right to decide whether they
want a Ward System will
move forward as Supreme Court Judge Margaret Garvey threw out St. Lawrence’s objections to the petitions. A ward system would
allow voters to elect representatives from their own districts, who would represent them on the Ramapo Town Board. The current
system has a panel of at large rubber stamps who have allowed St. Lawrence to decimate the finances of the Town and destroy
the zoning. (More)
Community View: Ramapo must reveal latest audits
June 23, 2013 "The
public has a right to know just what is going on. To clear this up,
the Town of Ramapo should immediately put its
Independent Financial Audit online for all to see or explain why it does not have this audit ready for review at this time. The towns of
Orangetown and Clarkstown already have put this information online for its residents to see. Previously, Ramapo has released independent
audits through Freedom of Information requests but the town has not released the audit for fiscal year 2012. Why not? What we do know
about the town’s fiscal condition at the closing of its books at the end of 2012 is hardly reassuring." Read Bruce Levine's analysis of what
it might be that the town is hiding.
Suspended Ramapo finance worker plans to sue, says town retaliated
June 21, 2013 "A
town Finance Department employee who’s been suspended from her job
says she was falsely accused of misconduct in
retaliation for speaking up about alleged “criminal” acts by Ramapo officials and plans to sue the town. Melissa Reimer, the town’s supervisor
of fiscal services, referred comment to her lawyer, Fred Lichtmacher, who declined to elaborate on the alleged criminal acts. But Lichtmacher
said Friday that Reimer plans to sue the town for $2 million in damages for defamation in her community, emotional injury and harm to her
professional reputation. According to a notice of claim sent to the town, officials retaliated against Reimer after she complained about “criminal,
deceitful and inappropriate acts and omissions by several members” of town government. The notice states Reimer complained to Supervisor
and Finance Director Christopher St. Lawrence; town attorneys Michael Klein, Alan Berman, Janice Gittelman and Beth Finkelstein; and others but
does not specify whom she complained about." Complete story here.
finance official says she's being scapegoated
Worker disputes town claim of improper filing of report to comptroller
June 21, 2013 "The
town Finance Department employee who town officials claim sent
misleading information to the state Comptroller’s
Office says she’s done nothing wrong and is being made a scapegoat for the town’s unflattering new financial designation. Melissa Reimer,
the town’s supervisor of fiscal services, disputed a statement the town issued Tuesday in response to Ramapo’s being named to Comptroller
Thomas DiNapoli’s hot list of municipalities in “significant fiscal distress.” The town statement said Reimer sent the comptroller an “annual
update document,” or AUD, in May without the authorization of officials, including Town Board members and Supervisor Christopher St.
Lawrence, who also serves as director of finance. The town said the report Reimer sent indicated Ramapo faced “certain fund deficits”
and omitted $3.5 million in anticipated revenue. But Reimer said she sent the correct information the same way she always has in her 10 ½
years on the job and that the information on the anticipated revenue wasn’t made available to her." Full Journal story here.
East Ramapo: Senate OKs lottery bill to advance $3.5M to district
June 21, 2013 "A
bill that would advance the East Ramapo school district $3.5 million
in state lottery funding has passed both
chambers of the state Legislature, bringing the deficit-plagued district a step closer to getting the one-shot cash infusion that
could help restore programs next year. East Ramapo would get the lottery money in September 2014 anyway, as part of its annual
state aid award. But district officials asked lawmakers earlier this spring to draft special legislation that would provide the money
earlier, in June 2014, so it could help ease the district through the 2013-14 year. Over the past few years, the district has laid off
more than 450 employees and cut non-mandated classes and activities as it has struggled with operating deficits and rising contractual
costs." Full text of the Journal News story here.
the world is Mara Luz Corado?
Newly elected East Ramapo school board member is MIA
June 20, 2013 "In
mid-April, Mara Luz Corado surfaced as a candidate for the
beleaguered East Ramapo school board. She was
elected on May 21 and is expected to be sworn in on July 2. Despite relentless attempts to speak with her -- or even get her
phone number -- Corado remains elusive. East Ramapo school district clerk Cathy Russell said the only contact information
she could release for Corado is a mailing address. Moreover, Bernard Charles Jr. and Pierre Germain, who successfully ran
with Corado for the three open seats on the nine-member board, have been evasive when asked about her. "I do not have her
number. Let me find out for you and I could have her call you," Germain told Newsday earlier this week. Charles, who organized
the slate, last week said Corado has been "away." He declined to elaborate, and said he, too, would ask Corado to contact Newsday.
Still, no word. Records show that Corado, 45, registered to vote in Ramapo just five days before the school board election. The
address she used to register and to put on her candidate petition -- 89 W. Maple Ave. -- is in the Community Synagogue of Monsey,
a brick building with no apparent residential entrance." Complete Newsday story here.
Editorial: Ramapo’s Financial Mess Rates 2nd Worst in the State
20, 2013 Ramapo's
financial problems are entirely self-inflicted, created by our
remarkably irresponsible town supervisor,
Christopher St. Lawrence and his rubber stamp board. (More)
East Ramapo Budget Passes--4,050 yes 2,238 no (unofficial results)
Ramapo named one of state's most fiscally distressed
towns by state comptroller
Only one community in New York State with worst finances
New Square Slaughterhouse Plan Is Back—County
Objects, Candidate Michael Koplen Says It’s Workable
June 18, 2013 The Journal News reported today that the
village of New Square has revived its plan for an
industrial project within a residential neighborhood. The 26,250 square foot processing plant is smaller than
the one proposed in 2009, but is five times the size of the existing New Square plant, which is closed. The
U.S. Attorney's Office took civil action in December 2009 against New Square Meats for unsanitary conditions
at the plant and selling poultry since 2002 that the U.S. Department of Agriculture never inspected. Adir Poultry,
a company connected to New Square Meats and Ezras Yisrael, wants to replace the closed 5,000-square-foot
slaughterhouse with a $3 million, 26,250-square-foot plant." (More)
Ramapo stops pay for Desmaret's job at Town Hall
June 15, 2013 "Spring Valley Deputy Mayor Joseph Desmaret’s job as a data clerk in Ramapo Town Hall is on the line as he contends
with a federal mail-fraud charge and an investigation at Village Hall.The town filed a misconduct charge against Desmaret and stopped
his pay after an interview and an internal investigation, Town Attorney Michael Klein said. “We’re aware of the federal indictment but
we’re not privy to the witnesses and the evidence that the federal authorities gathered,” Klein said. “We did conduct an administration
interview of Mr. Desmaret, and based on that and our own investigation, we felt we have sufficient evidence to bring the misconduct charge,
independent of the federal investigation.” Full Journal News coverage here.
Monsey man tied to FBI informant must repay $1.75M for bank fraud
June 13, 2013 "A Monsey man linked to an FBI-undercover investor accused of bribing Spring Valley and New York City officials has been sentenced
to repay $1.75 million from a bank fraud conviction. David Neumann was sentenced to three years’ supervised probation and ordered to pay
restitution by U.S. District Judge Warren Eginton, said Herbert Hadad, a spokesman for the U.S. Attorney’s Office in White Plains. Eginton sentenced
Neumann on June 7 at the federal courthouse in White Plains. Neumann pleaded guilty to a bank fraud charge involving the 2007 sale of a single-family
house at 39 Remsen Ave. in Monsey. The dilapidated house is next door to a mansion owned by investor Moses Mark Stern, who pleaded guilty to
undisclosed federal charges in March after working undercover for the FBI." Complete Journal News story here.
Dismantling East Ramapo
Cutting Sports Programs
Part 3 of Lisa Karrer's on-going series of documentaries, studying
the dismantling of the
public School system in the East Ramapo District of Rockland County, NY. This video
features an interview with Duff Pannell, the Athletic Coordinator of Ramapo High School,
excerpts from the Brian Lehrer show on WNYC Public Radio, with Spring Valley High School
student and activist Olivia Castor, and quotes from Public School Parents and Advocates.
View video here.
Superintendent Klein Misleads the Press—Claims Schools “Given Clean Bill of Health”
2013 Were it not for
the timeline of events and a claim that absolutely contradicts what the
as dangerous conditions in two schools, you might cut the Superintendent a little slack and look for a set of circumstances
that might justify what he told Newsday reporters last week. But a quick read of what he said, and when he said it
seems to leave no doubt—what he told reporter Meghan Murphy was clearly not true. And that begs several important
questions: Why did he do it; and, Who is he serving with this kind of misinformation? (More) [Story updated June 10]
What’s the Grand Jury Doing?
June 5, 2013 After gathering information and evidence over an
extended period of time, the FBI then launched a foray into Ramapo
Town Hall on May 15, spending eight hours searching for specific documents and emails, removing hard-drives and cartons of paper files.
Some time within the following two weeks a grand jury was convened, and they have subpoenaed evidence from the Ramapo Local
Development Corp, Provident Bank, Jefferies LLC the company that places bond and note offerings for the town, and Environmental
Capital, which is the Financial Advisor for Town bonds and notes. The evidence and the case are now being sorted out by the members
of the Grand Jury to determine the indictments. (More)
Fire Code Violations Task Force Calls Ramapo a ‘Time Bomb’
Task Force Appeals to State for Help in Ramapo
June 4, 2013 "The head of
Rockland County’s volunteer task force on illegal housing says rampant
building and fire code
violations in the Town of Ramapo are a 'time bomb waiting to go off' and require a state investigation. 'The volunteer fire service
in Rockland is not about to wait until dead bodies are pulled from these ‘weapons of mass construction,’ be they civilians or firefighters,'
John Kryger wrote in a June 1 letter to the New York state Division of Code Enforcement and Administration. Kryger said he sent the letter
to Ronald Piester, director of the Division of Code Enforcement and Administration, with hopes the state would take notice of what he says
is a lack of enforcement by the town and some of its villages. 'Such has not been the case in Ramapo, Kaser, New Hempstead and Spring Valley,'
Kryger wrote. There, violations are issued and ignored, and court cases are repeatedly postponed, he said. 'We haven’t gotten any satisfaction
from the Town of Ramapo on any of the violations that have been reported to us." Complete Journal News story here.
Merge Rockland School Districts
May 31, 2013 "Given the situation, one
could assume that district schools have deteriorated to such an extent
are not receiving an adequate education preparing them to compete successfully as adults. In other words, the East Ramapo
students are being prepared for failure." Read the full text of the Community View here.
Ramapo Raid Update:Grand Jury Issues Subpoenas to RLDC,
May 31, 2013 While the most
frequently asked question seems to be, "When are the indictments
coming and who will be on the receiving end?" there are very nasty secondary repercussions as well, and they are already
May 30, 2013 "Questions have
surfaced about earlier data used to determine the need for the Hudson
River water treatment plant,
as well as what consumers will end up paying for the new water source, to be drawn from brackish Haverstraw Bay and put through
purification and energy-intensive desalination processes. On Tuesday, the Orangetown Town Board voted to support an “issues
conference” — the first step in a state Department of Environmental Conservation review of United Water’s Hudson water treatment
plant plan. Such a conference would allow an administrative law judge to review data and determine whether the proposed water
treatment plant warrants a full review." Click here for the complete Journal News editorial.
May 29, 2013 "Fed
up with waves of budget cuts and deteriorating building conditions, and
determined to show authorities their
troubled school district needs immediate attention, hundreds of East Ramapo students walked out of class late Wednesday morning.
Hollering and chanting "No more cuts!" they weaved their way from Spring Valley and Ramapo high schools toward Memorial Park as
surprised workers, drivers and pedestrians looked on with equal amounts of interest and annoyance." Journal News coverage here, with
video of the march to Memorial Park.
Stadium feeds Ramapo's fiscal slide
2013 After 71
percent of the public rejected the guarantee of a $16.5 million bond for
a baseball stadium, Ramapo
Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence first promised that no public funds would be used for construction. After first stripping
all reserve funds from our town treasury he got around the rejection with a $25 million five-year note that did not require a
referendum. We knew there was no way he could pay off this bond in just five years. Sure enough, he then refinanced with
a long-term bond, evading our citizens’ refusal to guarantee the bond. (More)
While all We Saw Were Silos, the FBI and Comptroller
Were Working Together
May 24, 2013 Over the past 10 years, Preserve Ramapo has filed a
number of official complaints and
requests for investigation with a wide variety of agencies—local, state, and federal—from the State
Attorney General to the Office of Special Council in Washington, the State Bar Association to the
Committee on Open Government. And almost without exception, these agencies operated separately
and apart as they dealt with our documents and timelines. Apparently, though, there was one
significant exception. (More)
May 24, 2013 "On
the heels of an FBI raid,
the financially strapped Town of Ramapo on Thursday postponed the
$39.2 million in bonds intended to refinance debt and help pay for basic town services such as road resurfacing. Town officials
dodged questions about the bond issue -- some even saying they didn't know what was going on with the financing -- while
the Wall Street market information firm IPREO confirmed to Newsday that the bond sale -- scheduled to be priced Friday -- had
been scuttled. No new sale date has been scheduled, according to IPREO." Complete Newsday coverage here.
East Ramapo trims tax hike, cuts budget $452,000; new vote is June 18
May 23, 2013 "East
Ramapo school officials will ask voters to decide on a $209.5 million
budget with a 2.8
increase next month following a narrow defeat of slightly higher spending proposal earlier this week. Until the second
election on June 18, officials said they’ll use the next three and a half weeks to ramp up efforts to get out the vote,
especially in the public school community, which sends about 9,000 students to East Ramapo. A $209.9 million budget
with a 3.13 percent tax increase failed by 505 votes Tuesday." Complete Journal News story here.
"Ramapo Supervisor Christopher
St. Lawrence -- whose Local Development Corporation is at the center of
investigation -- has clammed up about the probe, refusing to answer reporter's questions after a town board meeting
Wednesday night. The only mention of Ramapo's woes during the first regularly scheduled board meeting since the raid
was from Michael Castelluccio of Preserve Ramapo. Castelluccio refuted a statement made by Ken Lehner, president of
the Rockland Boulders, who said the team is in no way involved with the investigation. "Until the financial records from
last year are published and made public and given to the town, they are in the middle of the eye of that storm," Castelluccio
said. "And if, in fact, they have produced those numbers and that information is currently being stonewalled by the current
administration, all I could say is 'good luck'". Complete text of the story here.
Downgrades East Ramapo School District Bonds
to Three Steps Above Junk Status
May 22, 2013 "Moody's
Investors Service has downgraded to Baa1 from A2 the underlying rating
on East Ramapo Central
School District's (NY) $14.4 million in outstanding general obligation debt; the outlook remains negative. The downgrade
to Baa1 reflects ongoing deterioration in the district's financial position with the expectation of a negative General Fund
balance at the end of fiscal 2013. The weakened financial position is the result of a continued structural imbalance driven
by underperforming revenues." Full report here.
F.B.I. Raid Renews Focus on Ballpark Deal in Rockland
May 21, 2013 The New York Times reports: "When federal agents last week spent
Ramapo corruption investigation: FBI questioned Boulders' ballpark developer Holt
May 17, 2013 "The
FBI's 40-agent foray into Ramapo Town Hall Wednesday was not its
first trip to Rockland County in search of evidence
in an investigation of the town's Local Development Corporation and how the LDC refinanced $25 million in bonds for Provident Bank Park.
Several weeks ago FBI agents visited the general contractor on the $39 million baseball stadium, Jack Holt, the owner of Holt Construction
in Pearl River, and questioned him about the project and its financing, Holt told Newsday Friday." (More)
Bernard Charles' one vote on Ramapo Planning
stirs broad resentment
Originally published: May 17, 2013 NEWSDAY
"School board candidate Bernard Charles Jr.
voted on just one project during his unusually brief tenure on the Town of Ramapo Planning
Board. But that one vote is haunting him. Charles, who is running with a slate of candidates
for election to the East Ramapo Central School District Board on May 21, voted in favor of
the Patrick Farm development in March; three weeks after the vote, he quietly resigned from
the planning board, having served on it less than a month. The vote has proved controversial.
Education activists see the Patrick Farm project as a step toward further destabilization of
the troubled East Ramapo district. (More)
Ramapo raid is a proud moment for the gadflies
May 17, 2013 "They're often looked upon as
curmudgeons: the naysayers, loudmouths or know-nothings who revel in
obstruction. But in truth,
they are trying to do a civic duty -- challenging authority and offering a dissenting voice, however intense, passionate or seemingly annoying.
Socrates is one of history's better-known pains-in-the neck: He said such flies are easy to swat away or ignore, but society does so at its own peril.
Federal investigators must know a thing or two about that philosophy; they aren't blowing off any of Ramapo's gadflies these days." (More)
May 16, 2013 "An
influential investment rating agency issued a dire analysis of Ramapo’s
financial health as the town prepares to sell $39.2 million
in serial bonds for public improvement projects. Moody’s Investors Service issued its A1 rating and negative outlook for Ramapo on Wednesday,
coincidentally the same day the FBI and Rockland District Attorney’s Office raided Town Hall and seized financial records. 'The rating incorporates
significant erosion of the town’s financial flexibility stemming from four consecutive years of operating deficits from aggressive economically
sensitive revenue assumptions and inability to offset mid-year shortfalls,' Moody’s stated on its website." Complete Journal story here.
May 16, 2013 "The
investigators are reviewing documents to determine whether Supervisor
Christopher St. Lawrence overstated assets, such
as incoming revenue, for the bonds and refinancing of the $25 million bond. They also are looking into the movement of money among accounts,
possible commingling of funds and whether the Local Development Corp. that oversaw the project generated money and repaid the town,
a source familiar with the probe said. Among the documents taken were emails from St. Lawrence, Town Attorney Michael Klein and Finance
Officer Nat Oberman. Though the FBI made no arrests, the raid sent a strong signal that the U.S. Attorney’s Office has set its focus on more
corruption investigations in Ramapo." (This LoHud article provides background on the Ballpark and Elm Street financing--Read the
full article here.)
Reaction to Ramapo probe is no surprise--Journal News Editorial
May 16, 2013 "Ramapo is a mess —
socially, politically and fiscally. Tension has long been building
over the leadership and decision-making
of Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence, including ill-considered downzoning and profligate spending on his watch. And bubbling not even below
the surface — a growing perception among critics that town decisions are made to curry favor with the ultra-Orthodox and Hasidic "bloc vote,"
formidable enough to tip elections. Those challenges help explain the glee expressed by many residents as news spread that the FBI had raided
Town Hall and left with suitcases full of documents and computer drives. That strong reaction — some residents came to Town Hall on Wednesday
night to offer their comments to reporters — was emblematic of the long-simmering relationship between St. Lawrence, and the government
he leads, and the large number of disaffected residents who also are his constituents." Read the entire Editorial here.
Ramapo corruption probe: Feds focus on ballpark refinancing, sources say
May 16, 2013 "Federal
authorities are investigating whether Ramapo's Local Development Corp.,
headed by Town Supervisor Christopher
St. Lawrence, falsely claimed assets it did not have to back the refinancing of bonds, including the $25 million bond for the controversial
Provident Bank Park, sources told Newsday. FBI agents and prosecutors from the U.S. attorney's office also are investigating the LDC's
financing of the building of Ramapo Commons, a 24-unit affordable housing condominium project in an unincorporated part of the town,
sources familiar with the investigation said." (More)
FBI seizes town records in Ramapo corruption probe
Officials in the Rockland County town are
under fire over controversial spending decisions. Activists suspect the
FBI raid is a response to their complaints
against LDC president and town supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence
From the Twitter accounts of the
reporters still at Town Hall--Mareesa Nicosia and Steve
Lieberman from the Journal News:
Steve 10:40 pm--Assistant US Attorney Daniel
Filor was seen just leaving Ramapo Town Hall offered no comment.
Steve 10:40 pm--Heard that FBI agents were wrapping up after almost 7 hours inside collecting information.
Mareesa 10:35 pm--No sign yet of St. Lawrence
or Town Attorney Michael Klein but their cars are still in the parking
Mareesa 7:30 pm--Still inside Town Hall are St. Lawrence, Michael Klein and the head of IT for the town. (There since 4 in the afternoon)
Steve 6:30 pm--FBI seizing Ramapo financial
records, and documents from town atty and RLDC for baseball stadium,
housing. IT department
Earlier in the day there were reports that
several town officials were kept for questioning inside town hall as all
other workers were told
to leave. These included Christopher St. Lawrence--Supervisor, Michael Klein Town Attorney, Nate Oberman Finance Director, and Christian
Samson Town Clerk, and Teresa Reeck IT Director.
Another as yet unconfirmed report claimed there were Treasury Officials along with the FBI evidence recovery team.
FBI Raids Ramapo Town Hall
May 15, 2013 Newsday reports: "About
40 federal agents showed up in force at Ramapo Town Hall Wednesday
afternoon and ordered
most employees out while they executed a search warrant for financial documents related to yet another corruption probe affecting a
Rockland County community, sources said. FBI spokesman Jim Margolin confirmed the raid, but would not answer questions. A law
enforcement source with knowledge of the investigation said some of the records sought by federal agents include documents related
to Provident Bank Park and the local development corporation that runs the controversial, $38 million baseball stadium that is home
to the Boulders. Shortly before 11 p.m., a swarm of agents carted out two dollies stacked with number brown cardboard boxes full of
documents. Ramapo's finance director, Melissa Reimer, walked out of town hall a few minutes after 10 p.m. -- more than six hours
after the FBI arrived -- and told reporters she had no comment." (More)
FBI agents descend on Ramapo Town Hall,
employees ordered out
May 15, 2013 The Journal News reports: "FBI agents and
investigators from the Rockland District Attorney’s Office have ordered
employees out of Ramapo Town Hall after agents arrived for an apparent investigation. A town employee said everyone was told to
leave the building by agents, who arrived around 3:30 p.m. The FBI has not said yet what it is seeking at Town Hall, or what the focus
of the investigation might be. Ramapo police arrived shortly after the FBI and were blocking the entrances to the building. Town
Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence arrived at 4 p.m. and went in the side entrance to his office. “I’m going in to see what’s going on,”
he told The Journal News. About 15 minutes later, agents were still escorting employees out of the building. Employees said they were
not told what was going on. Some of the agents are wearing blue windbreakers with lettering “FBI ERT,” indicating they are from the
bureau’s Evidence Response Team." Read the developing coverage at Lohud here but be patient, the LoHud server has crashed at least once
with increased traffic.
Wrong to use public site to discriminate
May 13, 2013 "My husband and I went to Provident Bank Park on
Thursday evening. We read in The Journal News that there would be a
rally initiated by the ultra-Orthodox and Hasidic community addressing the danger of the Internet. The article indicated that the audience
would be limited to males ages 10 and older and that tickets were $10 a person. It was our intention to see if we — with the purchase of
two tickets — would be admitted to a public site that our tax dollars paid for — and apparently will pay for many years to come." (More)
(Read announcement from Day's campaign here)
Preserve Ramapo Announces Endorsement of Ed Day for County Executive
May 10, 2013 Today
Preserve Ramapo and County Legislator Joseph Meyers announced their
endorsements of Ed Day for the
office of Rockland County Executive. Read the Press Release here. And read the letter from Preserve Ramapo Chairman, Bob Rhodes,
which outlines the reasons for our choice of Day as the best candidate. Bob's letter can be read here.
Olivia Castor and Peggy Hatton
Explain the Crisis in East Ramapo Schools
on WNYC's Brian Lehrer Show
May 9, 2013 To replay the full show,
just click on the image of the player below. You will be taken to the
where you can click on the play button and listen to a stream of the entire half-hour segment with call-ins.
Monsey Controls Planning and Zoning Boards in
St. Lawrence Appointees Kept Anonymous
May 3, 2013 The names of the seven
members of the Ramapo Planning and Zoning Boards do
not appear anywhere on the Town’s website. Clarkstown, Orangetown, Stony Point—they list
their boards. You might ask the Supervisor. After all, he appointed the members to terms as
long as seven years. More important though is the question why does one sector which has
the most irresponsible and out-of-control development have control over the planning and
zoning for all of Ramapo? (More)
Suit vs. East Ramapo: Judge says discovery process may proceed
May 3, 2013 "Nine
months after parents filed a federal lawsuit accusing East Ramapo school
officials of steering public tax dollars to
private religious schools and segregating special-education students, the records-gathering process in the case can begin. The Advocates’
case could hinge on parsing the evidence to show how much the district has spent — for special education and in other areas — on its private
school population versus its public school population." Journal News story here.
May 1, 2013
You just recently paid your Ramapo Town tax
bill, and Nathan Oberman, receiver of
taxes, presumably, banked your check to fund all the expenses outlined in the new town budget.
And what does the Ramapo Supervisor and the Board do next? They vote to borrow an additional
$19.7 million to fix the roads, spruce up the parks, buy some equipment, and roll over an old debt—all
guaranteed by your signature and to be paid by you and the neighbors next tax collection cycle, and
the next, and the next. (More)
Community View: Planning, balance lost in Ramapo's development
May 1, 2013 "Neighbors
are upset, fearing property values will decline, worried about traffic
and noise. They should also be concerned
about planning imbalance that will bring greater costs to all and a decline in the quality of living. Throughout much of Ramapo, housing
construction for religious groups, principally from land-starved New York City, has skyrocketed, with building density and height not in
keeping with suburbia. Sewers and water supply are increasingly stressed even as the county considers an uber-expensive Hudson River
water-treatment desalination plant that will encourage more such growth. The East Ramapo school district, its public school children
disenfranchised because their education is increasingly held hostage by religious group-inspired budget cuts and private school needs,
will suffer even greater financial drain." Read the full text of Arthur Gunther's Community View here.
Spring Valley's use of HUD funds in housing project
Feds probe use of HUD funds for condos
April 30, 2013 "The
village potentially owes a federal agency close to $1 million resulting
from administrative errors involving an urban-renewal
housing project, according to a federal audit. The project, Park View Condominiums, has also drawn federal scrutiny following allegations the
developer discriminated against blacks by selectively marketing and selling units to Orthodox Jews. The Department of Housing and Urban
Development is investigating Spring Valley’s use of federal money involving the condo property at Route 45 and Maple Avenue." Journal story here.
Finds Way to Enable Illegal School Conversion
for 250 Students in Hillcrest
April 30, 2013 At first, the building
inspectors for the Town of Ramapo shut down the illegal conversion of a
Eckerson Lane into a school. Then a Town Advisory Board that included Ramapo Chief Building Inspector and planning
consultant Anthony Mallia and the Town’s legal department gave the congregation permission to use the house as a
school for a year, during construction. "They are retrofitting a house as a school," Mallia told a Journal News reporter.
"They could have used modular trailers for classrooms. What’s the difference? The congregation is taking a risk.
If after a year, they don’t get final approval for a school, they might have to leave." (More)
Failure of the Tax Cap in Ramapo
29, 2013 The tax cap
is almost meaningless at the local government level. As the Journal News
reporter tells us, it only takes a simple majority of
the town board (3 of 5), or 60% of the town board to overrule the cap.Take the town of Ramapo as an example. Around last June Supervisor
St. Lawrence announced with a big headline in the Journal News that local taxes would only go up by only 1.9% in 2013. But that was before
his EXTREMELY delayed year end financials for 2011 came out. We knew this was impossible and wondered how he could create a new budget
for 2013 when he still CLAIMED he did not have the financials for 2011! Then at the end of 2012, he announced the real tax increase for 2013
would be 9.4%, not the previously announced 1.9%. (More)
Wallace-Wells--Author of "Them and Them" appears
on WNYC's Brian Lehrer Show
28, 2013 Listen to the broadcast
here. To fill in some of the gaps in the
discussion, you can see a list of the fraud and abuse charges leveled against the school board and
administration officials in the parents' class action lawsuit here. There's also a direct link to the
text of the lawsuit, which is posted here. Wallace-Wells original article on the "gutting" of the East
Ramapo School District by its ultra-Orthodox board can be read here.
probe NAACP discrimination claim against Spring Valley, condo developer
NAACP: Builder, Spring Valley discouraged black buyers
April 23, 2013 "The NAACP has filed a federal complaint alleging that the Park View Condominiums discriminated against
black people by selectAively marketing and selling units to Orthodox Jews. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development
is investigating whether the developer of a 60-unit condominium complex violated fair-housing and civil rights laws. The April 16
complaint, filed by the regional and Spring Valley branches of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, names
the Village of Spring Valley and Route 45 LLC (of Lakewood, NJ), the developer of the complex at 120 N. Main St., at the Maple Avenue
corner. “Upon information and belief, the developer with the knowledge of the village of Spring Valley is marketing these dwellings as
segregated housing to people of Hasidim faith only,” the complaint reads." Journal story here.
Them and Them
New York Magazine feature article on the destruction of the East Ramapo School System
April 21, 2013 “Up
in Ramapo, the immigrant community and the growing population of Hasidim
had eyed each other with increasing
wariness. Then the Orthodox took over the public schools and proceeded to gut them.” (More)
Rockland Boulders ballpark's 2012 finances
remain a mystery, worrying residents, NY officials
Newsday: April 20, 2013"As the Rockland Boulders gear up for opening day in less than a month, Ramapo town
St. Lawrence’s Investment in Joseph Desmaret
April 21, 2013 Earlier in the week, in our
update on the political fallout in Spring Valley, we included a table
that showed a substantial cash flow
in a very short period of time between the Ramapo Town Supervisor and the recently indicted Joseph Desmaret. Since then, we have researched
the salary and raises given to Desmaret by his political enabler, and we have received some interesting speculation on the nature of the political
Journal News: East Ramapo board chief Schwartz resigns
April 20, 2013 "Schwartz
has held the unpaid school board post for two years and was elected
president in July. In that time, tensions between the
public and the nine-member board, whose members are mostly Hasidic and Orthodox men, have grown increasingly contentious. Often at odds with
the public-school community, Schwartz used his authority as president to threaten to remove the public-speaking portion of regular board meetings
and unsuccessfully tried to move people who videotape meetings from the front to the back of the room.Schwartz and several other board members
and district administrators are defendants in a federal lawsuit filed by hundreds of parents who claim the officials wrongfully steered public tax dollars
to private schools to benefit the Orthodox community’s yeshiva education system. Legal petitions calling for the removal of board members also have
been filed by members of East Ramapo’s activist community." Complete Journal coverage here.
April 19, 2013 "Citing
"various personal reasons," East Ramapo
school board president
Daniel Schwartz said
he will step down Monday -- days before the beleaguered board is set to pass its deficit-plagued
budget -- according to a resignation letter submitted Friday.Schwartz, an associate attorney at the law firm
Kantrowitz, Goldhamer & Graifman P.C. did not elaborate on his reasons for quitting the unpaid school board
position that he has held for two years. A well-connected source within the Hasidic community told Newsday
that the polarizing issues facing the board were hurting the law practice, and Schwartz, 43, was forced to
choose between his job and position on the board. "He was squeezed out of business because of what's been
going on," the source said. "A person needs to take care of his family first ... He had no choice." Schwartz,
who had one more year left on his term, did not immediately return a request for comment." Newsday story here.
East Ramapo school district proposes dozens of staff layoffs, sports cuts in 2013-14 budget
April 17, 2013 "The
East Ramapo school district plans to eliminate dozens of staff, mostly
teachers, and steer other longtime employees to opt into
retirement incentives to close a shortfall in its 2013-14 budget. The teachers who will be laid off are assigned to core academic subjects, as well as
English as a Second Language, music, art and physical education, at the high school and middle school levels. In addition, 15 special education teachers
will be laid off and collaborative classes other than those at the middle schools will be cut, according to the plan released by East Ramapo officials
Tuesday. Sports will also be affected. Varsity golf, cheerleading, boys volleyball, JV tennis, girls JV volleyball and all middle school sports will be cut from
the budget, according to the plan. Another set of potential cuts would eliminate 14 art and music teachers and seven librarians in the elementary schools
if the district were to lose $960,000 due to federal budget cuts enacted last month, known as “sequestration.” In total, 52 employees could lose their jobs."
Full text of The Journal News story here.
Spring Valley Round-up (News that is) for the Week
14, 2013 Over the
past seven days a lot has been going on in Spring Valley as a
consequence of the Federal indictments
brought against the Mayor, Noramie Jasmin, and Deputy Mayor Joseph Desmaret. The FBI is looking to gather more information,
and Desmaret has gotten new lawyers but can’t find a co-signer for his bail bond. Meetings between St. Lawrence and the wired
informant have been mentioned in the press, and the list of mayoral candidates is growing. (More)
Treatment method won't eliminate carcinogens from Hudson waters
April 10, 2013 "United Water, an
American subsidiary of the French transnational company Suez
Environnement, is pushing hard to
build a desalination plant on Haverstraw Bay, which they state will help them distribute water to their customers in Rockland County.
United Water is not really interested in protecting endangered species around the Hudson River or whether the water that they will
obtain by treating it with the latest reverse osmosis technology will have serious health consequences for its consumers in Rockland
County." Read the full text of the Community View here.
Latest on the Ward System in Court
The man who wore the wire revealed
New York Post--Shoulda Known He Was Trouble
April 4, 2013 "They should have just Googled the guy. A simple
Web search would have shown state Sen. Malcolm Smith and City
Councilman Dan Halloran that they were getting into bed with a shady developer who lost a $126 million lawsuit over a failed real-estate
project. Moses "Mark" Stern, who was the feds’ confidential informant against the pols, took out a massive loan from Citigroup to buy 11
shopping malls in 2007 — and his company promptly went bankrupt, according to court documents." (More)
FBI Press Conference
April 3, 2013 "And the dream of honest
government cannot come to pass unless there is real change in the
culture. Because what can we expect when there continues to be – even after a parade of politicians have
been hauled off to prison – a lack of transparency, a lack of self-disclosure, a lack of self-policing,a lack of
will, and a failure of leadership? What can we expect when transgressions seem to be tolerated and nothing
seems to ever change? New Yorkers should demand more. Federal prosecutors and federal agents are doing
everything we can to proactively attack the corruption problem. And it’s time for others to step up also." (More)
Mayor Jasmin Says Little in Minute Press Conference
April 3, 2013 In a press conference
which lasted a few minutes, Mayor Noramie Jasmin announced, "We will
vigorously defend against those
charges to restore my good name. I'm asking the community not to prejudge me, rather to keep me in your prayers for my good name to
restore." She took no questions, and did not say whether she would stand down until the legal issues are resolved.
Mayor and Deputy Arraigned
April 3, 2013 In a Westchester Court,
Mayor Noramie Jasmin and her Deputy Mayor, Joseph Desmaret, were
arraigned on federal
charges of mail fraud and bribery. Both were required to produce $250,000 bail, and they surrendered their passports. Desmaret was
also ordered to wear a digital tracking device and the Mayor was assigned a monitor. Pleas were not made at this time, and the next
court hearing will be April 23. The matter of whether the two will step down was not discussed at this time and will be possibly
addressed in an official comment by Jasmine promised for later today. The full text of the FBI complaint against the two local politicians
can be read at
Arrests Spring Valley Mayor Noramie Jasmin and
Deputy Mayor Joseph DesMaret Charging Bribery and Mail Fraud
April 2, 2013 This morning, at around six
am, agents from the FBI’s Public Corruption Squad arrested Spring
Valley Mayor Noramie Jasmin and Deputy Mayor Joseph DesMaret at their homes in Spring Valley and Monsey.
The two were charged in a land development bribery scheme involving property in the village. The charges
were unsealed in Manhattan this morning, and the two politicians will be arraigned in Westchester this
Rockland County Sewer District Notifies Ramapo and the Patrick Farm
of Need to Verify Wetlands
March 28, 2013 From ROSA 4 Rockland: “As of late this afternoon,
Scenic Development and the Town of Ramapo have been officially
put on notice by Rockland County Sewage District #1: "as a condition of allowing the Patrick Farm project to connect to the District's
sewerage system, the District requires the project sponsor to obtain and forward to the EPA and to the District a jurisdictional determination
from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers verifying the extent of the project area wetlands" ROSA's hired civil engineers and wetland experts
have carefully examined this project and reported that unmapped wetlands exist and need to be accounted for. Once mapped additional
wetlands can seriously impact the development plans.” (More)
Layne Gets Conditional Discharge for “Official Misconduct”March 28th, 2013 "Former Airmont mayor and Sloatsburg building inspector pleads guilty to misdemeanor and
Update: East Ramapo Surtax—Legal Defense
Fund for School
Board Members—Now $4,000+ Per Day
2013 With the most recent
returns from a Feb. 1 FOIL (Freedom of Information Law) request
added in, the cost of defending the East Ramapo School Board President and individual Board members
is growing. What amounts to a surtax to defend them against a lawsuit and also the New York State
charges of mismanagement and misappropriation of funds is now $4,336.91 per day. (More)
21, 2013 SPRING VALLEY, N.Y. (AP) —
board meetings descend into shouting matches. Accusations of racism
and anti-Semitism fly.
Angry parents turn their backs on board members in a symbolic stand of disrespect." (More)
McKinstry of Newsday: End the bullying in East Ramapo
East Ramapo sues state over special-education placements
March 20, 2013
East Ramapo school district is suing the state Education Department over
the district’s controversial practice of assigning
students with disabilities to private religious schools when public-school placements are available." Journal News story here. You can read the
lawsuit at www.scribd.com/doc/131318746/East-Ramapo-lawsuit-against-state. The first 12 pages offers a summary and history of the problem.
Journal News Editorial: State must help East Ramapo kids
Ramapo school district’s sinking fiscal situation and declining public
educational offerings have spurred various calls for action. The local
NAACP wants the governor to get involved. The state education commissioner wants legislation allowing the Board of Regents to intervene in
school districts that are in academic or fiscal distress, or, in the case of East Ramapo, both. A state assemblyman wants an outside study, paid
for by the state, of possible fixes, including the dramatic step of splitting the district into two entities — one serving public-school children and
the other the private school community. All these suggested approaches, different as they are, have their own risks and rewards. What they have
in common is this: they demand action from state officials. The state Legislature and Gov. Andrew Cuomo should heed the calls for their intervention.
New York owes its youngest citizens a sound public education — and the promise inherent in such offerings. Day by day, the public-school children
in East Ramapo move further away from that goal." Read full text of the editorial here.
Patrick Farm Final Hearing Before Ramapo Planning Board Tonight--Wed. March 20
March 20, 2013 A public hearing for a
Final Subdivision Approval of the Patrick Farm Subdivision, consisting
of 88 tax lots on 196.4 acres
will be held tonight, Wed. March 20 at 8pm, at the Ramapo Town Hall on Route 59. The applicant is Scenic Development, LLC, 3 Ashel Lane
Monsey, N.Y. More information can be found here.
Chestnut Ridge Elects Mayor Sam Presti with 978 votes
to Nancy Guirand's 303 votes
Click here for the latest update on the Ward Petition and Petition to increase number of council members.
State may act on East Ramapo, education chief says
King responds to activist's concerns about troubled district
March 14, 2013
chief education official says he’s ready to intervene further in the
East Ramapo schools’
crisis if the district doesn’t take sufficient action on its own. In a letter to a community activist, state Education Commissioner
John King Jr. said he’s “prepared to take escalating action, as authorized by law,” if East Ramapo officials don’t “make sufficient
progress” to address the district’s problems, including its multimillion-dollar deficit. Such action, according to state education
law, may include the removal of local school officials if it’s proved that they willfully violated the law or disobeyed an order
of the commissioner or Board of Regents. The warning heartened activists who had hand-delivered a petition with almost 5,000
signatures in Albany in January, asking King to appoint an oversight monitor to take charge of the troubled district." Complete
Journal News coverage here.
Dividing the East Ramapo District—A Response
March 13, 2013
State Senator Ken Zebrowski deserves real credit for his concern for
the future of the children who attend schools
in the East Ramapo school district. Unfortunately his proposed plan to divide the district into two separate segregated school
districts is not legal, or, even if it were, a practical solution. Read the full text of Bob Rhodes' response to the Zebrowski plan here.
Zebrowski on East Ramapo: Create 2 school districts
March 13, 2013 "A
state lawmaker says the “untenable” problems of the East Ramapo
school district could be solved by carving out
new geographic lines that would divide the current district into two. In an exclusive interview this week with The Journal News,
Assemblyman Kenneth Zebrowski Jr. said he wants to appropriate money in this year’s state budget to commission an independent
feasibility study on his proposal.The plan, he said, would create a new school district to serve the needs of East Ramapo’s 9,000
public school students — many of whom come from low-income, immigrant families." Full story here.
Board offers New
Interpretation of the First Amendment
March 12, 2013School board president, Daniel Schwartz,
Legal Fees to Defend East Ramapo School Board Now at $3,000 a day
March 6, 2013 The East Ramapo School Board, whose deficiencies
have "exposed District funds and assets to abuse,
waste, and/or loss," according to the New York State Comptroller, are currently fighting legal actions against the New York
Attorney General (investigating sales of school buildings), the New York Board of Education (for illegal placement of students in
private schools, lost and mismanaged funds and resources), and 600 East Ramapo parents who have launched a class action lawsuit
against the board members for "siphoning off public money to support private religious institutions," and "segregating students in
special-education programs based on their race, at taxpayer’s expense" (filed by the public-interest law firm Advocates for Justice).
The cost for defending this group, which the Comptroller’s Report claims, "[Have] failed to fulfill its stewardship, oversight, and
leadership responsibilities," is considerable. Worse, it’s being shoved off onto the taxpayers. (More)
Newsday--State school officials to East Ramapo: Show us your books
March 1, 2013 "State
education officials have asked East Ramapo to allow them to examine the
school district's financial records in an effort to resolve a persistent budget crisis. In a Feb. 14 letter obtained by
Newsday, Deputy Education Commissioner Ken Slentz deemed that East Ramapo again had failed to provide the
state with sufficient information to determine why the district is operating with a midyear deficit. Slentz also
requested a meeting with district leaders." Complete Newsday story here.
NY Attorney General seeks testimony from ex-East Ramapo board member
At least one former East Ramapo school board member has been asked to
testify to state
Attorney General Eric Schneiderman’s office, which is probing the district’s controversial sales and leasing of
two former public school buildings to local yeshivas. Stephen Price, one of two board members who abruptly
resigned from the fractured school board in January, told The Journal News he was recently contacted by the
Attorney General’s office and asked to testify. 'They haven’t indicated when. They just said they wanted to
talk to me,' Price said Thursday evening. He added that the office gave no indication in a recent letter addressed
to him what the subject of the questioning would be about." Complete Journal News story here.
Feb. 28, 2013 "With
the troubled East Ramapo school district facing a multimillion-dollar
shortfall and the
potential of more program cuts, state education officials say they want to meet face to face with school
leaders to address the district’s budget and its plans to dig out of its deficit. It’s a rare intervention by the
state Education Department, which has been monitoring East Ramapo’s financial problems and in recent months
demanded officials submit a plan to the state for how it will balance its budget." Complete Journal News story here.
East Ramapo fails public school students
Feb. 25, 2013 "I
was both perplexed and disturbed when reading the response by the
president of the East
Ramapo school board, Daniel Schwartz. Where is the mention of the public school student? He has a fiduciary
duty to steward children through the K-12 educational process and through education reform changes, and to
provide for them with proper budgeting." Complete Community View Reply here.
Square yeshiva got millions in tech funds despite
no student access to computers
Feb. 19, 2012 "An
all-boys school in the Hasidic village of New Square has accepted more
than $3.3 million
in federal funds earmarked for Internet and telecommunications technology even though students there do
not have access to computers, an investigation by the Manhattan-based Jewish Week has found. According to
a Feb. 15 report published by the newspaper, Yeshiva Avir Yakov in New Square “is just one of many fervently
Orthodox Jewish schools in New York State that, despite publicly eschewing Internet use and despite offering
their students minimal, if any, access to computers, have spent large sums of E-rate money.” Journal News
Week: Internet-Averse Haredi Schools Reaping Millions
in Federal Tech Funds
How does a
community that rails against the Web pull in $30 million in one year for
its schools from the
E-rate program? Story here.
Feb. 15, 2013 "Ramapo
Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence signed off on the refinancing of
Provident Bank Park
despite not knowing how the stadium fared financially in 2012, sparking concern and outrage from the state comptroller
as well as local residents. St. Lawrence, who heads the town-backed Local Development Corporation, and LDC board
members John Brunson and Moses Gross on Thursday extended the initial five-year, $25 million bond financing for the
2-year-old Pomona ballpark to a debt that would be paid off over the next three decades, LDC attorney Aaron Troodler
told Newsday. While the terms of the refinancing seem favorable, to some critics of the ballpark, it also raised red flags,
particularly with revenue figures from 2012 still not available, five months after the stadium's tenants, independent baseball's
Rockland Boulders, finished off their season. "Short of them coming up with new figures, I'm not sure how this is going to
alleviate any of the concerns of the initial audit," said Brian Butry, a spokesman for state comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, referring
to an investigation his office conducted in February 2012 that raised questions about the ballpark's revenue estimates.The decision
to refinance has only exacerbated the concerns found in the 2012 probe, said Butry, who added that this could spark another
audit from the comptroller." Read the complete Newsday story here.
I'll Show You Mine, If You Show Me Yours!
Newsday publishes a provocative
challenge from a perspective applicant for one of the vacant seats on
the East Ramapo School Board. It's both hilarious and very sad. Read the letter here.
February 4, 2013 On his Saturday radio
broadcast, Supervisor St. Lawrence had a
little trouble "controlling the message" when the laces on his Oxford got in the way
of his usual measured eloquence. (More)
January 31, 2013
Over the past year, millions have been transferred
from the Town of Ramapo tax resources to Supervisor St. Lawrence’s
private development company called the RLDC (Ramapo Local Development
Corp). It’s a small corporation, St. Lawrence is both President and Chairman
of the Board and there are two other members of the board and that’s it.
Yet it spends tens of millions of taxpayer dollars each year. The New York
State Comptroller’s Office has warned in a highly critical audit that the RLDC
funds and the Town of Ramapo funds must be kept separate and apart. But since the RLDC doesn’t have the money to
do what it wants, it takes what it needs from the Town coffers. The State’s warning is not an obstacle because the
Town Board is as deaf to what the State says as St. Lawrence, who, of course, is the herder of this group of accomplices. (More)
Journal News Editorial Calls for State Investigation of Resignations
January 25, 2013 Today, on its
editorial page, The Journal News echoed the same call for a State
investigation of those
circumstances that motivated the resignation of two school board members, which we expressed as our first reaction to
the content of the letters from Price and Young-Mercer. In part, the editorial reads: "The recent resignation letters of two
East Ramapo school board trustees assert ongoing intimidation, accuse the district’s administration of withholding key
information amid a fiscal crisis and express a lack of trust in the district’s leadership. But what could be the most important
line comes at the very end — a cc to Dr. John B. King, New York state’s commissioner of education. He needs to study the
letters closely as he weighs the need for future state intervention in a district drowning in red ink and community distrust."
Read the entire editorial here.
January 23, 2013 The letters include
a number of serious situations that require investigation by state
officials. Read both
East Ramapo school board members who unexpectedly resigned Tuesday said
they did so because
it had become “exceedingly difficult” to work in the district due to a lack of information from the schools superintendent and
continuous intimidation from their fellow board members. Stephen Price and Suzanne Young-Mercer submitted their resignation
letters to District Clerk Cathy Russell on Monday. The resignations were announced at Tuesday night’s Board of Education meeting,
which Young-Mercer and Price did not attend. Young-Mercer said doing her job as an elected official had become “exceedingly
difficult ... due to the lack of trust I have in the information being provided to me.” She also cited “the persistent level of
intimidation” she felt when she spoke out or raised concerns, including verbal abuse by fellow trustees. Price, who has served as
trustee for 20 years, wrote there was a “continuing pattern of harassment and intimidation” that made it near impossible for him
to carry out his duties. In addition to being denied access to district information, he wrote was “wrongfully accused of religious
discrimination” and threatened with legal actions. Price also wrote he had made numerous requests to Klein for financial and cash
flow data and other budget information but that his requests were “ignored and the scant information that I did receive was generally
incomplete or inaccurate.” Read the complete Journal News story here.
January 21, 2013 The Town of
Ramapo is still fighting the legal right of petitioners to have a
referendum vote on whether Ramapo
should be divided into Wards, each with their own elected representative on the Town Board. (More)
Jan. 19, 2013
It was general "mistrust of Ramapo government led to the creation of the
Village of Chestnut Ridge
in 1986. Chestnut Ridge followed several other communities becoming villages in response to town government
planning or lack of enforcement of zoning laws. Kobre has been the village’s only mayor and is currently the
longest-serving mayor in the county. 'I am proud to have been the mayor of this beautiful, diverse community,'
Kobre said last week. 'It’s time for someone else to lead after 26 years as mayor. The village needs someone younger who will
keep the village, in our estimation, the best in the entire county.' Kobre has endorsed Rosario “Sam” Presti Jr. as his successor.
An election is set for March 19." The complete Journal News story can be read here.
Planning Board delays vote on Patrick Farm,
seeks to scale back housing plan amid public opposition
Town urged to delay OK pending design review
town Planning Board closed a public hearing on the long-debated
Patrick Farm development Wednesday night with a decision to seek a reduction in the nearly
500 housing units proposed for construction on a vast parcel of undeveloped land. The controversial
project calls for 410 high-density multifamily units and 87 single-family houses on 208 acres off routes
202 and 306 outside the village of Pomona. Opponents have fought Patrick Farm for years, arguing a
project of its size will destroy the character of the single-family neighborhood and endanger the environment. The Planning Board closed the
hearing as midnight approached after hearing out more than three hours of speakers, many of whom urged board members to delay final
approval of the project to allow for further review of the designs. The board agreed to solicit further written comments from the public and
the project applicant on several disputed issues through Jan. 30." Journal News story here.
East Ramapo makes deadline on deficit; schools chief seeks N.Y. help in fiscal crisis
January 17, 2013 "East
officials made a state Education Department deadline Wednesday to submit
plan to address the district’s deficit, but they say that aside from a multimillion-dollar bond they intend to use to close
this year’s shortfall, there’s “almost nothing” they can do to solve the district’s broader financial crisis without an overhaul
of the state funding formula. East Ramapo Superintendent of Schools Joel Klein made the statements in a four-page letter
to state education officials, at once pleading for support from the state and criticizing the tenor of its recent communications
with the district." Complete Journal News coverage here.
Sandy showed risks of Hudson water treatment plant plan
January 17, 2013 "If
United Water’s desalination plant, proposed for Haverstraw Bay, had been
built last year, the critical
water intake infrastructure and pipes could have been destroyed by Superstorm Sandy. Unprecedented storm surges, 10 feet
in Haverstraw Bay, stripped the fronts off houses near the water, and dislodged intake pipes and mangled equipment used
for United Water’s pilot plant. The storm knocked marine fuel tanks into the Hudson and forced the partial shutdown of Indian Point,
located only 3.5 miles upstream from the proposed intake for United Water’s plant. Raw sewage flooded the area adjacent to the
proposed water supply intake. Access roads to the proposed sites, needed in emergencies, were completely flooded and impassable.
In short, the storm would have jeopardized public water supply for hundreds of thousands of people." (More)
January 14, 2013 In an interview Saturday morning, Marci
Hamilton, one of the lead attorneys for the Village
of Pomona, told Preserve Ramapo she was very pleased with the decision from U.S. District Judge Kenneth
Karas. "He did a great job," she said. "He called all of the relevant case law and was absolutely clear that no
one comes into a community and gets to build without first making an application." Without this clarification,
she explained, you would have the federal government (through the RLUIPA law) establishing itself as a local
governmental authority, controlling land use and development. (More)
School district makes big cuts--E. Ramapo axes teachers and sports
January 9, 2013 "A
week ahead of a state deadline to get a deficit-reduction plan in
place, the East Ramapo school board approved
eliminating six music teachers and almost all spring sports and plans to borrow nearly $10 million to plug its massive deficit. The decisions,
voted on during a meeting Tuesday night, followed a tense month of budget discussions that involved public outcry from hundreds of
parents and students who protested initial proposals to cut kindergarten and the entire elementary music and art program. Major budget
cuts are imperative if the district is to meet a state deadline next week requiring it to submit a plan to address the deficit and balance
its budget, including payment of $5 million in overdue bills to Rockland Board of Cooperative Educational Services." Complete story here.
mount against Minisceongo Park shopping center--Ramapo and
Haverstraw boards targeted
January 7, 2013
"Opponents of the
proposed Minisceongo Park shopping center have filed another set of
lawsuits against the towns
of Haverstraw and Ramapo. The development is proposed for a 53-acre lot that straddles the Haverstraw and Ramapo border on
Route 202 near Exit 13 of the Palisades Interstate Parkway. One of the recent lawsuits was filed by the village of Pomona, which
is challenging the Haverstraw and Ramapo planning board actions. Other lawsuits were filed by local businesses including Green Earth
Farms Rockland LLC, Paint’N Place Inc., 202 United Development Corp., Parkway Realty Corp., and Good Council Realty Ltd. and John
McDowell, who challenge actions by the Haverstraw town Planning Board and the Rampo town planning and zoning boards." Journal
January 5, 2013
"The debate over
the controversial Patrick
Farm development will move to a public stage next week when
residents get a chance to voice their opinions to state regulators.
New York’s Department of Environmental Conservation has scheduled
a legislative public hearing for Monday at the Joseph T. St. Lawrence
Community, Health and Sports Center, 115 Torne Valley Road, Hillburn.
Sessions at 3 and 6:30 p.m. are intended to solicit public comment as
part of the ongoing environmental review from the state agency,
which needs to sign off on two permits before construction begins.
DEC spokeswoman Wendy Rosenbach said the agency was taking the
concern over the development’s impact seriously." Complete story here.
Conceptual photo shows development proposed for the Patrick Farm Property
January 4, 2013 "A
man involved in the Spring Valley water-balloon incident — in which 50
men surrounded a
family — agreed Thursday to accept 40 hours of community service and sign a letter of apology to the family of
Sherry Scott, the village clerk. As part of the court agreement, Solomon Simkowitz, 40, of Wesley Hills will
see charges that he pushed Scott and harassed her family on June 15, 2011, dismissed if he stays out of trouble
for six months after finishing his community service. The incident erupted when Scott’s then-11-year-old daughter
tossed a water balloon and hit a car driven by a Hasidic Jew, who was turning off Monsey Boulevard onto Fletcher Drive.
The driver called the Chaverim of Rockland, a volunteer group that assists community members. About 40 to 50 members
of Chaverim descended on the apartment where the Scotts live on Fletcher Drive, police said. Spring Valley police and Scott contend the driver
chased Scott’s daughter, who was then protected by a 17-year-old cousin. Scott and her son, Junathan McNeil Sr., 36, came outside. The Chaverim
and the Scott family began pushing each other, as Scott’s daughter Shatiya tried to get into her apartment. At some point, Scott said Simkowitz
pushed her against a brick wall, injuring her leg and back. Spring Valley police charged Simkowitz with third-degree assault and second-degree
harassment and Jacobowitz with second-degree reckless endangerment, second-degree unlawful imprisonment and second-degree harassment."
Complete story here on LoHud.
January 3, 2013
"The East Ramapo school district has just less than two weeks to get
a plan in place to address its multimillion-dollar
deficit and pay overdue debts to Rockland BOCES, state education officials warned Thursday.A letter handed down from Deputy
Commissioner Ken Slentz is a second request to Superintendent of Schools Joel Klein for East Ramapo to submit a plan and timeline
for addressing its estimated $8 million deficit and balance its budget, including payment of some $5 million in back bills it owes to
Rockland BOCES.Today’s letter follows an initial Dec. 14 request from Assistant Commissioner Charles Szuberla Jr. that gave the
district until Jan. 2 to submit the plan — a deadline East Ramapo missed. If school board members willfully disobey or ignore an
order of the commissioner, he can remove them from office, though the only way the state education department can actually
take over a school district is if legislation is passed to authorize it." Journal story here.
Town of Ramapo Kicks After-school Tutoring Program out of Spring Valley Site
January 1, 2013 "When
schools reopen Wednesday, a few dozen kids who attend a local
after-school tutoring program — and their
parents — may be out of luck because the town of Ramapo has ordered the owner to stop operating out of its space at the Cultural
Arts Center.In a Dec. 24 letter to Jodi Georges, director of the program, Ramapo Town Attorney Michael Klein said use of the space
on Dr. Berg Lane hasn’t been approved by the Town Board. Furthermore, he said, the town hasn’t received proof the program is
licensed, insured and certified to operate as a not-for-profit. Georges has been using the space for about three years after signing
an agreement in 2009 with Spring Valley village Trustee Demeza Delhomme, who manages use of the center by not-for-profits that
serve seniors, youth and other community groups. The space is provided rent-free to these groups by the town, which owns the
building, but the agreement authorizing Georges to run a “not-for-profit after-school homework assistance and enrichment agency”
from noon to 7 p.m. five days a week is not town-approved, according to Klein." Journal News story here. For more information
on the connection between Trustee Delhomme and Supervisor St. Lawrence see these documents.
December 30, 2012 "Tucked
into a wooded hill on the land — some 145 acres of sprawling forest and
field off Chestnut Ridge
Road — is a tiny cemetery containing the graves of perhaps a dozen Talmans, several of whom fought in the Revolutionary War,
Talman’s father told him. According to the family, whose ancestors were some of the earliest settlers of Rockland County, the
property was acquired by Douwe H. Talman in 1796. It changed hands over the years and was eventually owned by the Edwin
Gould Foundation in the 1920s, according to records from the Historical Society of Rockland County. Earlier this month, and after
years of attempts, the Edwin Gould Foundation, based in Manhattan, sold the property to a local limited liability company
for $9.3 million." Complete Journal News coverage here.
December 28, 2012 "Sen.
David Carlucci, D-New City, plans to introduce legislation that will
increase the payout for education
funding from lottery winnings by 10 percent. That, and adding a portion of unclaimed prize winnings to a pool for education,
could raise about $700 million for schools without increasing taxes, Carlucci said. Two other bills that were introduced in 2011
but stalled in committee will be reintroduced in the new session, he said. These are a bill to change the state aid formula to
provide more money to the struggling district, and another that would allow the commissioner of education to intervene." Click
here for complete story.
December 27, 2012 A
letter sent last week to Dr. Joel Klein Superintendent of the East
Ramapo Central School District outlined
violations of Federal and New York State laws regarding the placement of special needs students in the district. Many have been
placed in private schools bypassing required reviews and offering no documentation of the placements. The illegal placements
have been made by a single person handling the review. The violations go back to July of this year. The district has been warned
several times of the violations with no change in its disregard of the law. The letter sent last Friday explains the violations, itemizes
the demands needed to bring the district into compliance, and demands that the letter be posted for public viewing on the East Ramapo
website in the announcements section. (The letter is dated Dec 19 and today, Dec 27, it still is not on the website.) If the decision has
been made to hold off on posting this document until after the next Board meeting, Jan 8, we offer this copy. Feel free to forward
the PDF on to other interested members of the school community--that's what the State intended.
Law stymies savings if East Ramapo district cuts kindergarten
December 15, 2012 "With
the solvency of Rockland BOCES in peril, the state education department
sent a letter
Friday to East Ramapo school officials demanding that they balance their budget and pay area education cooperatives
about $5 million in back bills, Newsday has learned. The missive appears to be the first step in a process that, without
cooperation from district officials, could result in a state takeover of the financially troubled district. "I'm very concerned
about the decisions the district is making around its finances, including the failure to pay for the BOCES services," State
Education Commissioner John King Jr. told Newsday Friday. "We are committed to exercising whatever authority we have
to assure that students are well served." East Ramapo school officials estimated that, without cuts, they won't be able to
make payroll at the end of the school year. Still, when faced with public outcry at a Dec. 4 meeting, the school board
balked at making any decisions and Orthodox Jewish board members, who hold a majority, abruptly left the meeting
as public comment began." Read the complete Newsday article here.
Ramapo Stadium Foes Accuse Town
of 'End Run' on
Public in Debt Vote
December 14, 2012
"It’s been almost two years
since town taxpayers first became obligated to back
$25 million in debt for Ramapo’s controversial baseball stadium. The Town Board’s decision last week
to extend that obligation past the original five-year agreement has critics worried that taxpayers could
get slammed down the road if revenues from the stadium and another project, the Ramapo Commons
housing development, don’t roll in as expected. The way the vote was held — as an unannounced “new
business” item approved at the tail end of a nearly three-hour board meeting Dec. 3 — also has drawn the
ire of critics who’ve long opposed the stadium financing. Members of Preserve Ramapo — a grassroots political
group whose members have challenged Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence — claim the town purposely
shielded the vote from the public and further kept taxpayers in the dark by failing to provide documents
from the meeting right away." The complete story on LoHud site can be read here.
Slipshod governance on Ramapo stadium financing
Journal News Comments on Illegal $25m Bond Vote
New York State Dept. of
Environmental Conservation Orders
Public Hearing on Environmental Issues at Patrick Farm
December 10, 2012 The DEC has issued an
order for the developer of the Patrick Farm project,
Yechiel Lebovits, to set up a public hearing in Ramapo. The order explains: "Because a significant degree of
public interest exists, DEC has made a determination to hold a Legislative Public Hearing." The project
sponsor, Levovits, must arrange for a suitable venue for the hearing and to secure the services of a steno-
grapher. An Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) will be assigned to the hearing. The meeting will most likely
take place in January. Read the text of the DEC letter here.
Boulders’ Off-season Rocky—Owners Fire the GM and the League
Scrambles to Replace another Failed Franchise
December 10, 2012 Now there are four. When the Rockland Boulders
joined the Can-Am League, two seasons ago,
there were eight teams from New Jersey, New York, New England and Canada. Today, only four remain as the other
half of the league has gone belly up. At home, here in Rockland, the Boulders prepared for the upcoming season by
firing the team’s general manager Dave LaPoint. (More)
Sources: Ramapo board OKs refinancing $25M in ballpark debt to extend repayment
December 8, 2012 "With
a mega debt payment looming for the Rockland Boulders ballpark next
year, the Town Board
this week approved refinancing about $25 million in costs associated with the park, sources with knowledge of the
decision told The Journal News/LoHud.com. The board voted unanimously, minus one absent member, late Monday
to refinance the debt that funded construction of the park in order to spread repayments over a longer term and lock
in a lower interest rate, the sources said. Numerous town employees and elected officials refused to speak about the
matter on the record. The debt was issued as five-year bonds by Ramapo Local Development Corp. and guaranteed
by the town for construction of the 3,500-plus seat baseball stadium, known as Provident Bank Park. The park is home
to the Rockland Boulders and opened for its inaugural season in June 2011." Complete Journal News story here.
Stavisky's Dual Role and the Inherent Conflicts
December 5, 2012 "Apparently
a flaw in the election law allows a party chairman to be approved
by a county Legislature as the election commissioner for that party. It may be legal, but it isn’t right!
What will Mrs. Stavisky do when a candidate supported by her party machine is challenged by an
independent candidate? Under the law, she will have the power to rule their petition invalid and force
the independent candidate to go to court to overturn her decision. Many Democratic committeemen
want Ann Marie Kelly to remain their impartial Democratic election commissioner. Mrs. Stavisky obviously
did her best to prevent an open meeting. She also claims no conflict of interest exists between the two roles."
Read here the full text of two letters to The Journal News about Kristin Stavisky's dual political roles on the Board
of Elections and as head of the Rockland Democratic party.
Time Off Policy Defined--Ramapo Puts Vacation Rules in Writing
December 4, 2012 "A new
policy allows town employees to use vacation, personal or other earned
time off to observe religious holidays. The policy puts in writing an established town practice of
accommodating employees who request to leave a few hours early Fridays to observe Shabbat, for
example, or take off a day here and there for a holiday, Ramapo Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence
said.The policy was adopted by the Town Board on Monday night and takes effect immediately." Read
the Journal News story here. Full text of the new rules here.
Democrats question party chief Stavisky's dual role,
nominated as election commissioner
November 29, 2012 "Kristen
Zebrowski Stavisky’s selection as Rockland County’s Democratic election
commissioner on Monday surprised no one. But it has caused rumblings within her party, with some
committee members saying the current Democratic election commissioner, Ann Marie Kelly, was forced
out of her position and Stravisky engineered her selection in such a way that her opponents did not make
it to the meeting in New City where she was voted in.Stavisky has denied the charges." Full story here.
November 25, 2012 "The
tremendous damaging coastal effects of the Hurricane
Sandy has added grave new concern to the public view of United Water desalination
proposal. The United Water desalination pilot plant pump house and intake sites
are on the shore line of Haverstraw Bay just 3.5 miles south of Indian Point Nuclear
power station." (Full text of the Letter to the Editor in Our Town here.)
November 24, 2012 "At the Nov. 14
Planning Board meeting, community residents, wetlands experts and
local business owners voiced objections to the project, ranging from the negative impact on the character
of the community, devastating effect on local businesses to the destructive impact on the wetlands in the
area and ultimately our drinking water and the Hudson River. The objections by the public continued to be
expressed well after 10 p.m. The response from the developer’s paid consultants could be summed up this
way: 'We are the experts, the local residents are not, so trust us.' " (More)
November 24, 2012
Stavisky has spent months lobbying for support to secure the post and,
during the party’s convention on Monday, is likely to tie up the job because she already has the key backing
of the party’s executive committee. If Stavisky’s appointment is approved by the Rockland County Legislature,
which is virtually guaranteed, she would simultaneously come to hold one job that requires her to be objective
and fair to all political office seekers and another where she is helping the efforts of a candidate who is backed
by her party. She said she wasn’t worried about a conflict." Read full text of The Journal News story here.
November 21, 2012 "The
town adopted its tax-cap-busting budget Tuesday, voting 3-2 to pass a
spending plan for 2013. Spending will increase about $8.5 million this year, or 10 percent over the current
budget.Under the plan, town taxes will rise 9.43 percent, meaning most taxpayers will pay $46.80 more annually
for every $50,000 of assessed value."
Board Members Voted (Yes vote approves tax increase--No vote opposes the
Comments cited were given to The Journal News Mareesa Nicosia (full coverage can be read here)
Brendel Logan Voted YES
St. Lawrence said he wasn’t concerned that the vote wasn’t unanimous. Board members “have their own minds and they can vote however they see fit as to whether they like or dislike the budget.”
described the budget as imperfect yet fair and said he voted
with public safety as his priority.
“I always put public safety before politics, and the public safety part of this budget is what I like,” he said.
taxes 9 percent is unacceptable,” he said. “To blame the county,
you know, two wrongs don’t make a right.”
He added: “The supervisor’s attitude was the budget is his way or the highway, and I chose the highway.”
think anybody wants tax increases, but I wanted to see more cuts
in spending and more ideas for revenue enhancement to balance
the budget without raising taxes,” he said. “That wasn’t in
place so I voted ‘no.’”
Read the Community View: Tax Increase Isn't Solution to Ramapo's Debt Crisis here.
November 21, 2012
"Faced with a
growing $7 million deficit, the East Ramapo school district is looking
again to cut nonmandated programs and staff to close its budget gap. Among the possibilities the district will
consider are cutting school nurses, shortening the school day, cuts to elementary art and music, and centralizing
special services for private-school students. Eliminating the kindergarten program, which was proposed last spring
and was curtailed from full day to half day this year, is another consideration. But Superintendent Joel Klein, in
addressing more than 60 people including parents, staff, the school board and administrators at a meeting at Kakiat
Elementary School on Tuesday night, said he does not support the measure, which would affect more than 700 students."
Complete Journal News coverage here.
November 20, 2012 "Rockland
County approaches $100 million in debt, we recently had a 30 percent
tax increase, and a 4 percent surcharge added to our electric bill. Guess who is running for county executive?
Ilan Schoenberger, chairman of the Budget and Finance Committee, the very person who year after year was
responsible for advancing flawed budgets from County Executive C. Scott Vanderhoef." Read the full text of
the letter to The Journal News here.
November 20, 2012 "After
a decade of fighting a public school board dominated by Orthodox Jews in
suburban New York, Oscar Cohen, a soft-spoken 71-year-old with a reputation for composure, is starting
to get angry.'You have eight school districts in Rockland County,' the retired school administrator told the
Forward recently. “One is cutting every nonmandated service to the bone. Seven are not. Ninety percent
of the kids going to the one are children of color. Is something wrong with that picture?' " (More from the
Jewish Daily Forward here)
October 25, 2012 "In
late summer, Preserve Ramapo collected thousands of signatures and
petitions to the town clerk, aiming to land two propositions on the ballot in next month’s general election:
one to increase the number of Town Board members from four to six and one to establish a ward system in
which each Town Board member would represent a designated geographic area. Board members are now
elected at large. Members of the group — which opposes town Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence and
many of his financial decisions — said the town needs a better system of checks and balances and their
proposals, especially a ward system, would ensure that happens." A show cause filing and an Article 78
lawsuit have now been invoked because of the town's attempt to ignore its obligations. Journal story here.
Oustatcher Prevails in Lawsuit
Against School Board and District--Another
Costly Misstep by the Board and Its Attorney
October 23, 2012 "A
judge has ruled in favor of a former East Ramapo schools superintendent
who sued the district
for breach of his contract.Ira Oustatcher filed a lawsuit in December, claiming he was owed more than $97,700 to
date because the district cut his pay — breaking the terms of his contract — after he was demoted from the superintendent
job and reassigned to his current position, principal of Pomona Middle School. Joel Klein, who was named in the lawsuit
along with the district and the Board of Education, succeeded Oustatcher as superintendent in the spring of 2011." The
board's attorney, D'Agostino, was uncharacteristically silent when asked for his opinion by the reporter. Journal story here.
October 18, 2012 "A
proposal to annex 6.87 acres of
privately owned town land to the village of New Square
received scant support Wednesday during a public hearing
that drew about two dozen residents. The annexation, which
requires the full support of the town and village boards, would
enable land that is now zoned for single-family residences to be
developed into multifamily dwellings. Applicants want to
accommodate the growing numbers of families who desire to live
together in the insular, densely populated Hasidic village." Full
text of the Journal News story here.
Ramapo Taxpayers Footing the
Bill for the Highest Paid Public Employee in
New York State--Christopher St. Lawrence insists "He's worth every penny of it"
Ramapo Police Chief Peter Brower
Governor Andrew Cuomo
St. Lawrence's explanation why Brower is the highest paid local employee in the entire State of New York:"It's a dangerous job and he's worth every penny."
October 18, 2012 New York City
Police Commissioner Ray Kelly is in charge of the largest police force
in the country--more
than 35,000 cops. Kelly is paid $205,180 for enforcing the law in the largest city in the nation (8.2 million people). Ramapo Police Chief
Peter Brower is in charge of 125 cops in a town of 126,595 in the Lower Hudson Valley and is paid $321,719. Brower earns $116,539 more than
Kelly while managing roughly 35,000 fewer officers. These outrageous numbers didn't discourage Brower's boss, Supervisor St. Lawrence,
from going on Channel 12 and insisting that his very pricey chief "[Has] a tough job, and a dangerous job. . . and he's worth every penny
of it." St. Lawrence and his Town Board (Daniel Friedman, Pat Withers, Brendel Logan, and Yitzchok Ullman) have recently voted a
9% increase in Ramapo Town taxes. Coverage in The Journal News here and the NY Post here.
The Death of a Once-Proud School District
October 16, 2012
October 16, 2012 "For the past five
years news, reports detailing the destruction of the East Ramapo School
District ("ERSD") have appeared on a regular, and recently daily, basis. This once-proud and superlative school district, that
encompasses a section of Clarkstown, has been ravaged by mismanagement and the shortsighted agenda of the ultra-Orthodox
majority on the school board. As a 1974 graduate of Spring Valley High School, I find these events especially disturbing." Read
the full text of Michael Bongiorno's Op Ed that appeared in Our Town here.
Group aims to prevent use of East Ramapo district funds for officials' legal defense
October 15, 2012 "Supporters
of a class-action lawsuit against the East Ramapo school district want
to block the Board of Education
from using public money to defend school officials in several ongoing legal actions. In a petition served on the district Friday, Spring
Valley residents Steven White and Betty Carmand ask the state education commissioner to grant an “emergency stay” on up to $2 million
in district money they say is earmarked for legal costs to defend board members, administrators and former employees.The petition is
backed by New York City public interest law firm Advocates for Justice, which filed a class-action lawsuit on behalf of some 200 parent
plaintiffs against the district this summer." Complete Journal News story here.
View: Tax increase isn't solution
to Ramapo debt crisis
Oct 9, 2012
Re "Ramapo to refinance bond debt: Plan
will save town millions," Oct. 6 article: "The 9 percent
increase in Ramapo’s tax rate in the town’s 2013 budget plan will do nothing to solve our debt crisis. At
the end of 2013, I expect that the town — and its taxpayers — will be in even deeper debt than we are now."
(Complete text here.)
October 9, 2012 "Clarkstown
will ask the state Department of Environmental Conservation to impose a
cleanup plan on a
developer whose actions officials say have caused Lake Lucille to turn brown with silt. The DEC and the Ramapo building
department have instituted a stop-work order on the developer, Joseph Herskowitz of Monsey, who is building the 18.6-acre
Sky Ridge development off Buena Vista Road in unincorporated Ramapo near the Clarkstown border. Both agencies also have
issued violations to the developer for failing to comply with stormwater controls that have allowed silt to flow a mile and a
half downstream into Crum Creek. The creek flows into Lake Lucille, off South Mountain Road in New City, which feeds the
Lake DeForest reservoir that serves Rockland and Bergen counties." Complete Journal story here.
Firefighter Slams United Water Scare Tactics Used in Promoting Desalination PlantOctober 5, 2012 Robert D. Jackson, a retired lieutenant in FDNY and a member of the Rockland County Incident Management
October 4, 2012 "Simmering
tensions between the public school community and the Orthodox majority
on the school board
boiled over this week at Grandview Elementary. Schoolyard squabbling occurred — among the adults. It was a big disappointment.
A parent-coordinated intervention Tuesday aimed to stem trespassing on school property while pupils in grades K-3 are in the building.
It quickly devolved into confrontation, with Ramapo police being called, and became yet another example of the growing strife
between the public school community and the Orthodox and Hasidic Jewish communities. As with other hot-button issues in East Ramapo,
the school board and administration could have provided remedies. Instead, the board’s longstanding inaction — even as parents and
school staff expressed concerns — exacerbated the problem." Read the entire editorial here.
October 3, 2012 "Tired
of hounding district policymakers to secure school borders against
trespassers, East Ramapo parents
took matters into their own hands Tuesday. About eight parents patrolled the grounds of Grandview Elementary for two hours,
informing dozens of walkers who were taking a shortcut through the property that they were trespassing and asking them to
find another route. A district security officer joined them. Despite parents’ demands, district officials have tacitly condoned
the presence of strangers on school grounds during school hours, alternately denying trespassing is a problem and worrying they’ll
appear anti-Semitic if they take action. Police have said they can’t do much unless “No Trespassing” signs are posted on the
property." Full text of The Journal News coverage, with video, here. Story in Newsday here.
October 2, 2012 "The
Town Board voted to bust the tax cap in July, much to the chagrin of a
group of residents who
protested the measure at Town Hall at the time. Clarkstown, Orangetown and Haverstraw also plan to exceed the cap
in 2013. Ramapo’s proposed $90,398,592 plan increases spending by some $8.4 million, or 9.3 percent more than the
2012 budget of $81,982,185. According to the 2013 proposal, townwide taxes will increase 9 percent, while residents
of unincorporated Ramapo can expect a slightly lower increase of 7.23 percent. That means for each $50,000 of assessed
value, a homeowner would pay $44.65 more in property taxes in 2013 under the townwide rate and $28.85 more
under the unincorporated rate." Complete Journal story here.
Sept. 26, 2012 "Ahead
of a financial audit due next month and following another round of
budget cuts, East Ramapo officials
say the school district faces an estimated $6 million deficit — far more than what they’ve cited in recent weeks. The district
ended the 2011-12 school year with a $1.78 million deficit and no reserves. Now, the district is adding about $1.5 million in
unanticipated expenses for transportation, special education and BOCES services, mostly due to increased enrollment, Assistant
Superintendent for Finance Michael Ivanoff said Tuesday. About 1,000 new students enrolled in East Ramapo’s private schools
this fall and 10 new private schools opened. Roughly 70 percent of students in the East Ramapo district attend private schools,
which receive public funds for transportation, books and special education." Complete Journal News coverage here.
Ramapo Asks NYS Attorney General
to Examine the Town’s New Confidentiality Policy
Sept. 25, 2012
weeks ago, Supervisor St. Lawrence and his board voted
unanimously to enact a new Confidentiality Policy. This policy threatens any
Town employee with termination and/or legal action if that employee discusses
virtually anything about town business, records, plans, or whatever St. Lawrence
deems “confidential,” with anyone outside of Town Hall. What’s confidential
includes “processes, reports, research, sources of supply, financial data” even
those things oddly classified as “confidential public information.”
The Executive Director of the Committee on Open Government at the Dept. of State in Albany has told Preserve Ramapo
that the policy is illegal, and today we have filed a formal complaint and request for an investigation by the Attorney
General’s Intergovernmental Affairs Bureau. (More)
Sept. 24, 2012 "This
does not make any mathematical sense at all. There are
several options and alternatives that can provide
additional water sources that would not include such a foolish use of ratepayer dollars. Many of the alternatives would create
construction jobs and if we invested more on fixing existing infrastructure would also result in more construction jobs. Let’s think
about a more robust and sensible solution to our water needs and protect our existing infrastructure and environment. It should not
be forgotten that UW is a private company with a corporate interest; its goal is making profits, not improving existing infrastructure,
leaving us poorly served." A practical cost analysis of the proposed United Water desalination plant by an experienced wastewater
engineer. Full text here.
Sept. 22, 2012 "State
Education Commissioner John King Jr. said Friday that he is
following developments in the troubled
East Ramapo School District and is aware that many parents are calling for state intervention. “We are looking closely, and
we are concerned,” he said at a meeting with The Journal News/LoHud.com Editorial Board. Harry Phillips, the Rockland/
Westchester/Putnam representative on the state Board of Regents, which makes education policy, went further, saying the
school district will have trouble meeting the special-education costs of the region’s fast-growing Hasidic and ultra-Orthodox
communities.“We see nothing but problems ahead,” he said. “People will have to look at some sort of takeover.” " Complete
Journal News story here.
East Ramapo forecasts more cuts after school board trims transportation, jobs
Sept. 21, 2012
"The day after the East Ramapo Board of Education voted to
eliminate three staff positions and nonmandated
transportation to private schools, an administrator said more cuts were planned soon to close the budget gap. Michael Ivanoff,
assistant superintendent for finance, did not say when the cuts would come or from where.“There are more financial challenges
on the horizon,” he said. “There will be more cuts.” The district has a budget deficit of $1.78 million and also must produce savings
to pay for about $1 million in legal costs to defend board members and administrators in a petition and lawsuit filed earlier in
the summer." Journal News story here. See also, Spring Valley High's fall play canceled by budget cuts here.
RLUIPA Documentary America's Holy War Nominated as
Finalist In Great Lakes
International Film Festival
Funny Numbers from the Ramapo Democratic Committee's Financial Report
September 18, 2012
Keeping track of local
politicians can lead you down some rather strange rabbit holes. The most
financial report from the Ramapo Democratic Committee (the July Periodic) had a few entries that should have raised both
Democratic and Republican eyebrows. Where the money went might have upset more than a few of the loyalists. That report
was followed by a second, amended periodic report, and it didn't do much to shovel cover over some rather damning entries
in the first report. (More)
Public responds to Journal News "East Ramapo District in Crisis" Series
Sept. 17, 2012 Click
for a sample of letters sent by readers responding to the two-day
about the East Ramapo School District and embattled board of ed. Link to index of Journal articles in that series here.
Ramapo Reform Democrats Run the Table
Patrick Farm: Judge nixes approval of development; Ramapo
Sept. 14, 2012 "A state Supreme Court judge has
annulled final approval for a high-density development of nearly
500 homes on
Patrick Farm that opponents argue would cripple the environment and the character of the single-family neighborhood. Based on
legal action by the Ramapo Organized for Sustainability and a Safe Aquifer, the judge ruled Ramapo violated its own rules that
require developments to undergo architectural review before the Planning Board considers final approval. As a result of the ROSA
decision, Scenic Development LLC in Monsey must put its architectural designs before the Ramapo’s Community Design Review
Committee. No date has been set." Full Journal News coverage here. Read the ROSA Press Release here.
District in crisis: East Ramapo's public- and private-school families fight for resources
Sept. 9, 2012 "One week after East
Ramapo became the only school district in the region to see its
budget defeated by voters,
school board Vice President Daniel Schwartz warned at a meeting that the district faced a “terrible, terrible crisis.” The crisis
he referred to was not the impending dismissal of another 90 jobs, including all social workers and most teaching assistants.
It was not the reduction of kindergarten from full day to half-day or the shriveling of art, music and sports programs, or the
possibility that a second defeated budget would eviscerate the school system like a carpet bombing. The crisis that Schwartz
bemoaned in May was a creeping anti-Semitism spurred by distrust of the school board, which since 2005 has been run by majorities
of Hasidic and other Orthodox Jews who send their children to private schools." Full Journal story here.
provides an overview of The Journal News' impressive coverage
that includes 14 news stories published
over two days, Sept 9 and 10. The news items cover the economics, the New York State investigations, the
Comptroller's reports, the state intervention in two attempted sales of grammar schools, the unprofessional
behavior of the Board's attorney, the class action lawsuit against the board members, and more. There is additional
information and video the newspaper's online site. Check out the Index Page here for links to all the stories.
East Ramapo needs intervention: Journal News Editorial
Sept. 9, 2012 "With so much wrong in
East Ramapo school district, it’s hard to see how it can survive
without intervention at the
state or federal level. It will need that and much more. The East Ramapo school district is broke. There’s not a penny in reserve funds,
and the district is operating at a deficit. A litany of other concerns are set forth in disturbing detail in today’s Journal News/LoHud.com
special investigation, A District in Crisis. School board members have a fiduciary responsibility to make sound decisions on behalf of the
public schools and the property taxpayers, and the East Ramapo school board has failed miserably." Full text of the editorial here.
to All for a Successful Ward Petition Drive
Education cuts hurt East Ramapo kids
Sept. 4, 2012 Letter in The Journal News "School
starts this week and I ask, what is happening in East Ramapo?
Are they ready? It was announced at the last board meeting that the fund balance is 90 projected to be minus $1.7 million.
We have seen egregious cuts to our children’s education over the past few years and it was also announced that due to
pending litigation costs there could be even more cuts. Is it even legal to carry a negative fund balance? Full letter.
Sept. 2, 2012 "Activists
with the grassroots political group Preserve Ramapo are reviving an
effort that’s been thwarted in
past years to seek a public vote that would change the composition of the Town Board. Members want to establish a ward
system in which each Town Board member would represent a designated geographic area. Board members are now elected at large.
Rockland sues Ramapo over emergency communications equipment
Ramapo planners won't allow 7 antennas
August 28, 2012 "Rockland
County is suing the Town of Ramapo after a Planning Board rejected
the county’s bid to install emergency
communications equipment on a wireless tower in a residential neighborhood in Monsey. The rejection, which came after a
contentious May meeting of Ramapo’s Planning Board, blocked the county’s attempt to install seven antennas and an equipment
shelter at the tower, which residents argue would increase health risks as well as truck traffic in the neighborhood, since the
upgrades would require monthly maintenance. The equipment would fill in gaps in the wireless coverage for the county’s emergency
communications, which include radio from police, fire, and other officials. The tower, on Eastview Road in Monsey, is owned by a
division of Cablevision and has existed at the site for decades." Journal story here.
27, 2012 Last Friday, the economically besieged Can-Am team,
the Worcester Tornadoes,
was scheduled to play the Quebec Capitales at home. When the team took the field, they were
wearing the yellow and black uniforms of the "Grays." The Grays were a Can-Am "traveling team"
that disappeared five years ago. The reason for the name change was that it was the only
alternative to a shirts-and-skins dress code for the contest. The Tornadoes' uniforms had been seized under court order
granted to the Hilton Garden Inn, which is owed $32,562.00 by the team. (More)
August 27, 2012 "Two
more legal actions seeking to block development of the 208-acre
Patrick Farm have been reinstated,
as a state appeals court ordered a judge to consider challenges to Ramapo’s decisions on environmental impacts and increasing
the housing density for the property. The Appellate Division panel ruled that Supreme Court Justice Linda Jamieson erred when
she dismissed legal challenges in 2011 by property neighbors Sonya and Milton Shapiro and Elizabeth Youngewirth. An appeals
panel ruled in May that Jamieson also erred by denying Pomona’s legal challenge on the same grounds. Those three cases join
six other legal actions challenging the approvals and environmental reviews for the Patrick Farm development." Journal News
coverage here. Text of the court decision can be read here.
August 25, 2012 "Holding signs and chanting, “Save our
schools,” about 100 East Ramapo students and alumni demonstrated
in front of their alma mater Thursday night, decrying school board decisions to cut funding and rallying in support of a lawsuit
that targets the district’s leadership." Complete Journal News coverage here. Video of the students who spoke at the
press conference can be seen at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOsCjzddgFk&feature=youtu.be. President of the Spring
Valley Branch of the NAACP, Mr Willie Trotman, talks about Education and standing behind our children. View this part of the
Press Conference here http://youtu.be/ZsISeUhq6Nc.
August 23, 2012 "Assemblywoman
Ellen Jaffee wants the state to reopen a 2006 rate case that
required United Water New York
to develop a long-term water supply solution. Jaffee asked that the agency require an independent financial analysis of possible
alternatives to the water treatment plant, which, she said, is estimated to cost between $139.2 million and $189.3 million. She
also asked the PSC to hold public hearings to consider “new information and unforeseen circumstances" to determine whether
a joint proposal that settled the rate case should be amended or vacated." I felt that we needed to raise these issues," Jaffee
said Wednesday. "United Water hasn’t done its due diligence and it needs to do more.' " Full text of The Journal News story here.
Clash over videotape interrupts East Ramapo school board meeting
August 22, 2012
Ramapo school board meeting broke up early, delaying time-sensitive
votes — including one related
to the federal lawsuit filed against the board — because of a dispute over a woman’s right to videotape the meeting that nearly
led to her arrest. Board members and about 50 members of the public were listening to a presentation of a recent audit report
when board President Daniel Schwartz interrupted in an attempt to enforce a new videotaping policy. The policy, which Schwartz
proposed after being elected board president in July, limits taping of the public meetings to a designated area at the back of the
room. [The policy violates the public's right as defined in a Committee on Open Government legal opinion given to the board.] “When
you’re ready to arrest me, just drag me out,” said [the videographer Emilia] White, after refusing Schwartz’s repeated requests for her
to move to the back of the room because, he said, her taping from the location was interfering with the meeting. White, who is Haitian,
added, “In the back of the room to me means the back of the bus.” Full Journal News coverage here.
You can view the video from the August 21, 2012 meeting when
Emilia White was threatened with arrest for video taping at a School
at this site: http://youtu.be/woB0K9aUfW4
August 17, 2012
prosecutors say disparaging remarks Town Justice David J. Stein
supposedly made about a civil rights
leader show he cannot properly judge three men accused of misdemeanor charges after a Spring Valley incident involving a water balloon.
In June 2011, up to 50 members of an Orthodox Jewish group confronted Spring Valley Village Clerk Sherry Scott, her daughter, son and other
family members outside their home on Fletcher Road after a car was hit by a water balloon. During a March 29 discussion in Stein’s chambers,
Stein told the prosecutor and defense attorney that he didn’t think an agreement could be reached. “I doubt it,” Stein said, according to the
court papers. “I knew Bill Scott (Sherry Scott’s father) and he was the biggest racist in Rockland County and I know Sherry Scott.” Pressed by
prosecutor Jason Rosenwasser to expound on his comment, Stein said, “Well, she is his daughter.” Rosenwasser then asked Stein to recuse himself,
contending “that due to Your Honor’s preconceived opinion about Bill and Sherry Scott it is impossible for you to be fair and impartial in these cases,
cases which candidly all have racial undertones.” Stein refused to recuse himself and declined to speak on the record about his comments." Complete
Journal News story here.
Minisceongo Park development foes get more time to review plan
August 15, 2012
"The head of the Haverstraw Planning Board has decided to give
opponents of the proposed Minisceongo
Park development more time to learn about what would be the largest shopping center in northern Rockland County. The 53-acre
lot, a former sand and gravel pit, straddles the Haverstraw-Ramapo border on Route 202 near Exit 13 of the Palisades Interstate
Parkway. After more than two hours of public participation, Planning Chairman Salvatore Corallo told the audience that the board
would continue the public hearing not in September, but Oct. 10, partly because the town’s Zoning Board of Appeals is still considering
parking variances, and partly because people can get more time to study the environmental review documents. 'You have roughly
60 days, rather than 30 days, to review,' Corallo told the public." Complete Journal News coverage here.
Update: Can-Am Tornadoes $90,000 in the red--Two Companies Initiate Lawsuits
August 14, 2012 Today's Worcester Telegram reports that
the last-place Massachusetts team has $7,500 in a bank account,
has been attached. There are two vendors suing for more than $30,000, and the city of Worcester is owed for police details from
2007 through 2010 and fire details from July 2011 through August 7 of this year--the tab so far totals $59,140. If this team goes the
way of the recently failed Pittsfield Colonials, Brockton Rox, and NY Federals, there will only be four teams left in the Can-Am League.
Read Two Companies Sue Tornadoes Over Bills here.
The Cleaning Company Shows up with Court
to Take Possession of the Can Am League Worcester
Tornadoes’ Uniforms, Bats, Gloves and Game Receipts
August 14, 2012 "The
Enterprise Cleaning Co. of Worcester cleans the Hanover Insurance
Park stadium, bathrooms and concourses at a discounted rate and has not been paid for
any of its services this year, company president Mr. Buchalter said, a pattern that has
played out for the past two years, he said. The Tornadoes are in their eighth season.
Chief Executive Officer Todd Breighner bought the team after the 2009 season and he inherited $500,000 in debt
from the previous owners." (More)
Amended copy of the East Ramapo Parents Class Action Lawsuit here
Parents to sue East Ramapo School District
August 7, 2012 "A class-action lawsuit brought on by a
bevy of parents claims East Ramapo school district’s top
officials and Board of Education members past and present have repeatedly schemed to 'siphon off public money
to support private religious institutions.' Among other claims, the group alleges the district has segregated students
in special-education programs based on their race, at taxpayers’ expense, according to a draft version of the lawsuit
provided to The Journal News/Lohud.com by the public-interest law firm Advocates for Justice. The 60-plus-page
document, expected to be filed in federal court Tuesday, is the latest legal blow to the struggling district as a conflict
intensifies between parents of public-school students and the Orthodox and Hasidic school-board majority that makes
decisions on behalf of those students." Journal News coverage here.
East Ramapo School Board refuses AG's request to have lawyers
in probe--Continue to withhold more than 1,300 documents
August 2, 2012 "Lawyers for the East Ramapo school
district are seeking to sue state Attorney General Eric T.
Schneiderman over their right to represent Board of Education members in the continuing state investigation
of the controversial attempted sales of two school buildings. Lawyers Albert D’Agostino and Dominick Minerva,
both of Long Island, have worked for East Ramapo for the past three years and are representing school board
members in the attorney general’s investigation into “alleged improprieties” in the district’s attempts to sell
two former elementary schools to private religious schools." Complete Journal News story here.
Violent Crime Numbers Spike in Ramapo--Up 72% from 2007 to 2011,
Most Accelerated Increase in the County
August 1, 2012According to disturbing recent statistics on reported criminal activity, the Rockland town with
Parents to sue East Ramapo school board over public funds
July 31, 2012 "A
growing number of parents with children in East Ramapo public schools
plan to file a lawsuit in
the coming days seeking millions in damages from current and former school board members they allege were
involved in a pattern of abuse of millions of public dollars used to support private schools. Arthur Schwartz, the
group’s attorney and head of the New York-based nonprofit public interest firm Advocates for Justice said 'This
lawsuit would seek to recover damages from the people who wasted millions of dollars in taxpayer money.' He
said the suit will target former school board members as well as the five addressed in the earlier petition: school
board President Daniel Schwartz, Vice President Yehuda Weissmandl, and members Moses Friedman, Moshe Hopstein
and Eliyahu Solomon. Parents want the board members to be held personally liable for up to millions in damages and
want to bar them from using district dollars to defend themselves, with the money then returned to the district." Read
the full text of The Journal News story here.
Governor Cuomo Vetoes Private School Tuition Bill
July 31, 2012 After passage in both legislative houses in Albany,
the Governor returned the Senate version of
the bill with his signed veto and reasons for his rejection of the proposed law. Read the full text of his veto
here. From The Journal News: "The amended special-education bill drew a huge response from public-school
districts and private, religious-based school advocates across the area once it was unveiled. Critics said the
amendment could cost millions of tax dollars to finance, was a back-door voucher system that undermined the
separation of church and state, and could create a segregated school program for the state’s most fragile
children." Complete Journal coverage can be read here.
By Peter Applebome
The New York Times Jvetuly 28, 2012
SPRING VALLEY, N.Y. — In the East Ramapo Central School District here, the children of Caribbean and Latin American
immigrants have filled the classrooms in recent years. About 85 percent of the students are black or Hispanic, and only
7 percent are white. But on the school board, seven of the nine seats are held by Orthodox Jews. Now, after years of
increasingly bitter discord between parents and the board, the parents are trying to force the state to intervene. (More)
ABC News Coverage of Impending
Federal Lawsuit Against the East
Ramapo School Board
July 26, 2012 Click
video replay of
the story broadcast today.
New Cost Overruns for Ballpark Construction
Rolling In--Bill for June is $143,785.15
July 26, 2012 If you thought the
construction at the Provident Ballpark was completed, unfortunately,
mistaken. The cost overruns keep coming as a continuing insult to the taxpayers who voted to reject paying
these bills more than a year and a half ago. The Supervisor and Town Board just voted another $144K to
Morano Brothers and Holt Construction Corp. That's the June bill for taxpayers, and keep in mind that these
costs are for change orders--cost overruns--tariffs for lousy planning. (More)
Probe Looks at Spring Valley Judge-Alan Simon in
the Middle of another Controversy
June 24, 2012 "Justice Alan Simon is being investigated by police
for harassment involving a confrontation with
an intern assigned by the mayor to work in the justice court clerk’s office. Simon became concerned that someone
he didn’t interview or approve to work in the office had access to confidential court files, his lawyer, William Frank,
said Monday, confirming his client was under police investigation. Simon also is accused of threatening to have the mayor,
police officers and other court personnel arrested or held in contempt of his court or both for not following his orders. Another
issue is whether Simon will be reviewed by state court authorities such as the 9th Judicial District or the state Office of
Judicial Conduct. Rockland County Court Judge Charles Apotheker, who oversees the Justice Court for the district, didn’t
have any comment on Simon or the events in Spring Valley." Read the full story in The Journal News here.
July 24, 2012 In a letter to the
Governor, the Rockland County AARP Chapter 1577 warns of
the impact of
the proposed desalination plan. Read the full text of the letter presented recently to Cuomo here.
Five East Ramapo School Board Members face ouster attempt,
accused of using funds to support religious schools
July 19, 2012 "Critics of the East Ramapo Board of Education are
asking the state education commissioner to
remove Orthodox and Hasidic board members they say have spent millions of taxpayer dollars to support
private religious schools while ignoring the growing needs of students in the public schools. The New
York-based public interest law firm Advocates for Justice, on behalf of 14 East Ramapo parents and
community members, said it is calling for the removal of five board members and the appointment
of a state monitor to oversee all spending and special-education placements at the district." (Journal News)
The five targeted for removal are Board President Daniel Schwartz, VP Yehuda Weissmandl, Moses Friedman,
Moshe Hopstein, and Eliyahu Solomon. (More)
North Jersey drinking water going to waste as system leaks lose 25%
July 17, 2012 The Record reports: "Last
year alone, United Water could not account for 26 percent of the water
treated and pumped. That amounts to 10.6 billion gallons, enough to fill the Oradell Reservoir three times over. 'United
Water has a lot of leaks in their system. It’s one of the leakiest systems I know,' said Robert Kecskes, a retired water
supply expert for the state Department of Environmental Protection." Now consider this: "In the summer of 2007, downriver
from Lake DeForest at the Oradell (N.J.) Reservoir, United Water was discharging 7.31 million gallons per day. This is nearly
as much water as the 7.5 million gallons per day that the proposed Haverstraw desalination plant would produce at full
build-out and 5 million gallons per day more than the historical daily median flow." Are Rockland ratepayers going to pay
for United Water's failure to maintain its own infrastructure in order to supplement UW New Jersey customers?" Read the Record
Albany Bill Would Add Family to Special Education Factors (New York Times)
July 15, 2012 "Critics of the bill, including the
administration of Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, said the language in the
bill was too broad and could cover anything from clothing or food preferences to the cultural norms and customs practiced
in Orthodox Jewish, Roman Catholic or other religious households." Article here.
Questions About Town of Ramapo Finances--Letter to the Comptroller
July 12, 2012 In a letter sent to the Chief Examiner for the
NYS Comptroller's Office, Bob Rhodes addresses a
number of financial questions that remain unanswered by the town administration. Read the full text of the letter here.
County Legislators Turn their Backs on East Ramapo Parents and Students
July 11, 2012 Last night’s Rockland County Legislature meeting
began with a short ceremony honoring one of the most
celebrated East Ramapo High teachers, Michael Smith. Leader of the justifiably famous East Ramapo Marching Band,
Smith was recently fired, joining hundreds of staff that have been let go in this year’s round of devastating cuts. But
it turned out to be just more empty political theater as many of those same legislators who were pushing in to be
photographed with Smith were the same members who later in the evening refused to allow a vote on a resolution
requesting Governor Cuomo to veto a bill that has the potential to destroy what’s left of the East Ramapo school
district. (More, including how each member voted)
Read My Lips
“The stadium will
be built with private money.
There will be no taxpayer dollars. I got the
message.” (Sept. 2010)
More than $60 million taxpayer dollars later:
to increase taxes and not be limited by the state 2% cap.
(Friedman—Agreed; Logan—Agreed; Ullman—Abstained; St. Lawrence—Agreed;
Withers—absent July 2012) The Bill for the taxpayers? 8.9% for starters
July 10, 2012 “Citing
a budget shortfall as it plans for 2013, the Town Board approved a plan
to override the state’s
2 percent tax-levy cap, despite opposition from angry residents who demonstrated at Town Hall on Monday. The board
voted 3-0 Monday night, with one abstention and one member absent.The vote followed a lengthy public hearing during
which residents opposed to the override plan alternately assailed officials for mishandling their money and for holding a
budget-related public hearing in the dead of summer with little notice.” Full Journal News coverage here.
Legislator Meyers to Introduce Resolution
at County Legislature Tuesday
Urging Governor to Veto Special Needs Student Placement Bill
July 8, 2012 The Journal News, The
Spring Valley Chapter of the NAACP, even the Huffington Post have
called on Governor Cuomo to veto a bill that will in effect create a voucher system for private schools,
an illegally segregated school system, and overwhelming new debt for the East Ramapo School District as
well as districts around the state. Parents have been calling the Governor's office, and Tuesday Joseph Meyers
will ask the County Legislator to adopt a resolution expressing their legislature's agreement with the parents,
the paper, the NAACP, and news outlets like the Huffington Post. You can read the resolution here.
And please join the East Ramapo parents and taxpayers at 7pm Tuesday at the Rockland County Legislative meeting.
Ramapo Dumps Provident Bank—Or—
Provident Bank Dumps Ramapo
July 3, 2012 The resolution that was passed at the town board
meeting contained no explanation. And there was no discussion
at the board meeting to explain the removal of Ramapo bank
deposits from the bank that christened Chris St. Lawrence’s ballpark.
The message simply read: "Cross River Bank is hereby designated as
official depository for Town of Ramapo funds for the remainder of 2012." Cross River Bank is not in Ramapo,
it’s not even in the State of New York. Why the offloading of tax revenues and other deposits out of state? (More)
JN Editorial: N.Y. special-education bill
many districts with soaring costs
June 27, 2012 "Amid last week’s
bill-passing whirlwind in Albany, legislators passed a bill designed to
special-education families by demanding districts give consideration to cultural and family background when
making placement decisions, and by mandating a rapid timetable for tuition reimbursement when a parent
decides to place a child in a different program than what a district recommends. Despite its laudable goals,
the bill likely oversteps federal rules, and sets up skyrocketing special-education costs for some districts.
Gov. Andrew Cuomo should veto the bill, and encourage legislators to craft reforms that work for families
and are affordable for school districts." (More--including full text of the bill)
Who is Kalman Weber?
June 25, 2012 Kalman Weber is usually
described as a community activist. He is
the president of the South East Ramapo Taxpayer’s Association. That’s the short
answer to the question of who he is. But more important than the self-ascribed
titles, the question should also be viewed from the vantage point of what Kalman
Weber does. In the most recent East Ramapo budget and school board election
(May 15, 2012) Weber’s Taxpayer’s Association placed a number of ads relating to
the candidates and the issues. Most of these ads were divisive, questionable,
and misleading. (More)
June 26, 2012 "Members of the
Rockland Coalition for Sustainable Water said they want an issues
conference before a state
Department of Environmental Conservation judge so alternatives can be considered. George Potanovic was among about 30
coalition members who gathered on the steps of the Rockland County Courthouse to deliver petitions containing the signatures
of 24,000 people who oppose the plant. Assemblywoman Ellen Jaffee, D-Suffern, and state Sen. David Carlucci, D-New City,
accepted the petitions and said they would get them to Cuomo’s office. Potanovic said the project deserved more scrutiny
because economic and environmental issues that weren’t evident when the plant was first pitched had surfaced. They include
the cost to build the plant, which the coalition pegs at $198 million, and the cost to run the plant, because desalination uses
a lot of power that will “forever tie local water rates to the cost of electricity,” Potanovic said. The coalition estimates that
ratepayers could see their annual bills increase by as much as $500 if the plant is built." Journal coverage here.
June 24, 2012 "State
Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli’s latest bid to gain more authority over
local development corporations
failed to make it to the Senate floor before state lawmakers went home for the summer. But state officials are optimistic
that the measure, which passed unanimously in the Assembly on Wednesday, stands a good chance when senators reconvene
in Albany — whether it’s in a special session this year or in a new legislative session next year. The comptroller has been a
vocal critic of LDCs in recent years, including the Ramapo LDC, which he said in a 2010 audit of the Rockland Boulders
baseball stadium had sidestepped regulations and left taxpayers liable for up to $60 million. He cited the ballpark in pushing
the bill last week." Full Journal News article here.
June 22, 2012 "Citing
millions of dollars in unnecessary costs to taxpayers, State Comptroller
Thomas P. DiNapoli
called on the state Senate to vote on his proposal to give the Comptroller’s office direct audit authority over
local development corporations (LDCs) and other similar entities that are controlled by local governments. The
bill has passed the Assembly (A.9689) and is awaiting Senate (S.7540) action." When passed in the Senate, St.
Lawrence will be legally forced to open the Local Development Corp books to state auditors. Full text of the
press release from DiNapoli's office here.
June 22, 2012When John Layne, the Deputy Head of the Highway Department in Ramapo
June 19, 2012 "A small fraction of East Ramapo voters easily
approved the district’s $191.9 million
Tuesday during a revote, bringing closure to a long and anxiety-ridden budget season. The 2012-13 spending plan,
virtually identical to the one taxpayers rejected last month, was approved by a vote of 3,562 to 1,217, according
to unofficial results announced by the district late Tuesday." Journal coverage here.
June 19, 2012 A story in today’s Newsday warns
that Ramapo should "Say farewell to the Rockland Boulders." The
team will be changing its name this Saturday in a news conference in Upper Saddle River N.J. The new name will
be directed at New Jersey to attract potential fans from Bergen County. Although the Jersey fan base being groped
by the team’s management have not kicked in a dime for the stadium, they have become the target of a pretty
strange marketing scheme. (More)
June 18, 2012 "As
voters in the East Ramapo school district head to the polls Tuesday to
decide on a $191.9 million
budget proposal for next school year — for the second time this spring — they will do so without knowing what their
schools will look like if the budget fails again. If it fails, the district is required to adopt a contingency budget with a
zero percent tax-levy increase, which would require it to cut $2.6 million from an austere spending plan for 2012-13.
District officials say they haven’t put together a contingency plan and they’re counting on the budget to pass." Story here.
June 14, 2012 "The
East Ramapo teachers union has agreed to a new, five-year contract that
limits raises and temporarily
freezes salaries for those who take on extracurricular leadership roles. The contract, which goes into effect July 1, includes
average annual cost-of-living raises of 1 percent to 1.5 percent starting in the second year. Additional step raises based on
teachers’ individual years of experience and other factors will be given only three out of the five years of the contract,
rather than annually as in the past. The contract’s approval by the Board of Education at a meeting last week followed six
months of negotiations between the school district and the union." Full text of the Journal News story here.
June 12, 2012
Letter in The Journal News
"Why does this Provident Bank Park baseball stadium in Ramapo have to be such an annoyance? It’s bad enough the
citizens who live near it have to be forced to put up with the fireworks’ sound; now concerts. My once quiet street
is now strewn with beer cans and bottles from the pre-show tailgaters." Read the complete letter here.
Attorney General Investigating East Ramapo Sale of Schools
June 9, 2012
The Journal News reported today: “The East Ramapo school district this
week handed over the last of
thousands of emails and other records related to the attempted sale and current leases of two school buildings after
the state Attorney General’s Office subpoenaed the district earlier this year.” (More)
June 5, 2012 More than most
sports, baseball is a game of numbers. Individual and team
define the value of a franchise, and, ultimately, its history. Immortality of individual players is
celebrated with the retirement of the star’s number. All of this makes what is happening with
the weird numbers at Ramapo’s Provident Ball Park all the more disturbing. (More)
June 3, 2012
In just two years, the Town of Ramapo has gotten itself on the hook for
about $100 million to fund
the construction of its Elm Street “affordable” housing project and its super-deluxe baseball stadium. Now, just
as I predicted, Moody’s Investors Service has downgraded Ramapo’s credit rating by two steps, and anticipates
a further reduction. It reduced Ramapo’s credit rating just in time for Ramapo’s sale of a $15 million bond
anticipation note. Why is Ramapo borrowing another $15 million? And why is it doing this with a bond anticipation
note instead of an ordinary bond? Read the full text of Bob Rhodes' Community View here.
May 30, 2012 "You cannot compare East
Ramapo with Clarkstown or any other district. When you talk about budget
cuts, start at the top.
Instead of trying to cut the budget, the Board of Education saw fit to hire an out-of-town attorney at an outrageous cost to the taxpayers.
How many unnecessary administrators do we have in Central Office? Cuts need to be made at the top, not with the educators who are
working directly with children and their families." Read the full text of this Community View here.
Federal Court Tosses Redistricting Battle of Chasidic Villages
May 30, 2012 "A
federal court has dismissed claims that threatened to upend newly drawn
lines for Assemblywoman Annie Rabbitt’s district
and those of surrounding Assembly districts in Orange and Rockland counties. A legal challenge brought by a Town of Ramapo councilman
had accused state lawmakers of diluting the voting power of Ramapo’s large Hasidic population by separating the Hasidic villages of New
Square and Kaser into two Assembly districts rather than keeping them in the same one, as they are now." (More)
Ramapo Leaders Must Take
Blame--Journal News Editorial
May 30, 2012 It was the combination of
the arrogant ego of the Supervisor who turned his back on the taxpayers
who voted against funding
his crackbrained ballpark project and the clueless complicity of his board that has brought the Town of Ramapo to the negative economic outlook
described in the latest Moody's ratings. The taxpayers now have years, or decades of $100million+ debt added to their taxes, and the Town is now burdened
with the lowest credit rating of all the towns in Rockland County. Preserve Ramapo forced the referendum vote on this project, and the people
responded by rejecting any money for the ballpark. St. Lawrence then lied about no taxpayer funds for the park, and his board backed him up.
The New York Comptroller slammed this group for the enormous waste of taxpayers' money, and now Moody's has cut our credit rating off at the knees
with the promise of more downgrades in the near future without some dramatic improvements. Today, The Journal News has pointed to those responsible
in a lead editorial. "Ramapo town leaders can point to the state’s property-tax cap, the weak economy and even Rockland County’s fiscal troubles for
contributing to a two-step downgrade by Moody’s Investors Service. But they need to save significant blame for their own choices — namely, the guarantee
of loans taken by the Ramapo Local Development Corporation to build a controversial baseball stadium." Full text of the editorial can be read here.
Drops Ramapo Credit Rating--
Boulder's Ballpark Debt Dents Ramapo Credit
Ramapo now has
lowest credit rating of any Town in Rockland
Town now Two Steps Above Junk Status
Rating from Aa2 to A1 on $119 million outstanding Debt
Ramapo only Town in County with "Negative Outlook" from Moody's
May 29, 2012
millions of dollars in debt guaranteed by the town to build its
baseball stadium continues to play a major role in its financial standing, as evidenced by Moody’s Investors Service, which cited the debt
guarantee as part of its rationale to downgrade the town’s credit rating. The debt-rating agency has lowered Ramapo’s rating two notches,
citing “significant erosion of the town’s financial flexibility” due to two years of operating deficits, midyear shortfalls and “aggressive”
revenue expectations. The town has $119 million in outstanding general obligation debt, of which $40.3 million is issued by the local
development corporation and guaranteed by the town. The $40.3 million includes a $15.3 million loan from Provident Bank for the
construction of phase one of the Ramapo Commons housing development and a $25 million bond that financed the construction of the
baseball stadium.The bond guarantee, though, is just a fraction of what taxpayers have invested in the Provident Bank Park facility.
According to the New York State Comptroller’s Office, town taxpayers are on the hook for as much as $60 million for the stadium.
The two-notch drop in Ramapo’s creditworthiness — the first change in its rating since 1997 — puts it in last place among towns in
Rockland." Read Mareesa Nicosia's story here. Read the Moody's report on its research for the downgrade here.
Albany Law School Blog posts Patrick Farm Lower Court Reversal
May 29, 2012 Patricia E. Salkin,
Associate Dean and Director of the Government Law Center of Albany Law
has posted on her Law of the Land blog the reversal won by Pomona in its court action against the Patrick
Farm development. Read "NY Appellate Court Holds Village Has Standing to Challenge Town Rezoning
on SEQRA Grounds and on Procedural Grounds" here. Our coverage can be read here.
May 28, 2012 The ad in the
Sunday Journal for the upcoming game with the Worcester
WPIX coverage of East Ramapo (click image for video) Why Block Antenna, But Not Stadium? May 26, 2012 Letter in The Journal News "I find it both
incongruent and preposterous that the Ramapo Planning St. Lawrence Appointee Arrested--Second May 21, 2012 Last June when Christopher
St. Lawrence and his Board enthusiastically created
Tornadoes featured the man who is arguably the most notorious abuser of steroids and
other illegal enhancement drugs in the history of baseball. He has also been arrested and
charged with other crimes, and most recently was kicked off the latest minor league
team that gave him a chance. The team was in Mexico and he was released for admitting to using a banned
substance without a prescription. A world-class sports cheat who is the featured attraction at Sunday's game.
Nothing like promoting a career drug abuser for the kids. (More)
Budget and the prospect for keeping
Board rejected the emergency services request to add antennas to an existing tower because it would increase noise
pollution and traffic and the changes could contribute to the diminution of property values. Where was the rejection
of the plan for the Provident Park baseball stadium in the backyard of my neighborhood for the same reasons in 2010?
Full text of the letter here.
in Command at the Highway Dept, John Layne,
Charged on numerous Counts by DA
an $80k position for John Layne as Deputy Superintendent of Highways for Ramapo, we posted
a long piece itemizing all the red flags hauled up by this ex-mayor of Airmont, and ex-building inspector for Sloatsburg.
We concluded the piece with this warning: "Some sources tell us that the $80,000 for Layne will buy personal internal
surveillance for St. Lawrence in the Highway Department. Many feel that Layne is being maneuvered in position to take
over when the current Superintendent, Tony Sharan, retires. But whether it’s for a political periscope or the
patronage-equals-control calculus that defines local politics, the spending and borrowing has maneuvered the town of
Ramapo into an increasingly dangerous position." Then in this afternoon's LoHud: "Former Airmont Mayor and current Ramapo
deputy highway department superintendent John Layne was arrested at 10:30 a.m. today on corruption charges relating
to his previous job as the Sloatsburg building inspector. The District Attorney's Office charged Layne with official misconduct,
first-degree falsifying business records, petty larceny, and issuing a false certificate." St. Lawrence told the Journal reporter
that he was shocked. We're not. Read our assessment of Layne from last June here and The Journal News article John Layne,
Airmont ex-mayor, charged with corruption in his former role as Sloatsburg building inspector here.
WPIX coverage of East Ramapo
(click image for video)
Why Block Antenna, But Not Stadium?
May 26, 2012 Letter in The Journal News "I find it both
incongruent and preposterous that the Ramapo Planning
St. Lawrence Appointee Arrested--Second
May 21, 2012 Last June when Christopher
St. Lawrence and his Board enthusiastically created
May 17, 2012 "Once again, public school
children lost in East Ramapo, as the majority of district voters — many
of whom have children who attend nonpublic schools and yeshivas — rejected the proposed school budget. The
“No” vote was an especially bitter pill to swallow; not only was East Ramapo’s the only budget in the Lower Hudson
Valley to go down, it also was $7 million less than the district’s current budget. The 2012-2013 budget plan already
contained draconian cuts that limited options for children, from the very beginning of their public school experience
through to the very end. For youngsters who attend the public school system — mostly minority-group members from
working-class families — it will only get worse." Read the complete editorial here.
Read Mareesa Nicosia's
evaluation of the consequences of the failed budget vote:
"East Ramapo budget loss may mean deeper cuts, including all kindergarten" here
A Delusional Solution
May 16, 2012 A puzzling story in The
Journal News last week claimed, "Two councilmen want Ramapo LDC
control shifted to Town Board, cite accountability." The two are Daniel Friedman and Pat Withers, and what
they want is actually not legal. And their reasons for wanting to take control of the LDC (Supervisor St. Lawrence’s
Local Development Corp), as explained to the Journal reporter, is to protect the public from none other than themselves.
(Full story here)
East Ramapo School Budget only one in the
Yonah Rothman 8410 (wins seat on Board)
Ramapo Central School Budget--Yes 1358 No 618
Theresa DiFalco 1293 (wins seat on Board)
United Water fine just a drop in bucket
May. 14, 2012
A fine of
$40,000 is a minor inconvenience to United Water New York, a
subsidiary of Paris-based
Suez Environnement; but we in Rockland should take notice. Without algal blooms, there wouldn’t be an issue
with copper sulfate. Without excess nutrients in the reservoir, there wouldn’t be algal blooms. Full text of letter here.
Moody's sinks Rockland's credit rating, now lowest-rated in New York State
May 11, 2012 "Rockland
County now has the lowest credit rating of all New York counties
rated by Moody’s Investors
Service after the company downgraded the rating Thursday by three levels, from A3 to Baa3. Moody’s also is reviewing
the rating for further downgrade, which could occur at any time within the next 90 days. A drop of one more level — to
Ba1 or lower — would put the county at below-average creditworthiness, meaning the county’s credit rating would essentially
be at junk status. Rockland County is now the lowest-rated county in the state.” Full text of The Journal News coverage here.
Former Airmont trustee Veronica Boesch to finish late mayor's term
May 10, 2012 "The
village board has appointed a former trustee as its new leader after
the sudden death of
Mayor Dennis Kay last month. Veronica D. Boesch, a retired teacher who was elected to the board in 2007,
succeeds Kay, a longtime local leader who was involved in the Boy Scouts and other causes. Complete
Journal News story here.
Financial Analysis of the 2011Annual Report of the Ramapo
Local Development Corp (LDC)
May 8, 2012 We finally have the long awaited financial
statement from last year’s operations of the Ramapo Local
Development Corporation. The financial statement only hints at the financial disaster that Supervisor St. Lawrence
has created for our town. When reading the report one has to keep in mind that following standard accounting practice
they assume the assets of the LDC are worth what it cost to create them. Readers should recall that the "affordable"
housing was built on a cost plus basis and the stadium was constructed through the worst winter in recent memory by
tradesmen working weekends and two and three shifts. Today these assets are worth almost nothing. Read the
complete report here.
Pomona Wins Decision in Appellate Court:
Judge Jamieson's Patrick Farm Lawsuit
May 7, 2012 On April 24th, a
four-judge panel of the
Appellate Division of New York State overturned orders
written by Judge Linda S. Jamieson in the Rockland County
Supreme Court relating to the Village of Pomona's lawsuit
against the Town of Ramapo and the concessions Ramapo
had made to the developer of Patrick Farm. Jamieson had ruled that Pomona had no right to sue ("did not have
legal standing"). The Appellate Court ruled that Jamieson had gotten it wrong ("erred") and that the village did
have that right. (More)
Saudi Arabia on the Hudson?
Why Water Speculators Want
Desalination in the Moist Northeast
The Other Costs of the New Square Arson Attack
May 6, 2012 When, at around four o’clock in the morning,
Shaul Spitzer showed up at the
home of Aron Rottenberg carrying accelerants, with which he would threaten the lives of
an entire family, the fire he ignited seriously burned both Rottenberg and himself. The fire
also starkly lit several underlying problems that brought the two New Square residents to
that deadly confrontation in the middle of the night. (More)
not going to take it anymore!"
Volunteer Firefighters on Building Violations
May 3, 2012 John Kryger, an assistant
fire coordinator at the Rockland Fire
Training Center, told The Journal News yesterday that firefighters "shouldn’t
have to be adversarial" but they will be taking the offensive against local
government officials and boards that allow illegally altered housing to pose
a threat to volunteer firemen. The situation has reached a tipping point,
and Kryger announced, "We’re not going to take it anymore." (More)
DEC Fines United Water $40k for Polluting Reservoir
May 2, 2012 "United
Water New York has agreed to a civil penalty of $40,000 for
applying pesticides to the Lake Deforest Reservoir under the terms of a consent order with
the state Department of Environmental Conservation, the agency said Tuesday. United Water
New York owns and operates the reservoir, a major drinking water supply for thousands of
Rockland homes and businesses. The company had nothing to say regarding its pollution of the reservoir Tuesday." Journal
News story here.
Let New Jersey pay for the Hudson water plant
April 26, 2012
United Water proposal to build a reverse osmosis water treatment
plant using Hudson River
water — I get it, it safely removes most contaminants to an acceptable level. But, it will cost more to operate than we’re
told. There is a very simple way to increase Rockland water that costs Rockland zero — stop sending Rockland water to
New Jersey and have United Water N.J. build a plant for New Jersey where they drink the Hudson River water and absorb
the cost to build the plant." Complete letter to the Journal here.
East Ramapo candidates make their pitch to concerned citizens
April 26, 2012 "Gathered
at the Chuggin’ Rhino in Pomona from 7-9 p.m. on Tuesday, April 17,
Kim Foskew, Hiram Rivera
and Joanna Thompson rallied a group of roughly 50 for support in this year’s East Ramapo school board election. These
three candidates were picked by the Concerned Citizens of East Ramapo because they claim to be committed to putting
the “children first.” Story.
Popular Nanuet Carnival Disappears in Pomona
April 26, 2012
Amusements can no longer stage their once popular biannual carnival
in the parking lot of the
Nanuet Mall due to construction there, so they moved the location to the parking lot of Provident Bank Park. So far,
it’s not working out, organizers have told the Rockland County Times. People cannot see the amusements from the
road and that is affecting turnout." Posting from Rockland County Times here.
Welcome to Jose’s Nightmare
April 23, 2012 It was only one month
ago, on March 8, that he was kicked out of the Mexican Baseball
League for admitting
to using a banned substance without a prescription. The drug was testosterone and the player was 47-year-old Jose Canseco,
who might be the most infamous pro sports juicer of all time. Then, on April 20th, the Worcester Tornadoes of the Can-Am
League announced the signing of Canseco. In the press release, Tornadoes General Manager Jorg Bassiacos said, "We expect
Jose to bring a lot of excitement to Hanover Insurance Park at Fitton Field." Story here.
April 19, 2012
"United Water has proposed
building the Haverstraw Water Supply Project treatment plant on
property at a
closed town landfill, just south of the Haverstraw Marina. The treatment plant would draw water from the brackish Hudson
River, remove contaminants, treat it and deliver it to its customers. The company provides drinking water to the majority
of homes and businesses in Rockland." Read William Stein's Community View here.
April 19, 2012 "The East Ramapo
school board adopted
a $192 million budget that decreases spending by $7 million and
scores of staff and programs while raising the tax levy by 1.9 percent. Taxpayers will cast their votes on the budget May 15.The
5-1 vote, with two abstentions, by the Board of Education late Wednesday night came after weeks of public controversy about
the impact of the district’s multimillion-dollar deficit." Journal story here.
April 18, 2012 "An
18-year-old New Square man who severely burned a village dissident
during an arson attack got sentenced
to seven years in state prison on Tuesday after apologizing for trying to burn Aron Rottenberg’s family out of the Hasidic
Jewish village. The attack on Rottenberg and others for refusing to pray in the village synagogue and other activities raised
how the Hasidic Jewish theocracy in New Square controls the lives of residents and deals, harshly at times, with those
who choose not to follow the grand rabbi’s dictates." Full text of the Journal News coverage here.
Joe Meyers' remembrance of Mayor Dennis Kay here
The Preserve Ramapo community will miss Mayor Kay
April 15, 2012 "Dennis
Kay, a two-term mayor of Airmont and longtime local leader involved
in the Boy Scouts and other
causes, has died. Kay, who had recently turned 65, was found dead this morning in his home on Lorna Lane, his family said.
Family members said Kay had been in good health and that his death was unexpected. They did not immediately know
the cause." Journal News story here.
April 14, 2012 "Shaul Spitzer,
18, faces five to 10 years for first-degree assault in the attack on
Aron Rottenberg at 4:15 a.m. May 22
during an attempt to burn down the family’s home on Truman Avenue in New Square. Rottenberg, 44, once a plumber, continues to
recover from third-degree burns over 50 percent of his body, suffered when Spitzer set off an incendiary device while grappling
with Rottenberg. Spitzer suffered burns to his hands and arms. Before Spitzer pleaded guilty Feb. 8, state Supreme Court Justice
William A. Kelly told the teenager that he would cap his prison term at 10 years. The violent felony assault charge carries a sentence
range of five to 25 years for a first-time offender." Complete story at Journal News here.
April 11, 2012
"The Concerned Citizens of East Ramapo will hold a campaign kick-off
meeting tonight ahead of the East Ramapo
school district’s Board of Education and budget vote May 15. The group of public education advocates will introduce three
candidates running for three open seats on the Board of Education: Kim Foskew, Hiram Rivera and current board member
JoAnne Thompson. The event is from 7 to 9 p.m. in the faculty dining room of the Rockland Community College cultural arts
building, 145 College Road. Training and coordination for campaign volunteers also will take place." Journal story here.
April 3, 2012 "Spring
Valley Mayor Noramie Jasmin justifies her newly enacted 8.5 percent
salary increase by saying she
works hard — “24/7” — for her village. No doubt she and the village’s four trustees, also getting substantial raises, put in
long hours; but the increases come at the wrong time, with village residents still struggling to dig their way out of the recession.
The four village trustees will see a 20.6 percent salary bump in the 2012-2013 budget, putting base compensation for the part-time
posts at $25,750; compensation for the mayor, whose post is considered full time, increases to $125,000. Taxpayers have been
generous to the mayor in other respects; they already picked up the $46,000 tab for the high-end SUV Jasmin drives. The raises
come as Spring Valley homeowners will see their village property tax bills go up more than 3 percent in the new budget; the
village’s tax levy increase is 3.4 percent." Read the complete editorial here.
March 30, 2012
The Town of Ramapo has accumulated a dangerously high debt load and
now has been placed on a watch
list for those municipalities and companies involved in distressed debt. (More)
March 29, 2012
hundred people turned out Wednesday night at an East Ramapo
community forum where a
proposal to cut millions from the school district’s budget — and the impact of those cuts on students — was the center
of attention. Administrators, saying the district faces a multimillion-dollar deficit next year, have proposed a list of
nonmandated staff and program cuts totaling more than $20 million. Superintendent of Schools Joel Klein has said the
district needs to cut between $13 million and $20 million to meet the state tax cap and pass the proposed $202 million
budget for the 2012-13 school year. Recommendations include eliminating the kindergarten program to save $5.1 million,
cutting extracurricular activities by half or in total to save up to $400,000, and eliminating the elementary library program
to save $1.2 million. Another would cut the athletic budget in half or in total to save up to $850,000. Cutting the entire
program would eliminate all after-school sports and intramural programs. Other proposals would drastically reduce the number
of teachers, social workers and nurses." Full Journal coverage, including video, here.
March 25, 2012 "Ramapo’s
LDC — which St. Lawrence chairs — allowed the town to get around all
sorts of other
issues as well. After town voters overwhelmingly defeated a referendum to guarantee a $16.5 million loan for the
stadium, the RLDC went ahead and secured a short-term bond (for $25 million) that was guaranteed by the town,
or rather its taxpayers. Plus, town land, purchased by the town for $7.7 million, was given to the RLDC, which
could use it as collateral. Then, there’s town-paid site work that benefited the RLDC project, and the town’s
payment of fines to the state Department of Environmental Conservation for violations at the site. Of more concern:
The comptroller cast doubt on the RLDC’s scheme to pay back the stadium bond — using profits from the sale of units
at an affordable housing complex being built by the RLDC. The comptroller doubted the profit could cover both bond
payments for the housing construction and the stadium’s debt. If the RLDC come up short on its stadium bond payments,
the bills could land in the lap of the guarantors — the taxpayers of Ramapo." Full text of the editorial here.
for Abuses of
St. Lawrence's Development Corp
that Bills the Taxpayers
March 25, 2012 In a joint investigation by the Rockland and Westchester
offices of The Journal News, reporters Mareesa Nicosia and Jorge Fitz-Gibbon
profile the role of Local Development Corporations in the two counties.
The best alternative to meet Rockland's water needs
"The United Water Lake DeForest
water treatment plant has a capacity of 20 million gallons per day.
However, the New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH) currently limits production to an average of 10 million
gallons per day. The best alternative to meet Rockland's water needs is to remove this NYSDOH production limitation
and operate Lake DeForest as it was originally intended, 'solely for the benefit of the citizens of Rockland County'."
Read the full text of Bob Dillon's letter to the County elected officials here.
Radio show 'East Ramapo Underground' spotlights school district issues
goal is to inform the public about what is happening to the East
Ramapo school district with
regard to the budget cuts and the upcoming election and to make sure the people are fully aware of what’s happening,”
Hatton said, following the show’s debut Thursday morning." Journal story here.
March 23, 2012 "If
taxpayers vote down the proposed budget, the district must adopt a
contingency budget with no tax-levy
increase. In that scenario, it faces at least a $15 million deficit. Proposals totaling $24 million worth of cuts include up to
180 staff positions, the entire kindergarten program and the elementary library program. The district has shed 255.8
employees in the past four years." Journal coverage here.
David Goldsmith 728
Bret Bekritsky 580
Trustees Ed McPherson 694 Marshall Katz 732
Jonathan Gewirtz 595 William Fried 562
(Totals are unofficial and do include absentee ballots)
Journal News story here.
March 15, 2012 "In addition to
extracurricular programs like sports and clubs, it will consider paring
down honors and
Advanced Placement classes and BOCES offerings. Most significantly, officials said, more than 180 staff positions could
potentially be cut. 'We do not have a choice. We will have to make some of these, if not all. We don’t know yet,'
Superintendent Joel Klein said, of the proposed cuts. If nothing else, the district will look to maintain a 'good, solid'
general education program, he added." Full text of Journal story here.
March 14, 2012 Among the documents
presented and sent regarding the desalination project there is
this letter from a local consulting engineer with credentials in environmental engineering. Mr. Stein, of
New City, has more than fifty years of experience in the design and development of water supply and
waste water disposal, highway, bridge, dam and land development projects. He explains why the project
is unnecessary. Text of the letter here.
March 9, 2012 "A car belonging to Aron
Rottenberg — the dissident member of the Hasidic community
targeted and seriously burned in a May arson attack — was intentionally set ablaze Thursday night. Hillcrest
firefighters responded to Jefferson Avenue about 10:40 p.m. to find the rear of Rottenberg’s 2003 Mazda
in flames, Ramapo Police Sgt. Blaine Howell said. The arson fire started with someone lighting either
paper or cardboard under the trunk near the gas tank, Ramapo Capt. Brad Weidel said this morning.
He said the criminal charge is third-degree arson if someone is caught." Journal coverage here.
March 5, 2012 In a
retirement ceremony at town hall, Supervisor
St. Lawrence promised on camera, “As a retirement we will keep
the dog in food and health. We will give him health benefits like
one of the guys here.” The dog had saved lives and provided
notable service to the police K-9 Corps and the public. When he became critically ill, however, the
cameras were no longer rolling and repeated, even certified requests to the Supervisor for help after
the dog's benefits were abruptly discontinued went unanswered. Cue the cameras, and guess what
the response was once the lights were on again? The story and video here.
March 5, 2012 "United
Water wants to treat and desalinate Hudson River water to meet
water supply needs. Before the already overtaxed residents and businesses of Rockland County pay
for an unneeded “Haverstraw Water Supply Project,” United Water must first gauge the real supply,
and real need, within the county. Meeting the current and foreseeable future water needs of Rockland
is simply a matter of United Water complying with the state Department of Environmental Conservation
discharge permit for Lake DeForest." (More)
March 4, 2012 A lead story in
Journal News Sunday examines the nexus of developers, politicians,
zoning boards in Rockland and Westchester Counties. The article includes the changes in zoning at the
Patrick Farm site from Adult Student Housing to high-density placement of 500 homes over an aquifer.
March 3, 2012 "Saying
firefighters’ concerns about the design of the massive Patrick Farm
have been ignored, the Hillcrest Fire Company has joined an existing lawsuit that seeks to halt the project in its
current form. The controversial 497-home development was approved by the Ramapo Planning Board late last year
amid public criticism over its planned density, wetlands location and proximity to a pressurized gas line. Several
lawsuits seeking to reverse the decision followed in January, including one filed by 10 members of the environmental
group Ramapo Organized for Sustainability and a Safe Aquifer (ROSA) against the town and the developer, Scenic
Development LLC of Monsey." Full text of the Journal story here.
Call to Investigate Elm Street Condos Triggers
March 1, 2012 This was the promise
from the Supervisor: "The Ramapo Local
Development Corporation (RLDC) is spearheading an initiative to construct a
new affordable work-force housing development on Elm Street in Spring Valley.
The project, known as Ramapo commons, is going to benefit families who otherwise might not be able to afford
to purchase a home in Ramapo." So who are the families who bought the first 24 condos recently completed?
A clue: Most of them weren’t people. (More)
March 1, 2012 "There are 40
synagogues on the Great Neck peninsula, more per capita than
Jerusalem, notes Rita Hall
of Reach Out America, a grassroots advocacy organization that has as one of its missions upholding separation of church
and state. In the Village of Great Neck, alone, there are 28 houses of worship - adding in the schools and parks almost
one-third of its property falls under "tax-exempt" category." The article is a review of the film "America's Holy War" and
a general commentary on the destructive nature of the RLUIPA legislation. (More)
February 28, 2012
The Provident Bank Stadium Park has been and will continue to be an
economic disaster for Ramapo.
Ramapo Supervisor St. Lawrence cited the Fishkind study in order to argue that the stadium will someday be a financial
success. But he doesn’t remind us that Fishkind based his optimistic projections on a total construction cost of only
$20 million. Based on incomplete data the Comptroller’s report found a total cost of $60 million. Preserve Ramapo
believes the final cost will be closer to $70 million. (More)
February 27, 2012 "Ramapo
officials are dragging their feet on requests by The Journal News to
release records of revenue
generated by the multimillion-dollar baseball stadium, an expert on state open government law said. Robert Freeman,
executive director for the state Committee on Open Government, said Thursday that the town and officials from its
development corporation have imposed an “artificial roadblock” by failing to fulfill requests for records about how much
money Ramapo made during the facility’s inaugural season. The town-created quasi-governmental agency, the Ramapo
Local Development Corp., owns and operates the controversial stadium." Journal story here.
February 24, 2012 "A
documentary (America's Holy War) explaining the history and
substance of the Religious Land Use and
Institutionalized Persons Act was banned by the New York Association of Towns, at its annual conference in Manhattan earlier
this week, because of unspecified objections from municipal officials from the Town of Ramapo in Rockland County. The
executive of NYAT, who would not specify who had objected, never saw the film or even asked to preview it before
they acted." Read the director's full response here. And remember, a screening of the film is scheduled next Wednesday, 8pm,
at Rivertown Film in Nyack. Click on notice above for details.
February 23, 2012
town’s controversial baseball stadium generated $734,100 in its
season, falling more than $300,000 short of projections made by a consultant in 2010 that it would
net $1.1 million. A revenue shortfall is significant as the RLDC prepares to make the first payment
of the year toward the $25 million, five-year loan backed by the town for the stadium’s construction.
The stadium’s success also has been tied to the taxpayers, though St. Lawrence insists residents
will not be liable. The town deeded ownership of the 61 acres of parkland the stadium sits on
to the RLDC to pay off the costs. The first payment of $1,937,500 is due March 15, and a
second payment of $437,500 is due in September." Journal story here.
February 20, 2012 "The village is
on track to operate its own Justice Court during the spring,
joining eight others within the Town of Ramapo that already do so. The village has operated
without a court since its incorporation in 1986, relying instead on Ramapo Town Court to hear
traffic cases, violations of zoning and building codes, and minor civil and criminal offenses. Though
he has opposed the idea of a village court in the past, Mayor Jeffrey Oppenheim said times have
changed. 'Now I feel that there is a legitimate need,' Oppenheim said Monday. 'My feeling is that
the people in the village deserve the right to elect a justice for their own court.' Contributing to the
decision, Oppenheim said, was the loss of a re-election bid by longtime former Town Justice Arnold
Etelson, a Montebello resident, to Alan Simon in November. Because Etelson was ousted from the
bench not by Montebello residents’ votes, but by Ramapo’s large Jewish bloc vote, Oppenheim said, village residents 'are
essentially disenfranchised.' " Full Journal story here.
February 19, 2012 "United Water has
launched a major public relations advertising and direct mail
campaign aimed at
convincing us that its plan to build a desalination plant for Hudson River drinking water is a good idea and the least
expensive alternative for Rockland residents. But United Water is not telling us the whole story. The company claims its
plant would provide economic benefits and new tax revenues. But the fact is, the projected cost of the plant has been
increasing, it would create only a few permanent jobs, it would require higher operational and energy costs and any tax
revenues will be generated by higher water rates for everyone.Hudson River desalination is a bad idea for Rockland." In
a Community View appearing in The Journal News, two members of the Rockland Water Coalition explain six reasons why
the plant is a bad idea for residents. (More)
Feb. 17, 2012 Community View in The Journal News
The Town of Ramapo is facing a cash crunch that could become a true
toward the end of this year. It will almost certainly not be able to make scheduled
debt payments without borrowing millions of dollars. (More)
Feb. 16, 2012 "The East Ramapo school district has a hard
road ahead as it seeks to provide effective education with fewer
while meeting the state’s new tax levy cap next school year. That was the message of Superintendent of Schools Joel Klein, who on
Wednesday night floated a $202 million budget proposal for the 2012-13 school year." (Story here)
Feb. 16, 2012 "A Route 306 religious school continues to hold
classes for children in a former single-family house despite being
to Ramapo Town Court for operating illegally and after yeshiva officials promised the village mayor they would first seek approvals.
Congregation Ohr Torah went before Ramapo Justice Rhoda Schoenberger on Tuesday and got another 30 days to move ahead on
filing plans and going before village planning and zoning boards. The congregation lacks a certificate of occupancy and approvals to
operate a school in the house and an addition." (Story here)
2012 "The recent climax of the New Square arson case is
troubling on several counts. First, it is troubling that a man who
attacked a home with a fire bomb that resulted in life-threatening burns on Aron Rottenberg can plea down from attempted murder
to assault. Secondly, it is troubling that the leadership of New Square can squash investigation into their role in the attack on a man
who they had allegedly repeatedly threatened by the writing of a check. However, the most troubling aspect is the concluding
sentence of the above editorial on this plea deal: “The community, like the Rottenbergs, is moving on.” (Full letter here)
Documentary America's Holy War to be Screened
at Annual Conference of NYS Association of Towns (Feb 21)
The story of Ramapo and RLUIPA, as covered in America's Holy War,
will be going Statewide when
it is screened at the Annual Conference of the New York State Association of Towns on February 21
at the New York Hilton in Manhattan. Officials from every municipality in the State as well as others
will be attending. The screening is part of a session entitled, "How to Survive an RLUIPA Investigation." There will be a panel
discussion after the screening. Local screening will be at Rivertown Film in Nyack, Wed. Feb. 29 at 8pm. Details here.
February 14, 2012 "United Water
New York is trying to lessen its impact on the Hudson River and
aquatic life as it seeks approvals to tap
the waterway as a drinking water source. Meanwhile, critics want to determine what they consider the “true” costs of the plant before
the process moves any further. The developments come as deadlines for public comment have been set, the Rockland Water Coalition
prepares to hold information sessions, and United Water readies an open house at its testing lab in West Haverstraw." Story here.
February 8, 2012 "Spitzer
admitted that he acted out of retribution — for Rottenberg’s
defiance of an edict by Grand Rabbi David Twersky,
leader of Skver Hasidim. That order commanded residents to pray in New Square’s lone synagogue. For months prior to the attack, Rottenberg
and his family had been on the receiving end of escalating protests due to his and other dissident men’s decision to worship at Friedwald Center,
a rehabilitation and nursing center outside New Square. While most of the others eventually returned to the community synagogue, Rottenberg
continued on at Friedwald. His defiance could have cost him his life. There were documented incidents of smashed car and house windows;
rapping on a bedroom window in the wee hours; phone calls threatening torment of Rottenberg’s daughter in school — followed by her school
desk and property turning up on the front porch; and crowds of men — as many as 300 — massing outside the Rottenberg home. This was joined
by a letter circulated by the village’s rabbinical court, with Rabbi Twersky’s stamp, spelling out instructions on where to worship. This area, too,
is beyond further inquiry in these proceedings." As is the public response of the Supervisor and Ramapo Police Chief ("top Ramapo police and political
leaders would parrot each other’s assurances that the arson attack was an isolated incident and part of no pattern of intimidation. Read the complete editorial.
February 8, 2012 On Wednesday, Feb. 1,
the auditors from the New York State Comptroller’s Office issued the
final results of their
examination of finances in the Ramapo Town government. Along with other serious criticisms of the supervisor and town board,
they repeated the charge that "Town officials have inappropriately mingled the activities of the Town and the Ramapo Local
Development Corporation (RLDC) in construction of a baseball stadium. These actions allowed Town officials to circumvent laws the
Town is required to abide by for the approval and construction of such projects." The State officials predicted "Taxpayers could be
liable for up to $60 million in the stadium deal, and in addition, there is little likelihood that the project will generate sufficient revenue
to help the Town pay for this outstanding liability." When contacted by local news media, the Supervisor initiated a shrill but shallow
defense of his RLDC claiming he had no idea where the Comptroller’s numbers were coming from. (More)
February 8, 2012 "Nathan
Rothschild, 54, the ex-fire district chairman and former president
of the East Ramapo Board of Education, had sought probation after pleading guilty to one
count of mail fraud in the summer. In addition to the prison time, Rothschild was
sentenced to two years of post-release supervision. Federal prosecutors had recommended
27 to 33 months in prison. Journal Story here.
February 8, 2012 "An
18-year-old follower of the New Square grand rebbe pleaded guilty
Tuesday to setting a dissident community
member on fire during an arson attack that rocked the Hasidic community. Shaul Spitzer, who lived with Grand Rabbi David
Twersky and did butler-type work for him, will face a maximum state prison sentence of 10 years for first-degree assault
when sentenced April 17. The plea was part of an overall agreement that included the settlement of a civil lawsuit brought
by the victim, Aron Rottenberg. He will receive a monetary award – believed to be in the $2 million range — from supporters
of Spitzer and Twersky." Journal News story here.
February 2, 2012 "Auditors stand
firm on earlier findings that the town 'inappropriately mingled its
activities' with the Ramapo
Local Development Corp. it created to finance the stadium, allowing officials to circumvent laws. For the first time, auditors
called on the Town Board to 'cease using the RLDC to, in effect, circumvent procurement practices' that would have been
required for any normal capital project. 'Town Board members failed to properly monitor the project, did not know the
stadium cost or how it would be paid for,' auditors added." Full story here.
February 1, 2012
officials took a risky approach to financing a minor league stadium
through the Ramapo Local
Development Corporation (RLDC), according to an audit released today by New York State Comptroller
Thomas P. DiNapoli. As a result, taxpayers may be liable for up to $60 million. 'Local officials can and should nurture economic development
opportunities in their communities, but they have an obligation to taxpayers to ensure that projects are realistic and financially viable,' DiNapoli
said. 'Instead, Ramapo officials ignored red flags that the project numbers didn't add up which could adversely impact its finances for years to come.
It is questionable deals like this that prompted my proposed reforms for the future use of LDCs by local governments.' In addition, DiNapoli's
auditors found that Ramapo had operating deficits of more than $2.4 million in 2010 and has experienced cash flow problems." The full text
of the press release and link to the complete final audit here.
February 1, 2012 "Shaul
Spitzer has waived his right to a pre-trial hearing and jury
selection is now scheduled to begin
Tuesday on charges in an arson attack on a dissident resident of New Square last May. Spitzer is facing felony counts of
attempted murder, arson and assault for his suspected role in a May 22 attack on fellow New Square resident Aron Rottenberg.
He faces 5 to 25 years if convicted of the top count of second-degree attempted murder." Story here.
January 31, 2012 "Members
of the environmental group Ramapo Organized for Sustainability and a
Safe Aquifer filed a petition
Thursday in Rockland County Court against the town and the developer, Scenic Development LLC of Monsey. The controversial
development was granted final Planning Board approval Dec. 27, amid heated public criticism centering on the environmental
impact of building on a site that is now woods and wetlands. The board’s approval is conditional on the developer obtaining
state permits. The 10 ROSA members listed in the lawsuit live near the 196-acre site near Routes 202 and 306 outside Pomona."
Full story here.
January 31, 2012
"One of several recent amendments to the
town’s zoning law unanimously approved by the Town Board last week
applies to owners of the illegally converted two- or three-family homes on Bates Drive, Horton Drive and Witzel Court. Many of those
converted homes still lack certificates of occupancy. The change to the law reverses an earlier clause, added in 2004, that for the
first time permitted the once-illegal conversions on the condition that property owners join a homeowners association that manages
the condominium apartments." Read The Journal News' "Ramapo tidies housing site, approving 2-family homes in management pact"
and then read the paper's editorial "Ramapo backs down on zoning."
January 24, 2012 In response to a request sent to the NYS
Comptroller's Office, we were told by the Assistant Director of
Communications, Kate Gurnett, that the state expects to "release the final audit within the next few weeks." We will post that document
here when it is released. Commentary and the complete text of the draft version can be read here.
January 23, 2012 "A state takeover of
the struggling East Ramapo school district is being suggested by some
advocates, but the dramatic step is unlikely, based on past practice in New York. East Ramapo will face a multimillion-dollar
budget deficit before the end of the school year, and the district may borrow up to $10 million this spring to cover costs,
Superintendent Joel Klein said recently." Journal article here.
January 19, 2012
New York has embarked on a public relations blitz in support of its plan
to augment the
Rockland County water supply by desalination of the Hudson estuary. Advertising for its “Haverstraw Water Supply Project”
is misleading when it touts the planned plant as cost-effective and a great tax generator for the Rockland community." Read
the Community View by Professor Nicholas Christie-Blick of the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory here.
January 19, 2012
"United Water New York has provided enough
information on its Hudson River treatment plant to allow
the state’s review of the project to proceed. The state Department of Environmental Conservation has deemed the company’s
draft environmental impact statement complete, agency spokeswoman Wendy Rosenbach said.The draft environmental report is
now ready for public review along with draft permits that the company needs to obtain before it can begin withdrawing and
treating river water it wants to supply to its Rockland County customers. A public hearing on the report and the permits will be
held at 2 and 6 p.m. Feb. 28 at Haverstraw Town Hall, 1 Rosman Road, Garnerville. Written comments may be submitted until
March 19." Full text of the Journal article here.
January 14, 2012 "Describing
East Ramapo’s financial condition as 'not a very pretty picture,' the
layoffs and program cuts next school year are all but assured in order for the district to comply with the state’s 2 percent
tax-levy cap in 2012. 'It’s very, very tight,' Superintendent Joel Klein said of the struggling district’s current budget. 'And
going forward, it’s going to be even worse. As we know, next year we’re going to be making cuts. Of what magnitude,
I don’t know.'” Full text of The Journal News story here.
Ramapo—A Fiscal Deadbeat?
January 10, 2012 It was just a little over
a week ago that Supervisor St. Lawrence
admitted on the radio that the Town would not be able to pay back the $2.5 million
borrowed in September from the Workman’s Compensation Fund and two other funds.
The loans were due no later than December 31, but the Town let the deadline slip.
Eight days later, The Journal News reported that of the $15 million owed to Provident
Bank in Ramapo-backed loans for the Ramapo Local Development Corp’s Elm Street
Housing project, the Town has only been able to repay $6 million, less than half of what’s owed. Worse yet, the housing
project now needs another $8.4 million from Provident Bank—an institution that is experiencing its own dangerous fiscal
stresses at this point. (More)
Connie Coker: Patrick Farm plan is abhorrent
Letter in Our Town: Patrick Farm downzoning--Ramapo’s assault on the rest of Rockland
January 10, 2012 The former Chair of
the County Legislature's Environmental Committee condemns the Patrick
and a Tappan resident speaks out voicing concerns about destructive down zoning that will affect everyone in Rockland. Both here.
January 9, 2012
0ur family just received
another slickly written, glossy mailing from
United Water Co. (UW) telling how OK it will be to drink water that comes from the
Hudson River. Facing huge opposition from the public, UW seems to be making a desperate, all-out push to persuade
the public that UW's "Haverstraw Water Project" would be good for Rockland County. In the last several months our
mailbox has been cluttered with at least five such mailings, plus almost nonstop newspaper ads. Who is paying for all
of this? It's probably all of us, from our recently jacked-up water bills. And for what? Read the full text of Chad Murdock's
January 5, 2012 "Ramapo
town leaders recently took steps to aid homeowners who were victimized
by poor planning decisions
of yesteryear, and almost simultaneously increased the likelihood that bad planning will cause further harm to town residents.
The contradictory decisions could cause costly headaches down the road. The same week that St. Lawrence touted the tax help
for homeowners, the town’s planning board on Dec. 27 cleared the way for a controversial mega-housing development on a swath
of lush, open land known as Patrick Farm. The development, which environmentalists and neighbors have fought for years, brings
nearly 500 housing units to 196 acres off routes 202 and 306, near the headwaters of the Mahwah River, a key part of Rockland’s
drinking water supply. Rockland’s planning department found much wrong with the requested zone changes. In fact, the county
negatively viewed the first downzone by the town, in 2004, that allowed the area to change from two-acre to one-acre zoning.
Now the town has approved 410 high-density, multifamily units with up to six bedrooms and 87 single-family homes with four
bedrooms." Full text of the editorial here.
December 31, 2011
We encourage all
of our readers to write letters not only to The Journal News, but
also to the Rockland County Times
and the other local papers as well. In the last issue of 2010, the Journal published the following two letters: Issues swirl
around Patrick Farm plan and Ramapo needs to invest in future.
Ramapo Fails to Repay $2m Borrowed from Workers’ Compensation
Fund—Also Defaults on $500k transferred from Ambulance and Lighting Districts
December 31, 2011 Back in September, apparently under cash-flow
pressures, St. Lawrence and his board borrowed
$2.5 million, most of it from the Workers’ Compensation Fund, most of it ($2m) going to bail out the Town’s General
Fund. Today it was reported St. Lawrence said they will not meet the payback deadline, nor did he offer any assurance
about repayment. He simply said they would revise the resolution that originally ordered the transfers. (More)
Planning Board Approves
Patrick Farm Plan—Opposition
Lawsuits Will Go Forward in Appellate
Court—DEC Approvals still Missing
December 28, 2011 Last night at the Ramapo Planning Board meeting
there were three 7-0 votes granting
board approval to three propositions related to the Patrick Farm plan of developer Yechiel Lebovits to place
500 housing units on the rural site in Pomona. (More)
St. Lawrence and Board Wrap up Year-end Gift for Ballpark Contractor
Morano Contract Bloats from Original $4.3 to $15.4 million
December 27, 2011 No, ‘Tis not the season. The season was over in
September with the Boulders
in next to last and the taxpayers still holding the bag for what has become an endless stream of
construction costs at the ballpark site on Firemen’s Memorial Drive. Now it’s late December, and
change orders (cost overruns) are still coming up regularly in the Ramapo Town Board meetings.
When these resolutions are read aloud in the meetings, Town Attorney Michael Klein always neglects
to mention the amounts so we have a few for you to look over, with the numbers attached. (More)
Posted on the LoHud
Rockland Blog Saturday, December 17:
"At the Lafayette Theatre in Suffern on Saturday, close to 1,000 people sat in the historic theater
watching the Christmas Classic, It's a Wonderful Life. The movie was brought to the masses as
part of the Ramapo film festival. And dignitaries and town officials were on hand to take their bows.
That’s when life became not all too wonderful for Ramapo Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence,
the hometown fellow from Suffern who attended the film with his wife and his mother. When
his name was announced, a strong cascade of boos filled the theater." Full blog here.
December 16, 2011 Can-Am Commissioner
Miles Wolff announced today that his league of eight
teams in 2011, the league which is the home of the Rockland Boulders, has shrunk to five teams.
The Broxton Rox folded today, joining the Pittsfield Colonials, which went belly up earlier this fall.
Wolff announced the remaining five teams will join another independent league, the American
Association, for part of the season to round out the current unbalanced schedule. Details of the financial collapse of the
Rox here. Visit the www.CanAmLeague.com for today's announcement of of the future for the remaining five.
December 15, 2011 After two long nights
of criticism, expert testimony and community reaction to the
Patrick Farm application, the Planning Board, at 1:21 in the morning, decided to close the public hearing and
adjourn until December 27 when they will meet to vote on the three items related to the Patrick Farm
development: 1. Patrick Farm Subdivision approval of a drawing entitled Patrick Farm Subdivision, consisting
of 88 tax lots on 196.4 acres; 2. Patrick Farm Condominiums plan approval of a drawing consisting of 314 market
rate townhouses and 72 "work force flats" on 51.459 acres; 3. Patrick Farm Volunteer Housing final site development
plan approval of a drawing entitled Patrick Farm Volunteer Housing, consisting of 24 residential rental units
for community service volunteers on 5.065 acres. All votes last night were 6-0 with Timothy Scott absent and Rev.
Walter Brightman recusing himself. The public may submit written commentary to the board up until 5pm Dec. 21.
Comments should be mailed or brought to: The Ramapo Building Dept., 237 Rte. 59, Suffern, NY 10901.
December 14, 2011 With an overflow crowd and a long list
the Patrick Farm application before the Ramapo Planning Board will
continue tonight. Journal News coverage of last night's meeting can
be read here. We will present a list of principal speakers against the
project and the evidence they presented Tuesday and Wednesday evenings in the next few days.
December 10, 2011 "East
Ramapo has revised its textbook-loan policy and is taking other
corrective actions after the state
Comptroller's Office blasted the school district for its handling of millions of dollars between 2008 and 2010. The audit also
found that the district undercounted the fund balance in its budget by more than $4.5 million in 2010 and that board members
in its health insurance pool failed to make payments totaling $15,672." Journal story here.
December 7, 2011 "The town's local development corporation
is being sued by an architecture firm in a
dispute over payments for the design of its baseball stadium. The RLDC failed to pay the Nebraska-based
company $62,061, the remainder due on a contract of more than $1.5 million, according to the lawsuit."
Journal News story here.
November 30, 2011 In a phone call to
the Chief Examiner of the Office of the State
Comptroller, we were told that the final version of the audit of the Town of Ramapo will
be posted within three weeks on the State website at www.osc.state.ny.us.
2011 County Legislator Joseph Meyers sent the following notice in an
email to his constituents: "I will be having a County budget information session at Airmont
Village Hall on Tuesday, November 29th at 8pm. Please come to learn more about the projected
2012 County budget and share your concerns and ideas before the Legislature votes on the budget
in early December. This directly affects all of us. The County Executive’s proposed budget for
2012 would increase County Property Taxes by about 30% for next year and cut many jobs and
services besides. It would close the County nursing home. Even with all of that, the budget
is still out of balance to the tune of about $18million." (More)
November 20, 2012 Last week, the Ramapo
Town Board approved the 2012 budget for the Town.
We received a copy of the full document at the end of the week, and have begun the process of
analyzing the various sections of the plan. At the same time, the highly critical final audit of the
Town is due back from the comptroller, probably shortly after Thanksgiving. (More)
Thank You from the Candidates,
with a Comment on
the Two-Party System in Ramapo--click here
Region's aging schools crumble as finances falter
November 13, 2011 "In East Ramapo, it's
not clear how officials can pay for $34 million
in repairs outlined by inspectors. The district, operating on a contingency budget, has
cut almost 400 employees since 2008 despite growing enrollment." Read the complete LoHud
report on schools in the lower Hudson Valley here.
Numbers for the Voter Turnout
Recent totals at the Board of Elections list
58,806 registered voters in the Town of
Ramapo. In the November general election there was a total of 21,395 who voted
for Supervisor. The voter turnout then was 36% of those who could have voted. By any
measure, this was a very poor showing, especially when you consider the drastic
changes taking place in the town.
Election Results for Ilan Schoenberger
November 10, 2011
Take a look at the
election results for Ilan Schoenberger and you
may (or may not) be surprised. (More)
Election Results--How the
Districts Voted and Who Won What
Click here for larger image
Districts Reporting--Nov 8
Unofficial Results from the Rockland Board of Elections
Christopher St. Lawrence 11,809
Robert Rhodes 6,799
Marino Fontana 2,787
Daniel Friedman 11,754
Brendel Logan 11,141
Emilia White 6,375
Patricia Wooters 6,151
Michael Dolan 2,399
Michael Campbell 2,308
LEGISLATURE DISTRICT 4:
Ilan Schoenberger 2,999
Michael Parietti 1,048
LEGISLATURE DISTRICT 12:
Joseph Meyers 3,002
Elye Kramer 448
LEGISLATURE DISTRICT 14:
Aney Paul 1,591
Henry Stewart 959
Louis Falco 28,477
Timothy O'Neill 20,166
Matthew Brennan 7,319
Alan Simon 11,908
Arnold Etelson 7,581
Sherri Eisenpress 24,022
Paul Chiaramonte 20,088
Karen Riley 6,590
Candidate Robert Rhodes discusses the collapse of the two-party system in Ramapo. (More)
an Oct. 31 letter to the Journal News editors, a reader in Orangeburg
complained about the
contributions that Orangetown Supervisor Paul Whalen accepted from businesses that do work for the town. Rightfully,
the reader, Pearl Samuels, pointed out, “This puts a business person in an impossible situation — how do you say ‘no’ when
it may affect your livelihood?” I think it also carries with it the malodorous pay-to-play taint that functions as that special
species of bribes-after-the-fact here in Rockland. In Ramapo, however, $9,000 would be a pretty paltry sum compared
to the hundreds of thousands paid to Supervisor St. Lawrence. His take in the last five years rounds out to $705,752.00
in political donations. (More)
St. Lawrence Asks for Extension on Disastrous State Audit
November 1, 2011 We have been informed by
Christopher Ellis, Chief Examiner of the Office of the State
that the Supervisor has asked for an extension beyond the thirty days allowed for comments on the State Audit of the
Town's financials. The report had been damning, and the delay would allow the comments to be sent back by November
4, which would take the matter past the date of the upcoming elections. If you have not read the State's review of the
financial condition of Ramapo check here.
Judge rejects legal challenges to Ramapo's Patrick Farm development
October 25, 2011 "A state judge has rejected
three lawsuits seeking to block the nearly 500-home Patrick Farm
decisions that allow the builders to start applying for construction-related permits from the town. Acting Supreme Court Justice
Thomas Walsh found the Ramapo Planning Board and Town Board followed land-use and planning regulations and state environmental
laws when approving a Monsey-based developer's highly dense development along Routes 202 and 306 outside Pomona. All three
opponents plan to appeal Walsh's decisions to the state Appellate Division." Journal story here.
Holy War--World Premier of British Documentary
Film on RLUIPA in Ramapo--1pm Sunday, Oct. 23 at
the Lafayette Theater in Suffern
Filmed in Ramapo between 2007 and earlier this year, the documentary
cases past and running. The filmmaker, Moondance, an Anglo-Italian-American production
company with Australian Associates, was established in 1987 by journalist and award-winning author, Anne MacGregor. The
London-based independent has produced programs for the BBC, Discovery US Specials, Smithsonian Networks, and ITV.
Screening is open to the public—tickets are $8 for the1pm screening at the Lafayette Theater. (Full text of the Press Release)
Here’s Your Summer Electric Bill for the
More than $30,000.00 a Month
October 21, 2011 Orange and Rockland gas
and electric bills for St. Lawrence’s ballpark
are really steep, and they were delivered to the taxpayers not to the owners of the Boulders
who use the park exclusively during the season. These bills are part of the continuing costs that
the residents will have to bear along with the boulder-size debt payments on the loans to build
the park the public didn’t want. (More)
Etelson stands on reputation after town justice primary loss
Oct.15,2011 Letter in The Journal News "I am saddened by losing the primary elections for Ramapo town justice,
St. Lawrence Rakes in $51,400.00
from those Who Built the Ballpark
Check the list here
CSL and Board Vote $1.6 million more for the Ballpark
7 Cost Overruns for Holt, Morano, and AKRF Inc.
October 11, 2011 If you thought you were done paying for St.
Lawrence’s ballpark you are mistaken. Tonight, at the
Ramapo Town Board Meeting, Supervisor St. Lawrence and the town board members unanimously voted to approve
10 change orders for construction and testing at the baseball park. The total cost to the taxpayers was $1,632,079.00.
October 5, 2011 Within the span of six
days, Supervisor St. Lawrence and others associated with
him were found guilty of denying a worker’s civil rights in one courtroom and of improperly sticking
the taxpayers of the town of Ramapo with a $25 million debt in another. In neither place, though,
were there any penalties handed down by the judges. (More)
Can-Am Pittsfield Team Folds--New York Traveling Team
also Gone Hobbled League is Now Left With Six Teams
October 4, 2011"The Pittsfield Colonials are no more. Team owner Buddy Lewis said the Can-Am League's owners voted
General Fund Needs Cash Infusion--So St. Lawrence Transfers
$2m from Workers’ Compensation Fund
September 28, 2011 On September 14 at the regular Ramapo Town
Board meeting, Supervisor St. Lawrence requested
authorization to make the following budget loans: $2,000,000 from the Workers’ Compensation Fund to the General Fund,
$100,000 from Ambulance District to the Highway DB account, and $400,000 from the Lighting District to A Fund. On
Friday, Sept. 23, when he was asked on WRCR why this massive withdrawal from Workers’ Compensation Fund, he
offered a confused narrative about a worker with a serious medical condition to account for $1million of the transfer.
He didn’t have much to say about the other $1million. He did, however, insist, once again that there are no cash-flow
problems at the Town. (More)
September 27, 2011 In
the New York State Comptroller’s report on money and Ramapo Town
governance, the examiners described the Town Board as ineffectual and often ignorant of the
issues on which they voted. "In fact," the Comptroller’s Office reports, "Board members told us
that they did not know how much the baseball stadium would cost the taxpayers or how it
would be paid for." None of that seemed to bother Board Member Daniel Friedman who, more
than any other councilman, hustled quite a pile of donations from those involved with Project
Grand Slam (the ballpark). He might not know what it would cost the taxpayers, but he certainly
knows what it was worth to him. (More)
September 27, 2011
"An East Ramapo school district resident is petitioning the state
Department of Education to halt the 2011-12
lease of Hillcrest Elementary School to Congregation Yeshiva Avir Yakov of New Square. "East Ramapo has an appraisal in front of it
that says the fair market rental value of this property is $10.50 per square foot, yet still they arbitrarily turned around and leased the
property for $4.22 per square foot," Forrest said Monday. "There's no rationale on how (the Board of Education) arrived at that figure.
It's troubling, and we're operating on an austerity budget, and the district could use that income." Forrest's petition further charges
that Avir Yakov has fallen behind in its monthly payments on the prior lease and owes $3,500 in back rent since January." Journal story here.
September 25, 2011 While St. Lawrence and his
political cronies partied in their luxury box,
five of the Boulders were homeless at the home field. Being paid less than $1,200 a month
doesn't give you too many options, and their own organization and the politicians who built
their $70 million stadium didn't think they were required to help them. In fact, "Boulders
president Ken Lehner said the team had no obligation to provide housing to the players." The
Journal reported, "For the last couple weeks of the Rockland Boulders' inaugural season, Mike
Richard ate his postgame meal at Provident Bank Park and slept on a training room table in the
clubhouse. Don't call it dedication. Richard said he and four of his teammates had no other place to go." Full story here.
September 24, 2011 "Enrollment is up in the East
Ramapo school district this year, and unanticipated numbers of students
entering from outside the district and outside the U.S. are contributing to crowded classrooms and overextended teachers.
Compounding the problem, many of the district's new students don't speak English, putting stress on the faculty and causing
the district to examine its need for special services the students may require.Some students who were signed up for Advanced
Placement, or AP, Regents and honors courses have been shut out of those classes." Story here.
"Return town finances to sound practices", and "Ramapo: 3 hats and no checks and balances." Read both letters here.
September 21, 2011How bad was the State Audit of the Town of Ramapo and its Board?
Sept. 21, 2011
The New York state comptroller did
a great job revealing the irresponsible spending and reckless lack of
financial controls that characterize the town of Ramapo. Furthermore, the auditors' very conservative observation that
St. Lawrence's stadium is probably not going to pay for itself was well taken. Read entire letter here.
Sept.19, 2011 "Auditors said that
Ramapo Town Board members appeared to be in the dark about how the
financing worked, and said they did not know how much it would cost taxpayers, or how the project was being financed.
Yet, a majority voted in favor of the project every time. How and why Town Board members went along with the scheme
to build a stadium with no idea how it would be paid for, or even how much it would cost, is a question voters must
continue to ask." Full text of the editorial here.
Sept. 16, 2011 At around four this
afternoon, in a White Plains Federal courtroom, a jury returned a
verdict of guilty against
Supervisor St. Lawrence in the Tim Cronin first amendment lawsuit. St. Lawrence had been charged with taking retaliatory
action against Cronin when the employee of the Spook Rock Golf Course refused to place a large four by eight plywood campaign
sign for St. Lawrence on his front lawn. "The verdict was delivered Friday afternoon at the U.S. District Court after several hours
of jury deliberations and after days of testimony during which Ramapo Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence was cross-examined. The
jury found that Timothy Cronin's refusal to allow St. Lawrence's campaign signs on his property in 2005 was a motivating factor in
his termination, 11 months later, from his job at Ramapo's Spook Rock Golf Course." The jury did not award any damages. George
Cotz represented Cronin in the action. Journal News coverage here, the back story on what happened here.
Sept.14, 2011 Letter in The Journal News
How ironic that these two letters praising Ramapo Town Supervisor
Christopher St. Lawrence for building a baseball stadium
over the objections of the majority of his own constituents were from writers living outside of Ramapo. (More)
Primary Returns: Joe Meyers wins the
Democratic Line for Legislature--Robert Rhodes, Patsy Wooters and
Emilia White Fail to Win Democratic Line--all will Campaign on the Preserve Ramapo Line
Among those who lost in the Democratic Primary: Henry Stewart, Denet Alexandre, Tim O'Neill, Karen Reilly,
Arnold Etelson, and Rita Louie
September 7, 2011 Alan Simon, candidate for
Ramapo Town Justice, told the Monsey Advocate in a front-page
that he was capable of handling 170 cases a day in the Spring Valley courtroom where he serves as village justice. He offered
this astounding claim in response to those who have pointed out that it’s unwise to have one judge serving on two courts,
both with very busy schedules. By reassuring the public that he can deal with landlord-eviction cases, small claims lawsuits,
even criminal matters in even less time than it takes to prepare a two-minute egg, Simon has redefined the term "judicious"
for us all. A carefully considered and weighed legal opinion is, apparently, available to all who appear in his Spring Valley court
in an average of less than two minutes per case, no matter the nuances, evidence or complexities. If you prefer your judicial renderings loose
and runny, you probably couldn’t do better than this short-order judge. Our objections to Mr. Simon’s candidacy, however, also include his
controversial tenure as head of the Ramapo Building Planning and Zoning Department when he was the highest paid official at Town Hall. (Story
looks at this instant Justice problem, reviews a Journal News editorial very critical of his years as Director of Planning and Zoning in Ramapo, and
provides a clear example of Simon's disregard for the law as Planning Director)
Digging an $85M Hole for Taxpayers in Ramapo—Is a Major Tax Hike on the Horizon?
Sept. 1, 2011 In the short span from June
9, 2010, to July 29, 2011, Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence and his
town board have
passed 18 bonds creating more than $85 million in new debt for the Ramapo taxpayers. That’s about $7 million more than the total
of the entire 2011 annual budget for the town. What’s going on? (More)
August 23, 2011 Is it the deal of the
century? How did an unknown marketing expert from Florida gain total
control of a $70 million
stadium/catering facility without risking a penny of his own money? In 2009 Ken Lehner incorporated Bottom 9 Ball (B9B). He is the
only officer listed in the document of incorporation. This corporation supposedly has a number of "owners." What kind of an investment
does an individual have to make in order to become an owner? We have no idea, in fact we have no idea if this corporation has any assets
of any kind. All we do know is that the number of "owners" and their names seem to change on a regular basis. (More)
Bears Might Join the Colonials as Teams Absent from the Can-Am League next Year
August 21, 2011 The Independent League, in
which the Rockland Boulders play, might be missing two teams next year.
Pittsfield Colonials teeter on bankruptcy this season (see As Boulders Prepare for Opener), the Newark Bears have prospects
as bleak in their digs in Newark. An article in yesterday's New York Times outlines the problems. If the Bears and the Colonials
fail, that would put the Boulders in a six-team league. The Boulders rocky season continues in next to last place, 20 games out.
Read the Times article Did Newark Bet on the Wrong Sport? here.
Habitat report stirs concerns for Haverstraw Bay--Desalination Plant cited
August 22, 2011
"A new state report on the Hudson River's fish and wildlife habitats
states that certain activities
would significantly impair Haverstraw Bay, considered the aquatic nursery of the historic waterway. In the case of Haverstraw
Bay, the report states that 'any activity that would degrade water quality, increase turbidity or sedimentation, alter flows,
water salinities or temperature ... would result in significant impairment of the habitat.' Rockland County Legislature Chairwoman
Harriet Cornell, D-West Nyack, submitted comment on the new report, which is still in draft version, concerned by the impacts
Judge Orders All Attorneys to Court on Monday,
Aug 22--ROSA's Lawsuit
to be Argued in State Supreme Court
August 19, 2011 Full text of the ROSA press release here.
Read the Journal News story Ramapo housing lawsuit may hinge on aquifer under 497 planned homes
"Please be advised that no such record exists"
August 18, 2011 Preserve Ramapo frequently
submits Freedom of Information Act (FOIL) requests for public documents
order to check the reality against politicians’ public rhetoric. Recently, Supervisor St. Lawrence and his assistant Phil Tisi
have been claiming that the profits at the Boulder’s baseball games will cover the costs for the numerous multi-million-dollar
loans and will even generate a profit for the town. That’s the rhetoric, and you’ll hear the same talking points repeated by
these individuals on local radio and in stories in the newspapers. We submitted several FOIL requests to vet these claims, and,
not surprisingly, there is a wide disconnect between the claims and the cash accounts. (More)
New Square Flouts Building Safety Codes: Clout
Protects Hasidic Enclave
from State Rules
August 10, 2011 "At least 60% of the
structures in New Square have serious code violations," said Kim
retired in April as chief of the fire department responsible for New Square. "It’s only a matter of time before someone
gets killed." Read the full text of the story from the current issue of The Jewish Daily Forward here.
August 3, 2011 Rita Louie, the current
deputy mayor of Pomona and a long-time
activist and advocate
for good government in Rockland decides she wants to run for county legislature in her district. She and
her team of supporters/petitioners gather and submit 426 signatures, well above the required number of
281. Michael Grant, the incumbent legislator in that district, and the choice of the Haverstraw machine,
turns in 434 signatures. (More)
July 28, 2011 An article in today’s Journal News attempts
to present a balanced analysis of the financial state of the Boulder’s
and the baseball stadium. (See Rockland Boulders So Far: Rock-solid or a millstone?) A fatal flaw at the center of the
discussion is that many of the numbers could not be vetted by the reporter because these key figures have not been
made public. In fact, some of them have been kept from the public. (More)
July 27, 2011 "A state appeals panel
has temporarily blocked a justice's order holding Ramapo and its
Planning Board in contempt
concerning a yeshiva's Kiryas Radin adult student housing complex on Grandview Avenue. The case, while increasing the town's
legal costs in the 7-year-old dispute to more than $1 million, focuses on the Planning Board ignoring a state justice's order to
conduct a complete environmental impact statement. A second issue centered on the board legalizing occupancies." Ramapo's
appeal of Supreme Court Justice Frances Nicolai's contempt and eviction order will now go before the Appellate Division in Brooklyn."
The complete Journal News story here.
July 22, 2011 That's the headline of
the Journal News story. But there's a serious question to be answered
here. Christopher St.
Lawrence's Ramapo Local Development Corp. built the ballpark, and they broke the environmental laws that prompted this
fine. St. Lawrence is the President of the RLDC and he is the Chairman of the Board of the RLDC, so why are the taxpayers
asked to bail out his sorry butt once again for this illegal activity at Fireman's Memorial Drive? I guess part of the answer is
traceable to his board of sock puppets who will vote for any and all expenses relating to the ballpark, but the primary problem
is with the Supervisor who has built this $70m disaster on lies. The voters overwhelmingly rejected the funding of this thing, and
he told anyone who would listen that no taxpayers' dollars would be spent, and yet he continues to bill the public. If you see
Mr. St. Lawrence at a public appearance, or any of his board members, make it a point to ask them, Why did they lie? And demand
a straight answer. We are past the point where they can be allowed to endanger the economic well being of the entire town
with this kind of arrogant, catastrophic governing. Journal Story can be read here.
July 11, 2011 In a letter to The
Journal News a reader writes: "I have been getting angrier and
angrier thinking about former
East Ramapo School Board President Nathan Rothschild's 11th grade education. During the court proceedings, when he entered
a guilty plea on federal charges, Rothschild admitted he had only an 11th grade education." Read the full letter here.
July 7, 2011 On Wednesday evening, Aron
Rottenberg was invited to deliver the invocation at the
Rockland County Legislature meeting. Later in the evening, Legislator Meyers proposed a resolution
calling on the FBI to take a leading role in the investigation of the deadly assault on the Rottenberg
family within New Square. What followed was an object lesson in the way elected officials stand up to or acquiesce quietly
to the voting cartels. (More)
July 7, 2011 "The state Department of Education has ordered
the East Ramapo school district to temporarily halt the sale of the
Colton School, a department spokesman confirmed Wednesday. Commissioner John King has issued a stay in the school sale pending
his decision on an appeal filed June 20 by Brenda Carole Anderson. Anderson has accused the board of failing to made a good-faith
effort when it voted 5-2 to sell the school for $6.6 million to the Bais Malka/Hebrew Academy for Special Children. In July 2010,
the Town of Ramapo assessed the school and the parcel of more than 15 acres on Grandview Avenue at $11,962,569. The appeals
process typically lasts for months before a final decision. The district cannot take any action toward selling the school during
that period." Full text of The Journal News story here.
July 6, 2011 Bob Dillon has created an
in-depth evaluation of the United Water Joint Proposal for building a
desalination plant to
draw drinking water from the Hudson. His study addresses five serious flaws in the Water Company's argument, including: the proposal
is incomplete without the groundwater study by the US Geological Survey; it does not consider the illegal releases from Lake De Forest
to New Jersey customers of United Water; it doesn't consider additional supplies from Lake Tappan; nor does it consider Rockland's
riparian rights to additional water supply from the Hackensack River; it doesn't account for the economic cost of desalination (adding
almost $500 a year more to customers; and it doesn't have realistic estimates about the supposed ratable benefits for Haverstraw. Dillon's
study is complete with volumes of reference material linked to his analysis. Read it here.
Town Board Still Spending $1million per week on the Ballpark—
June Overruns Equal $4+ million—Votes still unanimous at 5-0
July 1, 2011 They say baseball is a game of numbers, but here in
Ramapo it’s not the numbers
on the field that are impressive. As the team is muddling along, struggling to get out of next
to last place with a 12 and 19 record, the Ramapo Town Board keeps piling on the debt with
millions in cost overruns at meeting after meeting. In the two board meetings in June, the
million dollars a week pace has been matched again. And for those who think the ballpark
is built and the spending is over, take some time to attend a board meeting—the wasteful
spending continues on this project. (More)
In Rockland, water's in all the wrong places
Jul. 1, 2011 Community View in The
Re "Rockland flooding might be worst since 1999," June 24 article: "After all the flooding and the "State of Emergency"
issued by the Rockland County Executive's office on June 23, we must ask ourselves the question: Does Rockland County
actually have a water shortage? It's a vital question as United Water, which supplies water to a majority of Rockland residents,
moves forward on plans to tap the Hudson River to supply water to the county. Just days before the storm that flooded many
homes and businesses in Rockland, about 50 county planning officials and residents met in Haverstraw Town Hall to hear
Paul Heisig, hydrologist with the U.S. Geological Survey, present the findings of the Rockland County Water Resource Assessment,
a five-year scientific study that was funded by the County of Rockland, the state Department of Conservation and United Water. (More)
June 30, 2011 The Journal News is reporting that "Former East
Ramapo schools chief
and Monsey fire commissioner Nathan Rothschild this morning pleaded guilty to engaging
in a mail fraud scheme. He could face up to 20 years in prison for the felony charge."
Rothschild was charged with attempting to sell public property worth $125,000 to eliminate
his own personal debts. The federal judge who accepted the plea said Rothschild will
likely serve 2 to 3 years for the offenses. (More)
June 20, 2011
Conspiracy, literally, a breathing together,
has been called the prosecutor's best friend. Recent events in New
suggest that a charge of conspiracy will be used in the prosecution of the persons allegedly involved in acts of intimidation and worse
against the families of Aron Rottenberg, Dovid Fromovitz and other members of the community. (More)
June 16, 2011 When
the Ramapo Town Planning Board was ordered by the state Supreme Court to
re-evaluate the Adult Student Housing
complex on Grandview Avenue, beginning with a new environmental impact study, board member Dora Green expressed her own
legal opinion at a board meeting saying she didn’t think Judge Nicolai had the legal right to tell them to do that. Yesterday, Nicolai held
the Planning Board and the Town of Ramapo in contempt. His published decision "gives Ramapo 45 days to nullify all final approvals for
the ASH housing project and evict the tenants, except for the 16 families approved previously by the court." Ramapo taxpayers will now
be paying the legal bills for the opponents who filed the lawsuit that resulted in this decision. Ms. Green might better represent those
residents by: a) Remaining awake during critical hearings on which she is supposed to vote, and b) Refraining from the amateur practice
of law, which is not one of the requirements for a planning board member. Read The Journal News story here, and the complete text
of the judge's order here.
June 10, 2011 He’s a politician with
a past—and a building inspector with baggage, as well. And now
he’s the Deputy Town Superintendent of Highways at a salary of $80,000 per year. At a time when all
other levels of government are cutting, does Ramapo’s Dept. of Highways need an additional high-price
functionary? St. Lawrence and his board think so. (More)
June 6, 2011 Using the facts
presented, Commissioner David M. Steiner ordered that the July 28, 2010
sale of the Hillcrest
Elementary School be nullified because "the board abused its discretion by hastily approving the sale of Hillcrest [school]
to the Congregation [Yeshiva Avir Yakov] and that such sale must be set aside." Click here for Journal News coverage. To
read the full statement from the Education Commissioner, click here.
June 5, 2011
"Residents who defy this Hasidic
enclave's spiritual leader say they live in fear of a band of thugs who
violently defend his edicts — and they cite a recent arson attack as the latest example of the group's work. Described as "jihadis"
by those who fear them and "hotheads" by some village leaders, the group numbers up to 40 men and boys between the ages of
15 and 35, current and former members of the community told The Journal News." Complete Journal coverage here.
June 4, 2011
"They will assist us and will
not take over the case," said Ramapo Detective Lt. Mark Emma. "If they
federal crimes have been committed, they will make a determination on whether to pursue them." Police and the FBI
will not only investigate the attempt to burn down the home of Aron Rottenberg, 43, but also months of vandalism,
harassment and threats in the Hasidic Jewish village, Emma said. Full text of The Journal News story here.
June 3, 2011 For the second
time in 10 days, The Journal News has called for an
of the Ramapo Police Department in its handling of the events leading up to the arson attack
on Aron Rottenberg and his family in New Square. And now there’s another legal question for
the state or federal authorities. Why is an obvious hate crime not being investigated as a
hate crime, and why has Shaul Spitzer, the accused arsonist, not been charged with a
hate crime? Who made the decision to drop this from the case, and what are the legal
consequences for the authorities who decided to ignore state and federal statutes on bias crimes? (More)
June 2, 2011
County Legislator Joe Meyers has joined the call for a federal
probe into the recent events in New Square where
Aron Rottenberg was recently burned over more than half his body for his decision to pray outside his community’s synagogue.
“A federal probe is necessary because issues of civil rights and freedom of religion are involved and these are potential federal
crimes. Furthermore, we all saw Ramapo Supervisor Chris St. Lawrence, who is the head of the Town of Ramapo Police Commission,
dismiss the incident as an isolated one based on assurances he received after the incident by the Deputy Mayor of New Square.
This is not appropriate conduct given his position and the on-going investigation”, said Legislator Meyers. Press release text here.
Political Whitewash of Arson Attack Begins--
Newspaper and Lawyer Demand Federal Investigation
May 26, 2011 The opening of the Journal News editorial is
hardly ambiguous. "Aron Rottenberg
of New Square has long complained to Ramapo Police that he has suffered for his decision
to pray outside his community's synagogue. Now he is in critical condition with burns over half
his body, and an 18-year-old New Square resident is charged with attempted murder,
arson, and assault. Federal authorities, better positioned to inquire where local officials
will not, should vigorously investigate the attack, and the systematic harassment that preceded
it, as a civil rights violation and hate crime." (More)
May 20, 2011
On April 16, East Ramapo School
President, Nathan Rothschild, was charged in U.S.
District Court with mail fraud in an attempt to
defraud the public. Rothschild is free on bail
and has resigned as President of the Board.
Yesterday, Aaron Wieder, current Vice President of the Board, was arrested and charged with violations of the state
election law. Charges arose from a poll watcher at Hillcrest Elementary who said Wieder was photographing and
otherwise intimidating voters, and, along with two unknown men, blocked the entrance to the school, preventing
voters from entering the polling station. Wieder was released without bail and is due to appear in Clarkstown Town
Court on June 15. Story in today's Journal News here.
May 10, 2011
"The settlement of the U.S. Attorney's
Office's 2005 lawsuit against the Ramapo village could end a
legal action involving the Hillside Avenue development sought by the Hasidic congregation. Journal News coverage here.
May 7, 2011 The regular Ramapo town board meetings are scheduled
second and fourth Wednesdays of each month in the evening (8pm) at Town Hall.
State law requires notifying the press of these meetings "at least one week prior",
and providing "conspicuous posting in one or more public locations at least 72 hours
before such meeting." This year, there were two very important town board
meetings about which the public got virtually no advance notice. The first, a daytime
meeting on Feb. 17, was kept from the press and the public until 53 minutes before
the meeting was to begin. The second, April 14, was scheduled for the morning after
the regular Wednesday night meeting. On Monday, April 11, Supervisor St. Lawrence
notified the board members of the meeting. He then sat on the information until late
in the afternoon of the day before the 11am meeting, when he had it faxed it to the newspapers. At these two meetings,
protected from public scrutiny, St. Lawrence and his board passed nine resolutions that itemized $51,721,990.85 in new
spending—much of it for the ballpark project which had been rejected by the public last fall. (More)
May 7, 2011 In a recent press release, State Comptroller Thomas
DiNapoli wrote: "Local governments are supposed to
use LDCs for economic development purposes. But we found that isn't always the case. Time after time, our auditors
uncovered LDCs being used to skirt the laws governing local government operations. And that's costing taxpayers money."
Citing an ongoing pattern of abuse, the Comptroller has introduced a package of reforms. Christopher St. Lawrence formed
the Ramapo Local Development Corp (LDC), and he became its President and Chairman of the Board. The Ramapo LDC is
currently building a housing complex in Spring Valley, Project Grand Slam, and it plans to build a hotel in Sloatsburg and
a housing development there also. He has committed tens of millions of Ramapo taxes to the ballpark while still publicly
insisting that it will be built with private funds. There have been no investors and the cost, which St. Lawrence claimed
would only be $25m is now bumping up against a $70m completion total. The land for both projects belonged to the taxpayers
before St. Lawrence and his board gave the first two properties, the S.V. housing project and ballpark site, to his LDC.
The first two projects for his LDC could reach $90-$100m, and St. Lawrence is just getting started. Preserve Ramapo has been
working for months to provide the information and to get the state Comptroller involved. The Journal Story (here) outlines
what we hope is a beginning of a hard look at the books kept by the Supervisor's private development company.
April 19, 2011 "The NAACP announced Monday that the United States
Department of Education Office of Civil Rights
has begun investigating the East Ramapo School District."We cannot release any information as to what they're looking
at or what they're looking for, but we do know that they have begun an investigation into the functioning of the East
Ramapo School District," Aldridge said, adding that the U.S. Department of Education has asked that the particulars
of the investigation be withheld." Complete Journal News story here.
April 18, 2011 The final maps are up on the GIS County Portal
website. We also look
at the comments from a Chestnut Ridge Trustee, Howard Cohen, delivered before the
committee on April 11. Links to maps and comments here.
April 15, 2011 "East Ramapo Board of Education President Nathan
resigned from his role with the district Friday amid federal charges that he
engaged in a mail fraud scheme while serving as a Monsey fire commissioner.
Rothschild, 54, of Monsey, appeared in U.S. District Court in White Plains on
Friday, pleading not guilty to the felony charge, said Herb Hadad, a spokesman
for the U.S. Attorney's Office. Hadad said Rothschild used his position as fire
commissioner to cause Monsey to enter into a real estate deal with one of his
personal creditors in order to pay an outstanding debt." Complete Journal News
article can be read here. "Rothschild faces a maximum sentence of 20 years in
prison and a maximum fine of the greater of $250,000 or twice the gross gain or loss derived from the crime (Press
Release -- US Attorney's Office)." Read the full text of the press release here.
St. Lawrence and Entire Board Backdoors $25m Bond for the
OKs Process Hidden from the Public—Moody’s downgrades Bond Rating and
Assigns Negative outlook to LDC Bonds
April 12, 2011 The last time the Ramapo Supervisor and his Board
wanted to bond $16.5m for the ballpark, they posted a public notice
in the Rockland County Times. They said in the notice that this loan was subject to "permissive referendum" (the public could be
allowed to vote on it), and the matter was handled in public Town Board meetings—this was all done as a matter of required procedure,
probably not out of any sense of fair play or open government. They got killed in that vote. More than 70% of the taxpayers told them
absolutely no taxpayer dollars should be spent on the ballpark. Immediately afterwards, St. Lawrence publicly vowed, "I got the message.
There will be no taxpayer dollars." But then the investors who were supposed fund this project never showed up. And you can’t blame
them given the unbelievably shaky history of the Can-Am Baseball League (73% failure overall, 100% failure in New York State). Even banks
refused to make the loans. So the race to get ready for the June opening ramps up to three shifts around the clock and at $30m and counting
you’re running out of money. What can you do? SHUT THE LIGHTS OUT! You don’t publish any public notice this time. No Legal Notice in the
paper, no visibility for the public. Then call a special meeting of the Town Board at four o’clock in the afternoon (that was Feb. 17). No one
there to see and hear the vote—a 5 to 0 complete agreement on a new $25m bond for the ballpark: that’s St. Lawrence, Daniel Friedman,
Fran Hunter, Pat Withers, and Itzy Ullman all colluding to keep these tens of millions borrowed for the ballpark hidden away from public sight.
And yesterday, the IPREO Municipal Deal Calendar lists a $25m Revenue Bond (fully backed by the Town of Ramapo—the taxpayers, that is)
offered by the Ramapo Local Development Corp. What began as monumental lie by the Supervisor promising that the will of the taxpayers
would be honored and "The stadium will be built with private money. There will be no taxpayer dollars. I got the message." has developed
into a wider, absolute betrayal of the residents of Ramapo by the town board and the lead town attorney Michael Klein. (More)
April 6, 2011 From The Journal News editorial Page: "St.
Lawrence has gotten into plenty of dust-ups over his "Project Grand
starting with the supervisor's pledge not to use taxpayer money for the project. After voters soundly defeated an August referendum
to guarantee building loans taken out by the Ramapo Local Development Corporation, St. Lawrence said, "I got the message." He didn't.
St. Lawrence and his majority on the Town Board continued to use town money to pay for [the project]. The stadium's full cost has
topped $30 million, according to St. Lawrence, although Preserve Ramapo pegs the costs at near $60 million. Miffed taxpayers, however,
are not without recourse: As always, they can remember St. Lawrence's role — and that of board supporters Frances Hunter and Daniel
Friedman — when they fill out their "lineup" cards on the next election day." St. Lawrence has needed Friedman and Hunter's votes to
continue paying for the stadium with taxpayer money. All three are up for election this November. Complete editorial here.
April 5, 2011 The decision from the court was disappointing for
what it said and even more so for what it left out.
Judge Jamieson seemed to deal with one single issue while disregarding a dozen other legal points in the proceeding. (More)
The Journal News story "Preserve Ramapo loses bid to stop baseball stadium" is up here.
hy·poc·ri·sy noun, pl sies
March 24, 2011
If you attend a sufficient number of Ramapo board meetings, you will likely find yourself one evening asking,
They don’t really believe that stuff they’re saying, do they? Surely there’s a limit to their capacity for
self deception. (More)
March 17, 2011 Community View in The
Journal News "The private investors never showed up, so work in and
around the crater on Pomona Road is 100 percent taxpayer funded. In one recent two-week period, cost overruns
totaled $2.3 million. St. Lawrence and two council members, Fran Hunter and Daniel Friedman, didn't bat an eye
voting their approval. (Feb. 23 Town Board meeting minutes show $2,315,890.30 approved.) That was just two
weeks after a Feb. 9 Town Board meeting at which the same three approved $1,307,069.85 in overruns." (More)
March 11, 2011 After an inspection at the site yesterday, the
NYS DEC found a number of
violations and ordered a stop to all construction activities except for the work necessary
to correct the half dozen violations. This is not the first time violations have shut down
the project. (More)
If you'd like a picture of how corrupt the political process can be
here in Rockland and Ramapo click here.
February 28, 2011 "A Monsey company that provides Ramapo with
liability insurance carriers and handles the town's
claims is associated with the firm charged last week by federal prosecutors in a $550 million insurance scam. The LeBaum
Co. is providing the town with $491,166 in liability insurance through three companies until February 2012." Full text
of The Journal News story here.
Monsey businessman and political activist, Chaim Lebovits, was named in
a Federal indictment
last week along with five others accused of multiple counts of insurance fraud, money laundering and wire fraud.
As Managing General Agent and Vice-President of Liberty Planning, Inc., an insurance agency located in Monsey,
the defendant and others are alleged to have purchased large insurance policies for “Straw Buyers” offering
fraudulent information and then created trusts to sell the policies on the secondary market. The Department of
State lists Moishe E. Lebovits as Chairman or CEO of Liberty Planning, Inc. Moishe is also Chairman or CEO of
LeBaum Company, the company that insures the Town of Ramapo. (More)
February 27, 2011 At every Ramapo Town Board meeting there are
cost overruns and change orders approved
for hundreds of thousands of dollars for St. Lawrence’s ballpark. The Town Attorney Michael Klein doesn’t identify
the project when he abbreviates the reading of the resolution, and only two of the council vote for approval along
with St. Lawrence. Fran Hunter and Daniel Friedman vote to approve the spending. At the last Town Board meeting,
Feb. 23, the total approved by St. Lawrence/Hunter/Friedman was more than $2million. This time, the baseball
tax trio voted while the other two council members, Itzy Ullman and Pat Withers, were out of the room. (More)
Who’s Paying for the Ballpark—Part 2
Entire Package of State Aid for Ramapo Used up
One Cost Overrun for St. Lawrence’s Ballpark
February 23, 2011 In the governor’s
proposed budget, aid to all municipalities will be
cut by about 2%. The Town of Ramapo, which receives the greatest share of state aid
of any town in the County, will have its aid package cut by almost $9,000, but that hardly
makes any difference because St. Lawrence, Hunter and Friedman have blown the entire
amount of state aid in 2011 on one check to Turco Golf for a cost overrun on their
ballpark project. (More)
February 15, 2011 "Ramapo
building and fire inspectors have found evidence of 22 apartments
being occupied in violation
of a state judge's order and town regulations at a congregation's adult student housing project off Grandview Road outside
New Hempstead. In late January, attorneys for four villages provided Nicolai with utility bills that indicated at least 17 more
units were illegally occupied. Nicolai said the evidence was overwhelming; he called Ramapo derelict in its duties to uphold
his order and town zoning rules and order another inspection." Journal News story here.
February 11, 2011 Following on the announcement that Alan Simon
has quit as planning director in Ramapo, The Journal News
printed an editorial today that opened with: "Ramapo Planning and Zoning Administration Director Alan Simon has issued his
resignation, which takes effect March 4. The date represents an opportunity for Ramapo, where land-use issues and zoning
enforcement are the spark of fiery politics. It is time to turn around the town's legacy of ever-bending zoning regulations and
lax enforcement that has fostered an attitude among some developers that it's easier to seek forgiveness than ask permission.
By choosing someone who will enforce zoning laws and sniff out building violations, Ramapo can stem a dangerous tide of
developers who choose to ignore building codes until they get caught." It's a nice thought, but it neglects to mention that
Simon followed Brophy who left office after they found the envelope stuffed with $100 bills and the weed in the glove compartment
of his Town vehicle. It also doesn't push for an answer to the obvious question: Why wasn't Simon fired by the Supervisor when the
town attorney said he was routinely breaking the law? If this whole mess teaches us anything, it's that there's truth in the old saw--A
fish rots from its head.
February 10, 2011 "The town's embattled planning and zoning
administrator has resigned,
effective March 4. When the Town Board hired Simon, the Building Department was in
disarray after its chief inspector was forced to resign after being caught with cash and
marijuana. Simon ran zoning and planning, while another person oversaw the inspections.
Simon also began running the enforcement side and his tenure became controversial and
confrontational with other departments, specifically the town Attorney's Office and engineering
department. The battle heated up — according to letters obtained by The Journal-News — when
the town's top lawyer told Simon he was illegally signing building permits and other documents, and overruling engineering
decisions on developments. Simon was fast-tracking specific developments — mostly in Monsey — and changed town policy
to allow a developer's engineer to self-certify a project without oversight from the town's engineers and planners. Simon
responded that he acted properly and had permission from Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence. Town Attorney Michael
Klein had told the Town Board in a memo that Simon's actions potentially left Ramapo open to "significant civil and
criminal liability." Complete Journal News story here.
-- Bottom 9 Baseball Neglects to Trademark
Baseball Team's Name, Then Loses It
February 9, 2011 If you go to the Patent Office search site at
and look up Rockland Boulders, you will find a trademark filed for the baseball team,
but it’s not owned by Bottom 9 Baseball, the Can-Am League, or Christopher St. Lawrence.
Apparently the business arm of the enterprise did not have the sense to protect their most
important property—the brand. The TM is owned by a local, small businessman, Peter Vistocco. Months after Vistocco filed
and got the listing Bottom 9 finally got around to applying and found it was too late. (More)
Dropped Ball on Stadium Project
State Judge finds Ramapo yeshiva illegally housed people at Nike
Ramapo and threatens special inspector if Town doesn't end violations
February 3, 2011 "A state Supreme Court justice found the
evidence convincing that a Ramapo yeshiva allowed people to
live in adult-student housing on Grandview Avenue in violation of his orders and town law. Justice Francis Nicolai also
called Ramapo 'derelict' for allowing the illegal occupancies. 'To a large degree ... what has happened here is as a result
of the lackadaisical ... attitude of the Town of Ramapo towards this building site. ... It was absolutely clear that there
were violations of the building code ... violations of the fire code, and yet they took almost no action,' Nicolai said. He
said he might impose daily fines on Mosdos Chofetz Chaim but was concerned the fines would be absorbed by the
bankruptcy petition. The justice also said he might fine Ramapo." Journal News story here.
Can-Am League and a study in public policy failure
Tuesday, 01 February 2011 12:50
BY EVAN WEINER NEWJERSEYNEWSROOM.COM
THE BUSINESS AND POLITICS OF SPORTS
"Ramapo taxpayers better understand that this stadium will be a loss
no matter what both sides say. Ramapo officials think the team will bring in
$900,000 in stadium related revenues. The bad news, the revenues figure is grossly overstated, the good news
for Ramapo is that at this point they are not being asked to pay the team's expenses like New Orleans and
Indianapolis and Glendale, Arizona residents are doing for pro sports teams. The bad news is that Ramapo will
have to find money somewhere to pay for the annual $1.3 million stadium debt. That money won't be coming
from local college baseball teams (Rockland Community College, St. Thomas Aquinas College and Dominican
College) or high school baseball or stadium concerts, as the seating capacity is too small for anything but
small acts." (Full text of the story here)
Preserve Ramapo Files Grand Slam Lawsuit in State Supreme Court
January 28, 2011 "Among a dozen accusations — most of which town
officials already have denied — Preserve Ramapo
claims the town has improperly financed the multimillion-dollar project and wrongly transferred a taxpayer-owned 61
acres to the Ramapo Local Development Corp. The complaint filed in state Supreme Court in New City on Wednesday
also claims Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence has acted improperly by voting on financial and other issues as both a
Town Board member and as head of the development corp. The 54-page legal action also says the town and St. Lawrence
continue to fund the 3,500-seat stadium with taxpayer money, even though voters rejected the town guaranteeing
$16.5 million for the project's construction in August." Full text of The Journal News story here.
Read the Complete text of the Lawsuit here
Project Grand Slam--the Cost to the Taxpayers, so far
January 28, 2011 The question that’s likely to occur to anyone
driving by the ballpark site out on Pomona Road is,
"With no investors, how is he paying for this?" The unfortunate answer, so far, has been, "The taxpayers are paying
for it." Forget what he told the paper the day after the public soundly rejected public funding in the August 24th
referendum vote. The measure of what Mr. St. Lawrence’s word is worth appears below. "No taxpayer
dollars!"—you add them up for yourself. (More)
The Ramapo Hatter and the Reorg
January 19, 2011 Is it fair to assume you
can guess the size of a politician’s head
by the number of hats he tries to put on it? If so, then nothing short of a haberdasher’s
nightmare was created at the last Ramapo Town Board meeting. (More)
Water Resources: Wistful thinking won't replace a plan
Our Town January 5 Editorial
January 16, 2011
County Sewer Commission oversees wastewater.
The Rockland County Drainage Agency weighs in on wetlands, streams and runoff.
What official agency, determines the policy that ensures an adequate supply of drinking
water and the use and conservation of water resources in Rockland? You guessed it, no one,
thus a classic policy vacuum that is filled by the organization most likely to benefit itself,
our multinational water utility, United Water Resources." More
Legal battles continue in
Ramapo Planning Dept.--
Alan Simon lashes out at Attorney's Office and Co-workers
December 26, 2010 Apparently, Alan
Simon, Ramapo's Director of Planning and Zoning has decided that the
best defense is
a truly offensive offense, and he's gone on a tear--scripting one potential lawsuit/and or/investigation after another. Keeping
track of all the possible illegalities in this short article is a challenge, so pay attention as you add up your own total. The surprise
ending for the story might be contained in his score on a retake of the Civil Service exam. He failed it the first time around, and
now the County Personnel Office says his current job ($143k) and his $7,166 raise depend on his December 11 retake. Journal story.
Preserve Ramapo Initiates Lawsuit against Ballpark
December 19, 2010 A letter has been
sent to Christopher St. Lawrence, all the principals of the Ramapo Local
Corp., the members of the Ramapo Town Board, and Ramapo Attorney Michael Klein that explains the following legal responsibility:
"You are hereby placed on notice of such impending lawsuit. Accordingly, please be advised that you have a legal, fiduciary and
ethical obligation to disclose to any lenders, consultants, title companies and other parties involved in such land transfer or any
financing involving such land of the above impending and threatened legal claim. You may not knowingly make any representation
that is inconsistent with your knowledge of the impending and threatened lawsuit." Full text of Joseph Meyers' letter.
The Short Uneasy Career of Ryan Karben--Finance Director
December 16, 2010 It was only two
days ago that Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence announced the
appointment of Ryan
Karben as the new Ramapo Finance Director. He had bucked the straw vote of the Board members who opposed the appointment
of the ex-Assemblyman/Village Attorney. The Board, with the single exception of a political lapdog-in-training, rejected Karben,
offering a clear sign of the political risk the Supervisor was taking for his long-time ally. In fact, you can still see the vivid evidence
of that price-to-pay on the LoHud blogs. Then, this morning, Karben rewarded the Supervisor's misguided loyalty by handing in a letter
that, in effect, was a resignation. The strangest thing about the sequence of events is that Karben knew about the problem of his
personal clients appearing before the Town two days ago when he apparently accepted the offer. He let the bonfires on the blogs
burn for two days, and then, finally, today, said, "No thanks," and the anger on the blogs turned to laughter. If you missed them,
the Comments sections at the end of both stories are still up on LoHud. Original Journal story with 80 comments here. The updated
story with a different set of comments here.
Permits for Illegal School Expose Ramapo to "Significant Civil and Criminal Liability"
Dec. 15, 2010
"A religious school operating illegally on
Highview Road is receiving state funding based on Ramapo building and
officials wrongly giving the congregation a temporary permit to operate, says Ramapo town attorney Michael Klein. It appears the town
illegally issued a building permit and certificate of use which are or may be used to defraud the school district or state in providing aid.
It is patently illegal to issue a building permit and/or a certificate of occupancy or use for a building (other than one-, two- or three-family
home) if the site plan approval has not been granted. Significant civil and criminal liability may arise from this situation." Ryan Karben is
the attorney representing the school. Journal story here.
St. Lawrence Appoints Ryan Karben as Ramapo's Finance Director
Dec. 14, 2010 Despite a suspicious
exit from his State Assembly post, a recent drunk driving charge that
led to an evening in the County
lockup, and his recently being fired from his post as Spring Valley village attorney, Ryan Karben was appointed by St. Lawrence to the
position of Ramapo Finance Director over the objections of Board members Fran Hunter, Pat Withers and Itzy Ullman. The only board
member at St. Lawrence's side supporting the appointment was Daniel Friedman, whose vote on most issues has developed into little
more than an echo of the Supervisor. Karben might not be available for immediate comment, as he is likely busy in preparation for
a court date this Thursday in the Elizabeth DiGiacomo vs. High Mountain Sanitation in Rockland Civil Supreme Court. Background on
that situation is available here. The Journal News story is here.
No Decision at Patrick Farm Meeting
December 2, 2010
[In brief] Meeting runs 5 hours. 52 speakers address the Board
with objections to the project. Ken Zebrowski and
Ellen Jaffee send reps to voice concerns over aquifer
and the Columbia gas pipeline. Leonard Jackson Associates
withholds critical information from public and Town
professional staff. Planning Board member nods off.
Shortly after 1am, public session is closed but no vote
is taken. Vote not scheduled for any particular time. (Story)
Grand Slam "A project that has failure written all over it"
Nov. 27, 2010 An award-winning sports journalist writes:
"In the suburban New York City
at the Town Hall of Ramapo in Suffern, New York, which is about 35 miles north of the
George Washington Bridge, Ramapo Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence will once again
on Tuesday night explain why he feels there is the need to spend millions of dollars for a
project that has failure written all over it." Evan Weiner, the winner of the United States
Sports Academy's 2010 Ronald Reagan Media Award, has written a detailed analysis of the
economics, the faltering history of the Can-Am League, and the disasters experienced in other
regions that continue to pay for sports fields that have failed or even have been already
torn down as taxpayers are still working on the original debt. Read "No Never Means No in
the Politics of Sports Facility Construction."
Baseball Tax Heading over the Fence
Nov. 22, 2010 At the end of the
summer, on August 24, the voters of Ramapo voted to end taxpayer
funding for Christopher St. Lawrence’s
baseball park. The vote was an overwhelming 70% to 30%. In effect, the voters erected a financial wall between St. Lawrence’s RLDC
(Ramapo Local Development Corp.) and St. Lawrence’s Ramapo Town Board. About the vote, St. Lawrence told The Journal News that he
had gotten the message, and going forward, he pledged "there will be no taxpayer dollars" tossed over that wall to the RLDC and its ballpark.
An examination of the paper trail since that infamous declaration lays out a pattern of monumental deceit, some of it possibly prosecutable. (More)
Ramapo officials looking to rein in zoning boss Alan Simon
Nov. 21, 2010 “Planning
and Zoning Administration Director Alan Simon was criticized for
fast-tracking developments by overstepping his authority
by signing documents he was not permitted under law and town rules to sign, town officials and town memos said. St. Lawrence said he continues
to support Simon, even though he agrees Simon has overstepped his authority and the law by signing building permits and certificates of use and
occupancy, overruling engineers and changing town policy. He said Simon was wrong to try to ban town engineers from his office and from reviewing
development plans. And he hasn’t passed the civil service exam for his position. Simon also has changed policy by signing temporary approvals for
developments still before the Planning Board, like a religious school that opened illegally on Highview Road in a residential house. And he’s allowed
developer’s engineers to self-certify that projects followed site plans.” Yet St. Lawrence still supports him. Journal story here.
adopts $78.5M Budget—Property Taxes Up 4.9%,
Police Services Up 6.2%, Elected Officials Get 5% Raises
November 21, 2010
the State and pension funds,
St. Lawrence said during a Town Board meeting held Friday
morning to adopt the budget, "We hope the state gets their act together." An unusual sentiment from a politician who has
turned his back on the taxpayers in his Town, and despite their clear objections, seems hell-bent on spending $20 to $30 million
on a baseball park that will undoubtedly feature his name on everything but the hot dogs. That's about a third of the entire budget
total invested in a business enterprise that has a 70% likelihood of failure. Journal coverage of the tax increases here.
Questionable Activity at Ramapo Planning Dept. Widens
November 10, 2010 It was only two weeks ago that Alan Simon,
Director of the Planning and Zoning Administration, was in the news for some
rather questionable activity. Documents show that he, Simon, and Supervisor
St. Lawrence were planning to have the taxpayers pick up a $75,000 bill owed
by developer Rabbi Areyah Zaks to the State Supreme Court. Zaks had moved
16 families into his Adult Student Housing development on Grandview Ave. that
Judge Nicolai had ordered closed with an injunction. (More)
Larger photo and links to the video presentation here.
October 27, 2010 When State Supreme Court Judge
Francis Nicolai ordered that a $75,000
surety bond must be posted by the developer of the Adult Student Housing project at the
Nike base, the builder turned to an unusual source for the funding. Rabbi Areyah Zaks turned
to Town Hall and the Ramapo taxpayers for the $75,000 he owed the court. And even more
surprising, Supervisor St. Lawrence and Alan Simon, Director of Building and Zoning,
both agreed to work on the withdrawal from the town’s tax coffers. (More)
October 26, 2010 "Mayor Noramie Jasmin fired Village Attorney Ryan
Karben on Monday for not doing the job she expected
of him. Jasmin said Monday night that she fired Karben because he didn't "fulfill my expectations as the village attorney."
She didn't provide specifics." Trustee Demeza Delhomme told The Journal News, "The mayor told me there was an incident."
Journal story here.
October 15, 2010 The New York State Dept. of Environmental
Conservation-–Division of Water—inspected the Grand Slam construction
site last Thursday, and then on Tuesday of this week ordered a "stop to all
construction activities, exclusive of that work necessary to correct the
erosion and sediment control deficiencies." The DEC found five violations of
State Environmental Conservation Law ranging from no erosion controls to a larger problem with "the entire site
under construction and there are no stabilization measures." The work site includes two wetlands, one State
and one Federal, and the property drains into a large County park. (More)
October 14, 2010 Just three weeks ago, in response to an
overwhelming 70% to 30% defeat
in the ballpark referendum vote, Christopher St. Lawrence promised the 10,145 voters
who came out that he had heard them. He told The Journal News, "The stadium will be
built with private money. There will be no taxpayer dollars. I got the message." Last night,
St. Lawrence and two board members broke that promise rendering what the Supervisor
guaranteed just a few weeks ago an expedient lie. (More)
October 6, 2010 In Ramapo: "The proposed budget
would increase town property taxes by 4.97 percent, with taxes
for town police services rising 6.2 percent, and sewer user fees jumping 4.89 percent, Supervisor Christopher
St. Lawrence said. The spending plan increases spending by $3.5 million and includes 5 percent raises for elected
officials and nonunion members." Journal Story here. Clarkstown: "For the first time in recent memory, Clarkstown
residents would see a modest decrease in their taxes under a $110 million budget for 2011 proposed by the
Town Board." That story here.
October 1, 2010 "United Water’s
proposal to construct a desalination plant in
Haverstraw NY is being promoted as a source of additional property tax revenue
for the North Rockland School District and the Town of Haverstraw. However,
the average North Rockland United Water customer will likely see an increase in
annual water bills of $485, roughly 2.2 times the estimated $221 annual property
tax revenue that would accrue to the benefit of the average North Rockland
customer / household from property taxes derived from a desalination plant."
The other towns, including Ramapo will pay $485 per customer. Read Bob Dillon's
September 24, 2010 Community View
in The Journal News "The Ramapo Planning Board is deciding
whether to approve an
immense residential development on a 206-acre parcel of land known as Patrick Farm. The site sits atop a critical component
of the Ramapo River Basin, designated a sole source aquifer by the Environmental Protection Agency. I believe that the Rockland
County Legislature should begin the act of taking Patrick Farm by using eminent domain law. An Aug. 8, 1992, the EPA action
notice addresses the importance of the Ramapo aquifer systems: "As a sole source aquifer there are no viable alternative drinking
water sources of sufficient supply; and if contamination were to occur, it would pose a significant hazard to the public health."
JN Editorial: East Ramapo Sale Rightly Delayed
Sept. 2, 2010
"Questions raised about East Ramapo's sale
of Hillcrest Elementary School are apparently shared by the state
commissioner, who has halted the sale of the school.It could take up to six months for the commissioner to weigh an appeal of the
Hillcrest sale filed by East Ramapo parent and public school activist Steve White. It's worth the wait. Because of the board's lack of
transparency in its decision-making on this and other issues, the public has been denied the information needed to judge the benefit
of the property's planned sale to Yeshiva Avir Yakov of New Square." Complete editorial here.
State blocks sale of East Ramapo's Hillcrest School
Sept. 1, 2010
"The state education commissioner has
ordered the East Ramapo school district to halt the sale of Hillcrest
Elementary School, an Education Dept. spokesman confirmed Tuesday. Commissioner David Steiner issued a stay in the
school sale, pending his decision on an appeal filed with the Education Department by Steven White, a district parent,
on Aug. 7. White thinks the East Ramapo Board of Education improperly sold the school to Yeshiva Avir Yakov, a New Square
congregation, in July for about $3.2 million, far below the $10.2 million value assigned to the 12-acre property by the
Clarkstown Assessor's Office. The sale price was decided after a first appraisal valued the school and land at $5.9 million.
A second appraisal, which the board did not approve until nearly a week after the school sale, was obtained by the school district's
attorney, Albert D'Agostino." Journal News coverage here.
August 29, 2010
Letter to The Journal News "Seeing that the Ramapo baseball
stadium initiative was defeated and
seeing that Ramapo Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence is still going to move forward with this project, one must
wonder when was St. Lawrence appointed dictator of Ramapo? The taxpayers of Ramapo have spoken and we don't
want any part of this. Why the supervisor insists on still moving forward is quitebaffling. When are the taxpayers of
Ramapo going to get together and stop this behavior? Yechiel J. Rosenrauch Suffern
St. Lawrence to Ramapo: Drop Dead!
I’m going to build this stadium no matter what the voters say,
and they’re going to pay for it.
August 27, 2010 In a rare referendum vote, more than 70% of the
voters rejected taxpayer
guarantees for a $25 million baseball stadium for an Independent League team here in Ramapo.
On the night of the vote, Supervisor St. Lawrence’s challenge was repeated as he offered a
more polite phrasing for his blunt message: I don’t give a damn what they want—they’re going to
pay for it, one way or another, and I’m going to build it. (More)
August 24, 2010 The vote count was an
overwhelming 7 to 3 margin against spending $16.5 million taxpayers'
dollars for a stadium
for an Independent League ball team. The totals published by the Town were 7,166 No (against funding the ballpark), and 2,979
Yes (in favor of the funding). The total number of voters was 10,145 with an overwhelming 70.6% showing up to reject the
resolution . The rare referendum special election was the only check of the public of its kind in recent memory, and the voters
were hardly equivocal in their opinion. Check the Journal News coverage. Click here for a breakdown of districts.
August 3, 2010 Another piece of
Ramapo history has been obliterated
from the landscape--to be paved over with parking lots. The most
recent views and a retrospective of what had been on the site--a legacy
that reaches back to pre-Revolutionary Ramapo.
July 28, 2010
destruction of a pristine woods at the
corner of Pomona Road and Firemen's Memorial Drive has
accelerated as the politician who has proved himself to be
the greatest threat to Ramapo's environment blunders ahead
without the funding or support for a project that he has
repeatedly said in public is going to be built whether the
taxpayers want it or not. Photos and link to Flickr catalog
of images here.
July 23, 2010
Federal prosecutors and owners of a violation-ridden and unsanitary
processing plant have reached an agreement that permanently shuts down the slaughtering
operation but could allow storage and sale of imported fowl inspected by the government.
The U.S. Attorney's Office took civil action in December against New Square Meats for
unsanitary conditions at the plant and selling poultry since 2002 that the U.S. Department of
Agriculture never inspected. Adir Poultry, a company connected to New Square Meats and Ezras Yisrael, wants to replace the
5,000-square-foot slaughterhouse with a $3 million, 26,250-square-foot plant." Journal News story here.
July 19, 2010
"Assuming Bottom 9 Baseball
gets into the Can-Am League (and pays a million dollars
or so for that right) and is set to go and Ramapo or the RLDC gets the stadium funding together, the new
facility will be built over the winter and will be ready to open on June 6, 2011. Bottom 9 Baseball will
be throwing a million dollars or four percent of the estimated costs into the venue. The team will pay $175,000
a year in rent. It would take more than a century for Ramapo to get back the construction costs at that rate.
The team threw a couple of bones to Ramapo. The municipality will get a dollar for each ticket sold (not including those seats
in the stadium's 20 luxury boxes – the town will get some money from those seats and some money from the sale of the stadium's
naming rights. What are the odds that a Ramapo Stadium can get any money for naming rights when the New York Giants/Jets
Meadowlands Stadium, the Dallas Cowboys Stadium and the Golden State Warriors facility are still unnamed?)" Complete article
July 11, 2010 "A
consultant estimates that a new Can-Am Association ballpark in Ramapo,
N.Y., should turn a profit if things go well. But a closer look at the number shows that
the city has almost no room for error and will rely on offseason events, not baseball, to
cover debt payment." The site's editors also have this to say: "Crunching the numbers: It
will take $700,000-$800,000 just for debt service on $25 million in bonds on a 20-year repayment schedule using current interest
rates. No way this deal works without a lease where the city eats at least half the cost of the ballpark." Click here to read
the two articles.
July 5, 2010 An article in the July 1st Journal News
reported that "a 34-year-old local
businessman has been charged with forcing his way into a Kaufman Court home and
assaulting the couple living there. Jacob Wagschal, owner of JW Developers on Sunrise
Drive in Monsey, faces a hearing in Ramapo Justice Court on the morning of July 15.
An argument over a parking issue apparently caused a confrontation between Wagschal
and a family living on Kaufman Court, according to a spokesman for the police department.
The male homeowner told police that Wagschal was carrying a cane and hit him in the face, and then punched him
several times in the chest." Wagschal is familiar to our readers as one of the individuals connected with the fraudulent
signs put up the night before a recent election. These signs directed Preserve Ramapo supporters to vote on the line
containing the St. Lawrence slate. (More)
June 24, 2010 Late this morning, Preserve Ramapo Chairman Robert
Rhodes and Rockland County Legislator Joseph Meyers delivered four
volumes of petitions with 2,139 signatures from those in Ramapo who
want the voters to decide whether $16.5 million in new loans to build a baseball park should be co-signed by
the already stressed taxpayers. (More)
Jim Bouton on Building New Baseball Stadiums
people, besides team owners, who want new stadiums are
politicians, lawyers, and the
media. Politicos like to swagger around a palace—and stadiums are the modern palaces—the bigger
the better, especially for mayors suffering from stadium envy. They like to watch games from the
owner's box in full view of the TV cameras and hang out in the clubhouse with the players. This is
in addition to the usual perks, graft, kickbacks, and patronage that accrue to politicians on big
construction projects." (Click here for More from the ex-Yankee All-Star)
May 5, 2010
Yesterday, Preserve Ramapo filed a formal
complaint with the New York State Inspector General.
At the same time, the organization requested a thorough
investigation of what it considered to be a fraudulent
application for urban renewal status for the wooded site
next to the Fire Training Center in Pomona.
Applicable sanctions were also sought by the group.
(Complete story with full text of the complaint
May 2, 2010 "Patsy
Wooters has spent more than a decade raising awareness about
the environmental issues confronting Rockland County. From threats to drinking water
and air quality to concerns about overdevelopment and habitat loss, Wooters has
worked to explain how these issues fit into everyday life." Story here.
A Risky $26million Gamble with 5 to 1 odds-Against
and There’s No Business Plan
April 28, 2010 Last week,
Preserve Ramapo received a stack of 120 pages, documents and notes,
from the Ramapo Town Clerk’s Office. We had submitted a Freedom of Information Act request
for two things: the business plan for Supervisor St. Lawrence’s $26m baseball park (Project Grand Slam)
and a list of the investors he said he had lined up for the project. What we got back was an assortment
of unrelated papers pulled from a number of areas, but there was no document that purported to be or
even vaguely resembled a business plan, and there were no investors. (More)
April 15, 2005 Daniel Friedman was appointed to the Ramapo
Town Board at last night's board meeting. Friedman will take
the place of Ed Friedman who passed away on March 12. Board
members St. Lawrence, Hunter, Withers, and Ullman voted to
seat the 24-year-old to serve out the remainder of Ed Friedman's
April 8, 2010In the latest legal milestone in the ongoing odyssey
April 5, 2010
Over this past weekend, the
PreserveRamapo.org website crossed a
threshold the average blog doesn't reach. Since it's launch on May 30,
April 1, 2010 From the Journal News "Firefighters
had to knock down a locked door in order to
evacuate teenage boys from a fire in a yeshiva Thursday after the students living in the dormitory
were unable to get out because several exits had been padlocked, said Kim Weppler, chief of the
Hillcrest Fire Company. Weppler said that when firefighters arrived, some of the estimated 30
teenage boys living in the dorm had escaped the building, but that about 20 others had been unable
to evacuate because several of the exits had been padlocked or dead-bolted. To gain access to the
rest of the building and search for additional students, Hillcrest firefighters had to pry open a door
in the common hall, which separates the school from the dormitory, and cut a padlock on a gate in a
common fire exit stairwell, Weppler said. 'Deadbolts, padlocks or any other devices used to chain a
fire exit are barbaric,' he said. 'Especially when people are occupying the space within.'" Full story
on Journal News site here.
March 28, 2010 The Commissioner of the
Independent Can-Am League, Christopher St. Lawrence's
partner in the proposed $25million baseball park in Ramapo, claimed in a Community View in The
Journal News: " In every market where our leagues have built new facilities, the municipalities
have enjoyed great success and seen strong positive economic benefits. I hope this helps clear up some of
the discussion, and I am sure that a new stadium with Can-Am baseball will be providing great baseball
entertainment for decades to come in Rockland County." Actually, the Can-Am League has fielded seven teams
in New York State and all seven have gone belly-up and/or moved out. Of the 22 modern franchises, this League has
seen 16 fail. We also look at the Commissioner's most famous team, the Durham Bulls, and what happened when he
tried to get the town of Durham to build a stadium for that team. (More)
Community View in Journal News March 23, 2010
There are problems with the facts in
Supervisor St. Lawrence’s Community View, "Baseball will lift up
" He says a formal business plan for the $25.5 million project does exist. On Feb. 17, Preserve Ramapo submitted
a Freedom Of Information Act (FOIA) request for all documents, notes and communications concerning this project.
A month later, Tuesday, March 16, we were given 48 pages and a large technical drawing. No business plan—in fact,
no documents or papers that might be part of a business plan, were included. Either the Town is illegally
withholding information in violation of State law, or Mr. St. Lawrence is violating the public trust with a serious
lack of candor. (More)
The Economics of the Baseball Field Proposal
March 19, 2010
Before investing $25.5 million in a baseball stadium and team, you would
think the first steps
taken by the Town of Ramapo would include a serious business plan. Estimate the costs, the risks, the benefits,
ROI, and the overall suitability of the project for the community. There’s no evidence that this has been done,
and the public has been generally stonewalled in its attempt to get any information about the project beyond what
Christopher St. Lawrence chooses to feed to the newspaper and Channel 12. None of this seems to bother the Supervisor.
But then again, he’s not playing with his own money—he’s using house money, or more precisely, the taxes you pay
on your house—that money. And the obligation will be yours and your kids’ until the year 2040. Click here for an
analysis of the economic liabilities of this project, including information about the league he is looking to partner with.
Last time, he launched a threatening
against a parent who criticized the selection
of the costly counsel under investigation by
the State's Comptroller. That performance
looked like this. Story and video here.
A pattern is emerging. One that seems
to indicate serious issues with the First Amendment and
anger management. Reasoned discourse? A measured professional demeanor? Don't get your hopes up.
A student wrote to us, concerned that the characterization of the confrontation presented in the Journal
article didn't tell the complete story. He sent the video, so those who weren't present could hear the
exchange. Click here to view what happened.
March 7, 2010 Evan Weiner, a New
York City-based journalist and speaker,
is recognized as a global expert on the business of sports. He was presented
with the United States Sports Academy's first ever Distinguished Service
Award for Journalism in 2003 in Mobile, Alabama. This morning on the
www.examiner.com website he posted an analysis of the St. Lawrence
initiative to borrow $25 to $30million to build a stadium and bring a
minor league baseball team to Ramapo. "If that happens," Weiner writes,
"Ramapo will join a league [CanAm Leage] that is more of a floating crap game
than a stable organized entity." Read the entire analysis here.
February 12, 2010
When the Village of Airmont replaced the Town
Highway services at a savings of $86,000 a year the only question was how well
the new contractor would do. Phone calls made yesterday to a number of Airmont
residents unanimously rated the new snow removal contractor as "very good" to
"excellent" with most using "excellent" as their preferred descriptive.
The pretreatment before the snow began to fall around midnight striped
the roads, and by 6am the morning after the day-long 14-inch snowfall, the roads
were black throughout Airmont. Story here.
February 7, 2010 "The New York State
Department of Conservation decision authorizing the construction of
Lake DeForest states, "This Commission has the full power to see that this project is operated solely for the
benefit of the citizens of Rockland County. The only benefit to the Hackensack Water Company (United Water
New Jersey) and the people of New Jersey is the incidental benefit of a regulated flow in the river." Even during
periods of drought between 1991 through 2007, the United States Geological Survey's Hackensack River West
Nyack monitoring station recorded an average flow of approximately 15 million gallons per day. As a result, the
average flow to New Jersey exceeded the amount permitted by the DEC by more than 7 million gallons per day." (More)
Sits on East Ramapo School Board and
Spring Valley Zoning Board
February 5, 2010 The owner of the house at 38 N. Myrtle Avenue
in Spring Valley has
been cited numerous times within the last four months, and along with the health and
safety violations, the Rockland County Dept. of Health has described the home as an
illegal boarding house. Of the many violations throughout the building, it was noted by
the inspectors that, "Some of these violations are considered to be life-threatening."
The owner of 38 N. Myrtle is Eliyahu Solomon, a school board and Spring Valley zoning
board member. Full story here.
January 28, 2010 "How could Congress have passed legislation
that so dramatically harmed the interests
of so many of its constituents? There are two main explanations.
First, Congress did not bother to familiarize itself with the constitutional rules surrounding land
use. There is no evidence in the legislative history that any member (or staffer) grasped that land
use law that has been the domain of the states and local governments since the Framing. They
simply did not understand that this attempt to federalize local land use law was a revolution in
the making. Nor is there any evidence of even a modicum of knowledge of the purposes and
principles underlying zoning and planning, or how such legal rules aid and protect private
Second, the record on RLUIPA was unbalanced, and thus distorted. The only groups permitted to
testify regarding the bill were religious groups, and less than a handful of constitutional scholars,
including myself. The very group most affected by the bill - residential homeowners - was
conspicuously absent." Read the entire article by Constitutional Law Expert Marci Hamilton here.
January 26, 2010
Three hundred Ramapo residents showed up at the special meeting of the Town Board last night, and 2,000 more
had emailed board member Fran Hunter asking her to vote against the high-density building on Patrick Farm. Owner
Yekiel Lebovits and his developer from Brooklyn, Abraham Moskovits, have applied to put 500 homes on the environmentally
sensitive property on Route 202 near the corner of Route 306. (More)
January 24, 2010 Friday morning,
Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence
explained to the audience of a weekly radio show that he would not stand
in the way of Yekiel Lebovits or Scenic Development of Monsey if their
intentions include the creation of a new high-density religious community on the Patrick Farm property. Click
here for recent aerial views of the density in two other Orthodox communities in Ramapo. This promise contrasts
starkly with his active opposition to the petitions from the residents of Ladentown when they applied for the
same thing. Or the several petitions for single-district elections which he fought in court.
January 22, 2010
Baile Glauber had been Ramapo’s first Orthodox
until yesterday. Actually, she was a probationary officer, and despite the strong personal
support of Christopher St. Lawrence, when Glauber’s probationary period was to end in
February, Police Chief Peter Brower planned to recommend that she not be hired on
as a regular on the force. (More)
January 15, 2010 Read the full text of the resolution here.
January 13, 2010 A most informative
informational meeting was held before the Clarkstown Town Board
last night. The most interesting information was provided by a well-informed and persistent audience
that would not accept the evasive answers provided by executives and engineers representing United Water. (More)
January 12, 2009 Washington, D.C.—"The Haverstraw Water Supply
Project, a proposed
desalination plant in Rockland County, New York, could generate as much as $5 million in annual
profits for United Water New York, but community members would ultimately pay the price
in the form of increased water rates, finds a new report released today by the national consumer advocacy
group Food & Water Watch. Entitled Not Worth It’s Salt: How Rockland County Could End Up Paying for an
Unnecessary Desalination Plant, the report recommends approaches to meeting the area’s water needs that
include conservation, improving existing water infrastructure, and better stormwater management and land use
planning, among others." Read full text of this press release with link to the full study by Food & Water Watch here.
December 29, 2009 "A federal judge has ordered a New Square
kosher poultry slaughterhouse padlocked
for unsanitary conditions that pose a health risk to the community. During an April visit to the plant, federal
investigators said they found poultry residue on walls, light fixtures, and the manager's office. Employee restrooms
had no soap or hand sanitizer while rubbish and foul-smelling pools of water were found outside the plant, according
to court papers federal authorities filed asking for the temporary restraining order against the plant." Story here.
December 28, 2009 "A kosher poultry slaughterhouse and processing
plant in New Square has been
selling uninspected meat since 2002 and continues to operate under unsanitary conditions, federal
prosecutors said. The U.S. Attorney's Office is seeking a temporary restraining order and a preliminary
injunction against New Square Meats, which is seeking an expanded facility, for violating federal law.
The case will be heard at 10 a.m. tomorrow in federal court in White Plains. 'The defendants ... have
demonstrated a brazen disregard for the health and welfare of the consumers of its poultry products,'
the U.S. Attorney wrote in a court document. It went on to state the defendants have 'repeatedly flouted' the
law and ignored requests by federal investigators to provide necessary records." Story here.
December 11, 2009 Two recent
appointments in Spring Valley
seem to prove that if you want to hide your qualifications,
or lack of qualifications, or you’d just rather avoid any
conversation at all about your life experience and professional
track record, the new Jasmin administration could have
a place for you. (Story here)
New York Times: Board's Hiring Sets Off a School War
December 7, 2009 "Ground
zero for now is the schools, where roughly 70 percent of the students
black and Hispanic, and where Hasidic and other Orthodox Jews, who almost always send their children
to private yeshivas, control six of the nine seats on the school board." Read Times' article here.
Continues to Spin
in East Ramapo
Board Meeting Features Long, Angry Public Monologue
D'Agostino Erupts at Parent's Criticism
December 3, 2009 It’s gotten to the point
where you need a scorecard to see who’s the legal
counsel today for the East Ramapo School District,
so here’s a current lineup of who’s in and
who’s on the bench. Also we have Albert D'Agostino's
first legal action--he threatens a parent with, "I will
have you in court by Friday." The parent had expressed the opinion that the decision to hire D'Agostino "stinks."
Complete story (here).
November 24, 2009It was well past midnight (12:42) when the
October 29, 2009 In his
newspaper Mendel Hoffman announced, "We now have to deal with
over 10,000 people who sent a strong message: We don't want Jews to live and expand in
Ramapo. Their concern is our existence." During this year's primary elections some anonymous
writer posted the following on synagogues in the Monsey area: "These dangerous activists proclaim
that the Town should go back to the times when there was the limit on how much we can
expand, and that shall never be!" The two writers were obviously working on behalf of the
St. Lawrence campaign, and the distrust and anger they fomented had a purpose. Story here.
October 18, 2009 "The
leadership of New Square has decided that it wants to build a huge
chicken slaughterhouse off
Route 45, directly opposite single-family homes and perhaps only a hundred yards from apartment houses occupied by
New Square's own residents. The role played by Rockland's political leaders in this whole affair can only be described
as dreadful. To put it simply, it appears that our county's entire political leadership has turned its back on our residents
for the continued political support of the very small group of individuals who will deliver New Square's bullet vote to
properly compliant politicians." Read the complete text of Robert Rhodes Community View here.
October 17, 2000 For photo coverage of the rally in New
against the poultry slaughterhouse, click here.
"This should not be allowed in a
residential neighborhood. We cannot let this stand. If Perdue wanted
a chicken plant in Pearl River, we'd stop that, too."
Ken Zebrowski: "We have to work together to stop this." Zebrowski recently introduced legislation to prohibit municipalities
from granting any approvals for the construction or operation of a slaughterhouse that is within 1,500 feet of a residential area.
Joe Meyers: Legislator Meyers introduced a resolution in the county Legislature calling on New Square to reject the proposal
and asking the state to withdraw the $1.62 million grant awarded for the project.
Ramapo Files Complaint with Attorney General
over DA's Failure to Investigate Voter Violations
October 2, 2009 This week, Preserve Ramapo filed a formal
complaint and requested an
investigation of the Rockland County District Attorney’s failure to investigate felony
violations of New York State Election Law at a New Square polling place. We also asked that
a second, independent investigation look at the possibility of election fraud based on a
political relationship between the office or any individuals in the Office of the Rockland County District Attorney
and the officials of the Village of New Square. Both requests were sent to the Public Integrity Bureau of the New
York State Attorney General's Office in New York City. (Story here)
Rockland County has 5th highest property taxes in the United States
October 1, 2009 According to the American Community Survey,
which is based on US Census Bureau statistics,
in 2008, Rocklanders paid median property taxes of $8,430--up $895 from the year before. The median is the
middle number with half paying more and half less. The number for property taxes in all of New York
State is $3,622 and the median for the country is $1,897. Last year we were 6th highest, so we're edging our
way up toward the worst in the nation--definitely not good. Journal story here.
September 25, 2009 Because the proposed 50,000-square-foot
Route 45 in New Square could prove to be an environmental Chernobyl for homeowners
in New Hempstead, Spring Valley and Clarkstown, there has been a political backlash
rising up from the grass roots. Two letters today in The Journal News accuse
politicians of serving the bloc vote with no regard for consequences that will
end up being paid by local residents. Read "Mad at Sen. Morahan for chicken plant
support" and "Apathy only makes the bloc vote stronger" here.
Slaughterhouse on Main Street--
An Environmental Catastrophe
September 9, 2009 The proposed 50,730-square-foot poultry
slaughterhouse in New Square would not only create the type of air
pollution called "brown air" throughout the surrounding neighborhoods,
it would also have a disastrous impact on the supply of potable water.
Slaughterhouses like these also negatively impact waste-water systems,
storm and sewer, and this one is to be built on one of the more traveled
roads (Route 45) in Ramapo. The firestorm created by the plan is a
reaction to the size, the location, and the politics of the decision—the
last of which has a particularly offensive odor. Full story here.
September 11, 2009 "The recent $1.63 million "Restore New
York" grant ("State to give New Square $1.6M for chicken
slaughterhouse," Sept. 4) for a kosher chicken slaughterhouse in New Square is the last straw for this second-generation
Ramapo homeowner. How can this be allowed when we pay some of the highest property taxes in not only the state
but the country?" Full text of the letter here.
September 5, 2009
Rockland County Planning Department has recommended against the
proposal [the poultry
slaughterhouse in New Hempstead], as submitted by New Square. Planners found problems in the site plan, a variance
request and a special-permit request. Concerns ranged from lack of parking to the stress on New Square's notoriously
low water pressure. The county still has not been notified that the area was re-zoned for industrial use, something
that New Square Deputy Mayor Israel Spitzer says happened more than a year ago. There's also some fuzzy math - though
the state announcement hails the project, which it reported will be placed on a 7.8 acre lot, county documents show
the parcel for the slaughterhouse at 0.99 acres. The Empire State Development spokesperson said, '[There was ] a great
deal of support' from elected state officials." Read the full text of the editorial here.
September 4, 2009
"Following a $1.6
million state grant for a kosher chicken slaughterhouse in New
Supervisor Howard Phillips is asking the state attorney general to investigate the process by which municipalities are
chosen for awards of public money." Journal story here.
August 22, 2009
Baile Glauber's "nomination as a police officer was strongly
supported by Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence and the Town Board." Today,
The Journal News reported, "Ramapo's first ultra-Orthodox Jewish police officer
has filed a federal labor complaint accusing the town and some fellow officers of discriminating against her because
of her religious beliefs." Ms. Glauber had been given a work schedule that gave her the Sabbath and other religious days
off. "She said the department gave her a hard time about taking Jewish holidays off, but relented when her lawyer got
involved. She has been assigned to desk duty for months after complaining that she was injured." Journal story here.
August 14, 2009 Ramapo
Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence boasts proudly of
the $35 million dollars he has spent for “open space.” There are a few things you
should know about his “open-space” purchases that he will not tell you. (More)
August 7, 2009 Federal Judge Kenneth Karas of the U.S.
District Court of the Southern
St. Lawrence to Face Charges in Federal Court
for 1st Amendment Violations
August 4, 2009 The Ben Gilman Medical and Dental Clinic in
Spring Valley is
scheduled to reopen today. The building had been closed by the Board of Health,
The Journal News reported, because it had dead birds, animal droppings, and other
unsanitary conditions. Today, the news focus shifted to the Director Mendel Hoffman.
According to the Journal, "Hoffman was paid more than $556,000 in 2006 as director
of [a number of local nonprofits], many of which receive much of their budgets
from taxpayer funds, according to records." Full story here.
July 27, 2009
Last Friday, The Journal News
posted the Rockland
County Planners’ rejection of the proposed poultry slaughterhouse
on North Main Street in New Hempstead. They called the plant "an
incompatible, industrial use that should not be permitted alongside
residential properties." On the same Friday morning, Supervisor St.
Lawrence, on his WRCR local radio slot, said he would not oppose it,
and, in fact, he praised the project as economically advantageous
and state-of-the-art, as well. He virtually guaranteed that there
would be no brown-air problems on Main Street from this 50,730-square-foot factory. (Story here)
July 13, 2009 We have
learned from Republican friends that the petitions
returned to the Ramapo Republican Committee have included shredded candidate petitions as well as some
that were just torn up, stuffed into an envelope and returned. (More)
July 6, 2009
"In Ramapo, land-use
issues are about more than traffic, sewer and water use. A
community's needs for housing and schools has rubbed against a woodsy, single-family home, suburban culture.
Overdevelopment angst is often fed by the town's willingness to downzone, even in the densest areas, and the
planning and zoning boards' perceived overflexibility for developers seeking more building on less land. County planners
have consistently warned of the stress overdevelopment throughout Ramapo puts on the county's infrastructure. Frequently
criticized is downzoning in the Monsey area that allows six-family structures to replace single-family homes. Town officials
have said that it is better to accommodate a rapidly growing population, rather than create onerous zoning laws that beg
for illegal development." Read the full editorial here.
July 1, 2009
"Two villages in Ramapo
- New Square and Kaser - are the fastest- growing
municipalities in the Lower Hudson Valley, according to newly released data from the
Census Bureau. Between 2000 and 2008, New Square grew 40 percent, while Kaser's
population grew 30 percent, according to the data. The population of New Square was
6,461 in 2008. In Kaser, it was 4,315. New Square ranks fourth in the state, behind
Brookville, Romulus and Kiryas Joel. Kaser ranks ninth." Tables of the new data here.
June 30, 2009 "New Square
is considering a plan
to allow a business to build a large poultry
slaughterhouse on Route 45 across the street from New Hempstead. The proposed
50,730-square-foot facility would be built in a new industrial park at the intersection with
Rovitz Place, according to documents. (More)
June 22, 2009 Supervisor
Christopher St. Lawrence has filed a lawsuit against
the candidates running against him in the September 15 primary. Bruce Levine,
Veronica Boesch, and Rod Lustin were served with legal notice that Mr. St.
Lawrence is highly incensed over their characterization of his administration as
corrupt. In this piece we take a look at an abbreviated list of some of the "gifts"
this administration has offered all of us, beyond even the invention of a new kind
of zoning called Adult Student Housing, and in addition to that colorful building
inspector driving around with an envelope stuffed with cash alongside the pot in the
glove compartment of his town vehicle. (Story here)
June 20, 2009
"The fates of two controversial plans to
build yeshivas in residential neighborhoods were questionable
despite decisions this week by the Zoning Board of Appeals. The first soundly rejected Bobover Yeshiva of Monsey's
plan for a school to replace an illegal one it operates on Route 306." Story here.
June 18, 2009 After
one-and-a-half hours of public testimony, the
request for zone changes needed to permit the building
of a school for 250 students on two acres on Route 306 failed by a
four to one majority vote. The Town Hall meeting room was packed
with an audience that spilled out into the hallway. The crowd erupted
with the announcement of the denied approval. (More)
June 11, 2009 What do
you do when you are
faced with the first difficult primary challenge
of your career, and your bloc might not be able
to pull your bacon out of the fire? Well, for
Christopher St. Lawrence, the answer was obvious--
high-tail it over to the opposition. Send enough of
your Monsey base over to the opposition party's
convention, and if you can't get your own party
line, steal theirs. And what about loyalty to your
own party? Forget it--no place for that when it's your
own fat you smell in the pan. Republican candidate
Christopher St. Lawrence will soon be seeking your
endorsement on the Republican Party Line. Sounds
odd doesn't it, especially when you think here's a
guy who never misses an opportunity to remind you
that, as a kid, he spent hours licking envelopes
working on his father's campaigns. (Read the complete story here.)
June 10, 2009 After receiving the legal
determination from a state Board of Elections Enforcement
Counsel, a Preserve Ramapo representative met with a detective from the Rockland County District
Attorney's Office and requested that the department complete a full investigation of two events in
recent elections. In the 2005 Supervisor's race, poll workers at a New Square location handed out cards
that promised a gift to those who had come to vote. In the September Primary Election in 2006, ice-cream
making machines were promised to voters in Monsey. Both acts constitute felony violations of the State
Election Law Section 17-142. The Journal News learned yesterday that the District Attorney is now
actively investigating the apparent felony in the Monsey election. Complete story here.
June 5, 2009
The flyer sent out to all residents in
proclaiming Ramapo as the safest place in the
country is a fraud. In fact, it is one of the more
outrageous examples of marketing fiction to belch
out of the St. Lawrence smoke machine. This piece,
though, goes beyond the usual attempts to dupe the
public. It, in fact, places the academic reputation
of a publisher at risk, and, worse, it portrays the
FBI as an organization that doesn’t have a clue when
it comes to crime statistics. (More)
May 21, 2009
"Marci A. Hamilton, attorney for Pomona and an
expert on the federal Religious
Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, known as RLUIPA, presented the village's case first, arguing
that Pomona has never received an application from the developer on the project, so the village
officials and residents didn't know what Tartikov really wanted to build on the site. Congregation
Rabbinical College of Tartikov sued the village in July 2007, arguing that Pomona's land-use regulation
and conduct prohibited it from building and operating the college and housing for students on a 130-acre
site off routes 202 and 306." The judge's decision is expected in 6 to 12 months. Read story here. See
draft of the Tartikov original plans here.
May 10, 2009 Members of the Monsey
community expressed their criticism of the illegal
slaughtering of a calf at the Bobover school on Route 306. Rabbi David Eidensohn
said, "This was not a religious act, it was an act of a fool." "Rabbi Moses David Tendler of
Community Synagogue of Monsey, a professor of medical ethics and biology at Yeshiva University
as well as an expert on Talmudic law, said the group's slaughter of a cow showed a disregard for
laws as well as the group's failure to understand American society. "They are ignorant of social mores,"
he said. "They don't know what is right and proper in an American community."
In an editorial in Saturday's paper titled "No More Breaks for Yeshiva Bobover," The Journal News
editors wrote: "On May 14, the Ramapo Zoning Board of Appeals should not give an inch on Yeshiva
Bobover's continuing dispute with the town over variances to allow the construction of a building on the
property to serve 250 students. In recent years, Ramapo has allowed organizations, often private schools,
to continue to operate even if they are out of compliance with codes. Sometimes, this has resulted in
good compliance with local codes and general cooperation. Other times, the violations pile up as town
regulations are repeatedly ignored. Guess which pattern fits here?"
Dramatically absent from this general discussion are the town leaders--Supervisor St. Lawrence, Inspectors, and the
Boards responsible for preventing illegal schools like Bobover, not looking the other way for years.
Read: Jewish leaders, others condemn cow slaughter in Ramapo here,
No More Breaks for Yeshiva Bobover here.
April 26, 2009 A New York
Times reporter looks at the situation
in the East Ramapo School District. He compares Ramapo and
Lawrence, Long Island. "In both cases, the boards voted to close one of the local schools.
In both cases, one reason given is declining enrollments because so many local families now
send their children to yeshivas. In both cases, the decision was made by boards dominated
by Orthodox Jews who are running the public schools but don’t send their own children to them."
The Times' suburban reporter also discusses the recent attempt to stack the board. "It gained a
measure of acrimony a year ago when two Orthodox school board members dropped out of
the race a week before the election, in effect giving their seats to two other Orthodox
candidates, one of whom never campaigned, never supplied information for a candidate
questionnaire and never showed up at candidate's forums." More
11,2009 The outrage over
the disputed transfer of a 76-year-old woman's home for $40,000
made its way from the LoHud blogs to Saturday's editorial page. Many are calling for a criminal
investigation over the proceedings. With the RICO statute as the basis for the lawsuit against Gershon
Alexander ("purchaser") and Ryan Karben ("attorney who was chosen to look after the woman's
best interests at the closing") there will, no doubt, be an investigation. Many would prefer that the
DA's office take a look also. Our cursory look at the numbers put the Ramapo Supervisor St. Lawrence
in bed with another of Gershon Alexander's companies, Puddingstone in North Haledon, N.J. Read
the most recent update "Congers Woman's belongings trucked from disputed house" here. At the
bottom of the article are the comments and questions from the public. Read about St. Lawrence's
involvement with Gershon Alexander here.
April 9, 2009
"The town has been denied a chance to appeal a
court ruling that gave four villages
the right to sue it over the town's zoning for adult-student housing. The Court of Appeals, the
state's highest court, preferred instead to allow the villages' case to proceed. Chestnut Ridge,
Montebello, Pomona and Wesley Hills launched the lawsuit in 2004, charging that Ramapo hadn't
fully considered the environmental impacts of its zoning that permits dormitories and apartments
connected to schools." Full story here.
April 8, 2009 During the week that Christians celebrate
Easter and Jews celebrate Passover, in Congers, the
next callous phase of an alleged house theft played out.
“The belongings of a 76-year-old Congers woman
were hauled away from her home this week in the
midst of a federal racketeering lawsuit charging she
was swindled out of the townhouse. Elizabeth
DiGiacomo's property, including all of her dying
husband's clothing, was trucked away before her
attorney could try to prevent it with a court order
against High Mountain Sanitation Haverstraw, a company based in Haledon, N.J. DiGiacomo lived
in the development since 1997. She was locked out of the 46 Leif Blvd. townhouse late last month.
She is now living with her son, John, in New City. Her husband is hospitalized with terminal brain
cancer.” (Journal News) At the center of this sordid affair is Gershon Alexander of New Hempstead,
Ryan Karben, two companies (High Mt. Sanitation and Puddingstone Group), and a trail that leads up
the side of a mountain of garbage with one other surprise standing at the top. (More)
April 8, 2009 What do you do
if you’re soon running for Town office
and your budget is swelling? You have to pass the increases to the
taxpayers, unless. . . Unless you can shove the costs off to the villages.
Charge the increases to them, and then credit the costs you’ve transferred
to them as accounts receivables on your books. Let the taxpayers pay the costs to the villages while
you’re "reducing" taxes at your level. It’s the kind of fraud the Town of Ramapo has been pulling for
years with highway department costs, and will once again claim as part of their “responsible stewardship”
in Ramapo. In addition, this year, Supervisor St. Lawrence has taken $200,000 out of the Chestnut Ridge
budget by prohibiting Interstate Waste Systems from operating in Chestnut Ridge. The company had to
suspend operations, and the village lost almost a quarter million in revenues. Read “Taxes could rise 8.9%
in Chestnut Ridge” here. Then read “Airmont looks to replace Town of Ramapo for road maintenance” here.
March 23, 2009In a Journal News feature article, Len Maniace
March 13, 2009 Ryan Karben and a
corporation that seems to have a fictitious address were named
in a lawsuit that accused the Monsey attorney "and a New Jersey-based company of misrepresenting
a real estate transaction in which a 76-year-old Congers woman says she lost the deed to her home."
The lawsuit was filed in federal court in White Plains under "civil provisions of the federal Racketeer
Influenced Corrupt Organizations Act, known as RICO." Read the Journal story, "Lawsuit: Woman
duped of deed to home" here, and for an interesting couple of degrees of separation from Supervisor
St. Lawrence read this interesting comment posted by a reader online at the LoHud site, and then
review the Preserve Ramapo story he refers to.
Feb. 22, 2009 Living in Ramapo,
you get used to some pretty bizarre situations. From
the Supervisor calling down at you twice an hour from one of those $30,000 clocks (eight in all
scattered around the town), to a judge (Scott Ugell) telling Ramapo Building Inspector Brian Brophy
not to worry about the dope and envelope of cash he was caught with--just consider it never
happened. Here's another one of those Ramapo moments that makes life so surreal here.
Feb. 20, 2009 "For decades,
volunteer firefighting officials in Rockland have
warned that one day their colleagues would die, trapped in an illegally converted
apartment or condo, running into rooms without windows or walls blocking what they
expected would be an escape route. So many single-family homes have been altered into
two, four and even six apartments that the officials were certain tragedy would someday
strike. It was just a matter of when and where." Read the Journal News editorial here, and
then read "Hillcrest Volunteers Want Out of New Square" here.
Jan. 27, 2009 Last Friday,
of Nyack passed away at the age of 84
after a short illness. From early adulthood to
the present, Irv dedicated himself to the
defense of the civil rights guaranteed to all
while fighting inequalities from the trial of the
Trenton Six in 1949 to the current unfair tax
burden on the residents of Spring Valley.
December 11, 2008 The court case had
reached jury selection when Ryan Karben
pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of driving while impaired by alcohol. He was
given a two-day jail sentence and a fine. Taken to the Rockland County Jail last
night at about 10pm, he was reported released by 8 am this morning. "His attorney,
Kenneth Gribetz, said that under the law, people who serve a portion of a day receive
credit for the entire day. 'There was no special treatment given to him,' Gribetz said.
'He's fully served. He's completed his sentence.' Prosecutor Kevin Gilleece said this morning
that he was not aware Karben had gotten out." Journal story here.
October 27, 2008
For years, Ramapo Supervisor
Christopher St. Lawrence and town attorney Michael
Klein have assured us that the open space he has been
buying will never be developed. Preserve Ramapo has suggested that St. Lawrence is not to
be trusted and asked why he has refused to dedicate this property as parkland, a simple process
requiring only a formal resolution by the Ramapo Town Board. (More)
September 16, 2008 First there
was the situation where "a young Ramapo officer
was publicly excoriated by Town Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence for ordering
a Hasidic Jewish woman, being booked on a fraud charge, to take off her wig." What
followed was a St. Lawrence public apology to the officer. Now, "Ramapo Officer
Ernst Tenemille, who has sought a work schedule that would permit him to observe
his Sabbath as a Seventh-Day Adventist, has found his request stalled on technicalities.
Now he faces more paperwork and a Police Commission hearing to explain his needs.
None of that happened when Ramapo's first Orthodox police officer earlier this year
was granted Friday night through Saturday off, to accommodate her religious obligations."
A Journal editorial asks, "Why the different treatment?" Full text here.
Two homes replaced with 42, political
fraud, and the machine
boss makes promises to his base--connecting the dots.
Sept. 2, 2008 The notice for the public hearing first appeared
on West Central Avenue on a cold, rainy Thursday in February.
In fact, it was February 14, Valentine’s Day. The laminated
12 by 18-inch signs were bound to trees with blue tape. What
was unusual about these notices was the middle section below the
heading: VARIANCE REQUESTED OR OTHER REASONS FOR
HEARING. A large block of text, 27 lines, followed, itemizing
not just a single variance, but a list of 50 variances. The list
was too long for anyone to stand in the cold rain and read all
the way through, in fact, it was almost too long to fit on the large
poster. Fifty variances—there was no way any board would allow
that many violations of the zoning rules, no way. (More)
August 28, 2008 Preserve Ramapo warned
last year that St. Lawrence and his board had formally dedicated only
one of the open space properties, the one that surrounds St. Lawrence's
home, and that all the rest were vulnerable and could be sold to
developers. At the time, St. Lawrence and his attorney Michael Klein
were "shocked and dismayed" at the accusation. St. Lawrence said
of our warning, "This is utter nonsense." Less than one year later, the
two have overcome their indignation and entered into a contract with
developer Jeffrey Goldstein to sell item number 16 on their list of "Open Space, Parkland and Historic
Preservation"--the Tilcon Quarry. Goldstein wants to build 440 condos on the property that had been gifted to the
people of Ramapo by Tilcon. Wednesday morning, Robert Rhodes, Chairman of Preserve Ramapo, was joined
by Legislator Joseph Meyers and attorney James Hyer as they filed a Supreme Court lawsuit to prevent the sale of
the open space property. More.
August 22, 2008 "Responsible
be based on real information, not propaganda
provided by interested parties. Unfortunately,
United Water, working closely with the Rockland
Business Association, is doing its best to mislead
the citizens of Rockland." Read the full text of
Robert Rhodes' letter to The Journal News
You can also read Rhodes' July Testimony at
the Public Hearing on the Proposed United Water
Experimental Treatment Plant.
August 8, 2008 The Journal
News reports today that the
supervisor and Town Board are being sued in federal
court by a former employee charging that he was
disciplined for refusing to post a four-foot by eight-foot
St. Lawrence campaign sign on his lawn. Tim Cronin's
lawyer explained, "We're suing over the violation of his
First Amendment right to take whatever position he wanted in a political
race." We reported on this in an extensive story titled "The Awful Price of
Independence in Ramapo." You can read that story here, and check today's update
in the Journal here.
August 6, 2008
at a Suffern workshop
called to address a plan to put 496 condos on the
Tilcon Quarry site, the man who put the deal together
sat silent throughout the entire meeting. Ramapo Supervisor
St. Lawrence had no comments. He had sold the open space
property that had been given to the people of Ramapo by Tilcon to one of his biggest donors—the
developer Jeffrey Goldstein. Suffern had not been part of the negotiations—our sources say the
mayor of Suffern had not even been told about the deal—and last night the Supervisor adopted a
godfather-like demeanor throughout the entire proceeding. (More)
August 1, 2008 It’s not just a dump,
it’s a Superfund
Cleanup Site. That puts it in the major leagues of
dangerous landfills. The N.Y. State Department of
Environmental Conservation will continue to monitor
the site for 20 more years to make sure poisonous
leachate doesn’t run into the groundwater. It’s 86
capped acres of fermenting garbage that has to be
vented so methane buildup doesn’t one day blow it all over the Torne Valley. And now it’s
being seriously considered as a future site for 650 living units. Once again, a really bad smell
leads back to Town Hall in the form of a damp money trail. (More)
July 12, 2008
"United Water New York's
proposal to build a reverse osmosis desalinization
and filtration plant to supply Rockland County with
drinking water from the Hudson River leaves many
with a bad taste in their mouths and concerns about
the quality of our drinking water, how the plant
will affect the ecosystem of the river, the
increased development it will bring on land - and at
what costs?" Read George Potanovic's Community
View here and please attend the public hearing Monday.
Photo George Potanovic, Jr.
July 10, 2008 "Gov.
David Paterson, Assembly Speaker Sheldon
Silver and former Senate Majority Leader Joseph Bruno agree
that property taxes are seriously threatening to drive homeowners
out of their houses. But they couldn't agree to do anything about it."
Read Irv Feiner's Community View here.
July 3, 2008 "We
believe this sale is illegal.
A municipality is not allowed to give gifts to
private parties. The fact that the developer is a generous contributor to St. Lawrence’s
election campaigns does not give him the right to accept gifts from the town of Ramapo."
The Chairman of Preserve Ramapo explained that they are in the process of researching
the sale and gathering documents for the action. (More)
June 19, 2008 Developers Yechiel and
Isaac Lebovits have submitted a
Draft Scoping Document that will be
reviewed by the Ramapo Town
Board in a public meeting scheduled for
Monday, June 23 at 6:30 at Ramapo Town
Hall on Route 59. The builders propose the
construction of 497 dwellings on the 207-acre historic site. The proposal includes
a map change of 61.3 acres now zoned for R-40 (one residence with 40,000 feet) to
MR-8 (multi-family housing with 8 units per acre). The village-size development is
expected to increase local population with numbers that could match the entire
population of the Village of Pomona as it exists today. The site is located over a
primary aquifer. Read The Journal News story here. A PDF of the 17-page scoping
document is available here.
June 18, 2008 On Monday evening, the
Ramapo Town Board
approved the sale of 65 acres in Suffern to one of the most
powerful developers in the area, Jeffrey Goldstein. At the center
of the deal was the man who brokered the sale, Supervisor
Christopher St. Lawrence. The land had been donated to the
people of Ramapo by Tilcon New York, and St. Lawrence
engineered the sale to Goldstein who plans to build a complex
of 440 condominiums on the Suffern site. (More)
May 29, 2008
On May 20, the day of the school board
elections, a dangerous precedent played out in full view
of the public, but it went by mainly unnoticed. A
candidate was granted a seat on the Board of Education
in East Ramapo. He was not elected, he was appointed
after hiding out throughout the campaign. More.
May 16, 2008
Some things you take for granted--like
elections. After the election, they count the votes, and before that,
the candidates campaign--showing up at grocery stores, on the inside
pages of the newspaper--taking hold of your sleeve wherever the
opportunity presents itself. But not this time in the School
Board Elections in East Ramapo. Two candidates have been out talking
and giving interviews, but two others just suddenly quit without any explanation, with only
one week to go before election day. And then there are the final two, who are
more like shadows with nothing more known about one of them than just his name,
and little more about the other. Should stealth candidates be tolerated in a system so
dependent on an informed electorate? More.
April 25, 2008 The
Journal News reported this morning
that "Ramapo Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence and
Terry Rice, the attorney for the developers, said in separate
interviews that adult-student housing would not be built on
the [Patrick Farm] property." More
April 15, 2008 Irv Feiner comments on the 10% jump in Spring Valley taxes. Read his letter here.
April 1, 2008
At a time when the
Fed is bailing out investment
banks to prevent a collapse of the system and
the state is looking for even more ways to cut a
budget already hanging in shreds, what are we
doing here in Ramapo to keep the tax wolves from
our doors? We’re buying time. Literally, buying time
with property tax money. Read the sad details
"What Savad chooses not to
mention is that an unintended byproduct of the law allows
developers to wield the RLUIPA sword as a weapon for economic gain." Read the full text
of this and two other letters responding to Savad's defense of the RLUIPA legislation here.
The new residential look for St. Lawrence's Ramapo photo©rosspilot.com
March 25, 2008
In a Community View in today’s Journal News,
Phil Tisi continues the water war between
United Water and Supervisor St. Lawrence’s office. This has been going on for a month or so now, and as
the two sides point and throw brickbats at each other, there is silence over the fact that they both have
actively conspired to destroy the water supply that has served this region for eons. (More)
"Even if found not guilty of driving while
intoxicated, former Assemblyman Ryan Karben could find
it difficult to return to office, voters and experts said yesterday." Read Laura Incalcaterra's full story
in the online Journal News here. Note--the Journal online articles often have interesting comments
sent in by readers. These appear at the bottom of the article, and they're worth checking out.
In early November we reported on the
issues with the Village of Montebello. He didn't pay those either
until they were handed over for collection by the County.
As Ramapo Town Supervisor it is extremely unseemly that he
would force the same collection agency to get involved in
his Ramapo Town property taxes, school taxes, police, and
library taxes. Actually, the last time he paid his town taxes on time was in 2002. Perhaps, like
the infamous Leona Helmsley, he thinks that "taxes are for the the little people." Our coverage
includes current tax bills and table of past delinquencies. Story here.
Irving Feiner, a political activist for
more than half a century, offers an analysis of the
calculating and undemocratic nature of Ramapo's Hasidic bloc vote. Using voting
statistics and trends, he considers the same question voiced in a Journal editorial,
"Are all the voters registered in the area living in the area?" Irv discusses five qualities
that set t